The communal establishment
By the second half of the nineteenth century the Rothschilds were not only the richest Jewish family in Europe but the leaders of organised Jewish life in London, Paris and Vienna. In Paris they sat on the Consistory of Paris and the Central Consistory of the Jews of France, the official bodies that Napoleon had created to govern French Judaism, and they ran the Jewish Charity Committee of Paris. James’s son Gustave was president of the Paris Consistory for more than forty years, and James gave the community the Rothschild Hospital, which still exists.[1] In London, Natty held the presidency of the United Synagogue, the federation of Ashkenazi congregations created by Act of Parliament in 1870, and was, as the Encyclopaedia Judaica puts it, “the effective lay head of Anglo-Jewry”.[1]
That position brought power and obligations. The Rothschilds were expected to fund the community’s institutions, to speak for it to governments and to set the tone of its religious life, and they did all three. Their Judaism was traditional in form and increasingly anglicised or Frenchified in style, and they used their influence to keep the communal establishment moderate, loyal and respectable. Critics, then and later, saw a self-appointed oligarchy; supporters saw a family that took its responsibilities seriously. Both pictures contain some truth.
The women of the family were at least as active as the men, though the histories written about the bank have often overlooked them. Miriam Rothschild, writing about her female ancestors, noted that large enterprises such as hospitals, waterworks, laboratories and the Rothschild dwellings “were generally left to the menfolk”, but that the wives took an interest in more than local matters and “worked tirelessly at ugly problems”. When Emma, Natty’s wife, came to Tring as a young bride, her account book recorded no fewer than four hundred charities, from church repairs and convalescent homes to carving classes and dancing lessons for village children.[2]
The Jews’ Free School and the East End
The family’s favourite cause in London was education. The Jews’ Free School in Spitalfields, which grew into one of the largest schools in the world, was, in the Encyclopaedia Judaica’s words, “a special interest of the family”. Lionel’s wife Charlotte was particularly concerned with it, and successive generations of Rothschilds paid for its buildings, sat on its committees and visited its classrooms.[1] Constance and Annie, the daughters of Lionel’s brother Anthony and his wife Louise, taught as girls in the village schools near their home and at the Jews’ Free School.[3]

From the early 1880s the East End changed. Tens of thousands of Jewish refugees and emigrants from the Russian Empire, fleeing poverty and the pogroms that followed the assassination of Alexander II in 1881, settled in Whitechapel and Spitalfields, crowding into some of the worst housing in London.[4] The Anglo-Jewish establishment responded with a mixture of charity, anxiety and control. It wanted to relieve the newcomers’ poverty and also to anglicise them quickly, and in some cases to discourage further immigration, for fear that a visible, foreign-speaking Jewish working class would provoke hostility towards all Jews.
Natty’s answer to the housing crisis was characteristic. A report commissioned by the United Synagogue in 1884 recommended that the newcomers be helped to adapt to English life and be given decent, healthy homes, which it believed would “constitute the greatest of all available means for improving the condition, physical, moral and social of the Jewish poor”. Days after the United Synagogue approved the report, the Four Per Cent Industrial Dwellings Company was formed at the Rothschild bank in the City, with Natty at its head. Investors were offered a dividend of four per cent a year on 1,600 shares of £25 each, less than other housing schemes promised, so that rents could be held at no more than five shillings a week. Decent housing was to be a sound investment rather than pure charity.[5]
The company’s first block, the Charlotte de Rothschild Dwellings in Flower and Dean Street, Spitalfields, was built in 1886–87 in what one observer had called “the foulest and most dangerous street in the whole metropolis”. It offered two-room flats with shared kitchens and lavatories, sculleries, balconies and attic workshops, luxuries unknown in the slums around it. The waiting list was always long. By 1899 the company had housed more than four thousand people, and the death rate in its buildings was a third of the Whitechapel average. It later built in Hackney, Stoke Newington and Camberwell, and survives today, renamed in 1952, as the Industrial Dwellings Society, a housing association with around 1,500 homes.[5] The first block has been demolished, but several later ones still stand.
