Skip to content

The well‑known benefactor

A collector turns to Zion

Edmond de Rothschild, born in Paris in 1845, was the youngest son of James and Betty. Unlike his two elder brothers, Alphonse and Gustave, he had little taste for banking. The Encyclopaedia Judaica describes him as devoted from his youth to “humanist and cultural matters, especially art”, and his collection of prints and drawings made him famous as a connoisseur and won him election to the Académie des Beaux-Arts of the Institut de France, which the Encyclopaedia calls the “Institut des Beaux Arts”. In 1877 he married Adelheid, the daughter of Wilhelm Carl Rothschild of Frankfurt, a man known for his strict religious observance and his reluctance to involve himself in the affairs of the Land of Israel.[1]

Edmond later wrote, in an autobiographical letter of 1928, “I have always been concerned with the future of Judaism.” But his public involvement in Jewish affairs began only after the pogroms in the Russian Empire in the early 1880s, when he joined the French committee to aid Jewish refugees and emigrants.[1][2] The same crisis that sent hundreds of thousands of Jews westwards also produced the Ḥibbat Zion movement, the “love of Zion”, whose members founded small farming villages in Ottoman Palestine. The first of them, Rishon le-Zion, “first in Zion”, south-east of Jaffa, was founded in 1882 by ten pioneers from Russia; Zammarin, on the southern spur of Mount Carmel, was founded the same year by Jews from Romania.[3][4][5]

The settlers knew almost nothing about farming in a dry Mediterranean climate, and within months they were in crisis. At Rishon le-Zion the wells failed and drinking water had to be fetched by camel cart from the agricultural school at Mikveh Israel. In 1883 the settlers sent an emissary, Yosef Feinberg, to seek help from the Jewish communities of Europe, and through the mediation of the chief rabbi of France, Zadoc Kahn, he reached Edmond. Edmond’s first gift, 25,000 francs, paid for a deep well.[4][1]

Ha-Nadiv ha-Yadu’a

From 1883 and 1884 Edmond took the first settlements under his patronage. He wished to remain anonymous, and so he was known by a cover name, Ha-Nadiv ha-Yadu’a, “the well-known benefactor”, which in the settlements and among the Ḥovevei Zion soon became better known than his real one. Contemporaries such as the writers Peretz Smolenskin and Moshe Leib Lilienblum testified that his aid saved the settlements from collapse.[1] He renamed Zammarin Zikhron Ya’akov, “the memory of Jacob”, in honour of his father James, whose Hebrew name was Ya’akov.[5]

His patronage took two forms. Some villages, including Rishon le-Zion, Zikhron Ya’akov, Rosh Pinnah and Ekron, which he founded, were wholly dependent on him; others, such as Petaḥ Tikvah, received partial support. He paid for every agricultural experiment conducted in the settlements by his French experts, and he became, in the Encyclopaedia Judaica’s phrase, “the major address for all problems in the yishuv, large and small alike”, so much so that he was called the “Father of the Yishuv”.[1] He himself insisted that what he was doing was “not merely philanthropy, but something entirely different”.

Ink-and-watercolour illustration of a vineyard on a gentle hillside with a village behind. A woman in a red headscarf holds a basket of dark grapes, an older man in a straw hat writes in a notebook, a boy and men load baskets and an Arab worker in a keffiyeh lifts grapes into a cart.
The grape harvest at one of the Jewish agricultural colonies in Ottoman Palestine in the 1890s, the settlements Edmond de Rothschild supported.

Edmond’s experts decided that the settlements should grow vines rather than grain. At Rishon le-Zion vine stocks brought from southern France at first proved unsuitable, and part of the vineyards was replaced by almond trees, but conditions improved after 1889, when he built the large Carmel Oriental wine cellars there. A second great cellar was built at Zikhron Ya’akov, where the vines were soon attacked by phylloxera and had to be replanted with American stock.[4][5] The wine industry of modern Israel grew from these beginnings. Rishon le-Zion also had the world’s first Hebrew-speaking kindergarten and elementary school, opened in the 1880s.[4]

The administrators and the settlers

Edmond’s support came through a bureaucracy, staffed largely by Frenchmen, which the settlers came to resent. The administrators often treated the farmers as hired hands rather than independent pioneers, and at Rishon le-Zion they stifled the settlers’ initiative. The antagonism reached the point of open revolt in several settlements, and the Encyclopaedia Judaica judges that “this type of bureaucratic patronage was the greatest problem of the Jewish settlements during a 20-year period”. Yet it also recognises that the administration introduced new crops and taught the first settlers how to farm the land.[1][4]

Edmond visited the country in 1887, 1893 and 1899, touring the settlements and demanding that the settlers work their own land, live modestly, speak Hebrew and respect religious tradition. He also ordered the purchase of land for new settlement, including in the Golan and the Hauran east of the Jordan.[1] The demand for “self-labour” was pointed, because many of the colonies came to rely on hired Arab workers from neighbouring villages, and relations between the new Jewish villages and their Arab neighbours, over land, labour and grazing, were already a source of friction in these years.[6] A study of Jewish and Arab labour in the First Aliyah notes that the baron, like the movement’s ideologues, wanted the colonies to employ Jewish workers, but that a Jewish labourer earned some 15 to 30 per cent more than an Arab one for a shorter working day.[6]

In the 1890s Edmond came into conflict with two very different critics. Theodor Herzl, the founder of political Zionism, read him his “Address to the Rothschild Family” and hoped to win him for the idea of a Jewish state secured by an international charter. They found no common ground. Edmond believed in “quiet” settlement, village by village, not in diplomacy and declarations.[1] The second conflict was with the Ḥovevei Zion of Russia, above all the essayist Aḥad Ha-Am, who denounced the patronage system for creating dependence. In May 1901 a delegation of Russian Ḥovevei Zion, including Aḥad Ha-Am, and representatives of the settlements visited Edmond to demand that the system end.[1]

By then Edmond had already acted. In 1900 he transferred his settlements to the supervision of the Jewish Colonization Association, the ICA, founded by the banker Baron Maurice de Hirsch, together with a grant of 14 million francs. The transfer covered about 250,000 dunams, some 62,500 acres, and twelve settlements, most of which, thanks to his support, were close to supporting themselves.[1]

Father of the Yishuv

Edmond’s involvement did not end in 1900. The settlements continued to expand under the ICA with his support, direct and indirect, and on his fourth visit, in 1914, he expressed satisfaction with what he had achieved. He helped develop the wine industry, co-sponsored the Palestine Electric Corporation, founded smaller industries and contributed to the founding of the Hebrew University. Gradually he drew closer to the Zionist Organisation. He told Chaim Weizmann, “Without me, the Zionists could have done nothing; but without the Zionists, my work would have been dead.”[1]

During the First World War Edmond helped prepare the ground for the Balfour Declaration, and he softened the opposition of assimilated French Jews to political Zionism. His son James served with the British army in Palestine at the end of the war and helped recruit volunteers for the Jewish battalions. In 1923–24 Edmond reorganised his work again, founding the Palestine Jewish Colonization Association, PICA, under James’s direction, with the aim of founding new settlements; the first of them, Binyamina, took its name from Edmond’s Hebrew name, Avraham Binyamin.[1] When the Jewish Agency was enlarged in 1929 he was chosen as its honorary president.

He died in Paris in 1934, a year before his wife. By then, the Encyclopaedia Judaica records, he had been involved in nearly 500,000 dunams of land and almost thirty settlements. Weizmann called him “the leading political Zionist of our generation”, and David Ben-Gurion said in 1954 that no one’s personal role in settlement could match his. In that year the remains of Edmond and Adelheid were brought to Israel and reinterred at Ramat ha-Nadiv, “the heights of the benefactor”, a memorial garden near Zikhron Ya’akov.[1][5] His name is now carried by streets, a boulevard in Tel Aviv and a whole town, Binyamina, as well as by the Israeli banknote, the 500 sheqalim note of 1982, that bore his portrait.[7]

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Rothschild