Hospitals, a school in Jerusalem and the protection of women
Other Rothschild foundations were more personal. Ferdinand de Rothschild, of the Vienna branch, married Natty’s sister Evelina in 1865. She died in childbirth the following year, and Ferdinand commemorated her in the Evelina Hospital for Sick Children, which he founded in 1869 and paid for entirely, in one of the poorest parts of Southwark; it still bears her name.[6] He also founded the Evelina de Rothschild School for girls in Jerusalem.[1] Ferdinand became a British subject and a member of Parliament, and his great house at Waddesdon in Buckinghamshire is the subject of a later chapter.
The most remarkable campaigner of the family in this period was a woman. Constance de Rothschild, born in 1843, married the Liberal politician Cyril Flower, later Lord Battersea, in 1877. The Jewish Women’s Archive describes her as active in English philanthropy, in the temperance movement, in the campaign for women’s suffrage and in prison reform; she became a government-appointed member of the board of Aylesbury women’s prison.[3]
In 1885 she founded the organisation that became the Jewish Association for the Protection of Girls and Women. Its purpose was to protect young Jewish immigrant women from sex traffickers, many of whom used London as a staging post on the route from Eastern Europe to South America, and to help women who wanted to leave prostitution. Constance had heard of Jewish women who could find no refuge except in Christian missions, which they feared would try to convert them. To create the association she had to overcome the resistance of a communal leadership that was reluctant to admit that Jewish prostitution existed at all, for fear of feeding antisemitic stereotypes.[3][7]
The association met newly arrived women at the docks and railway stations, ran boarding homes and offered training for employment. Over time it drew in prominent Anglo-Jewish families, among them the Rothschilds and the Montefiores, with Claude Montefiore, the founder of Liberal Judaism, as chairman, and after the First World War it worked with the League of Nations against international trafficking. It lasted until 1947.[7] Constance also persuaded upper- and middle-class Anglo-Jewish women to join the National Union of Women Workers and to found organisations of their own, such as the Union of Jewish Women, and the Jewish Women’s Archive credits her with helping to lay the foundations of a distinctively Jewish women’s movement in England.[3]
Defenders abroad
The family’s communal role did not end at the borders of Britain and France. Since the Damascus affair of 1840, Jews in danger abroad had looked to the Rothschilds for help, and the London and Paris houses were drawn into one crisis after another, from the persecution of the Jews of Romania to the pogroms in the Russian Empire. Their tools were the ones they had always used: access to ministers, private letters to foreign governments, and the knowledge that a state which mistreated its Jews might find it harder to borrow money in London and Paris.[1][8]
John Cooper’s study of Natty, whom he calls “the last of the shtadlanim”, the intercessors who pleaded with rulers on behalf of Jewish communities, shows how the work was done. Most of Natty’s interventions concerned Russian Jewry, but in 1893 the Foreign Office wrote to tell him that, after his representations, the Sultan of Morocco had reprimanded a governor accused of mistreating the Jews of Marrakesh, and in 1902 he took up the case of Romanian Jewish artisans threatened by a law that barred foreigners, a category in which Romania placed its Jews, from practising a handicraft. After the Kishinev pogrom of 1903 he pressed the foreign secretary, Lord Lansdowne, to protest to Russia about the danger of further violence in Odessa, and on 7 April 1904 he assured the American banker Jacob Schiff that the London house had not handled a Russian loan since 1875.[9]
Their methods were cautious, and they were often criticised for that. When the mass emigration from Russia began in the 1880s, it was Edmond de Rothschild in Paris who took a step that went far beyond lobbying and charity, and committed himself to supporting Jewish farmers in the Land of Israel.
References
OpenClose
- Henry Wasserman, Simon R. Schwarzfuchs and Vivian David Lipman, “Rothschild,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Miriam Rothschild, “Rothschild Women,” Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women, Jewish Women’s Archive *
- Linda Gordon Kuzmack, updated by Ellery Weil, “Constance Rothschild, Lady Battersea,” Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women, Jewish Women’s Archive *
- “Pogroms,” The YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe *
- Industrial Dwellings Society, “Our history” *
- Evelina London Children’s Hospital, “Our history” *
- “Jewish Association for the Protection of Girls and Women,” Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women, Jewish Women’s Archive *
- Niall Ferguson, The House of Rothschild. Volume 2, The World’s Banker 1849–1999 (London: Penguin, 2000; first published 1999) *
- John Cooper, “Nathaniel Mayer Rothschild (1840–1915), the last of the shtadlanim,” Jewish Historical Studies 43 (2011) *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Rothschild index page.