Why the Rothschilds
No family in history has attracted more conspiracy theories than the Rothschilds. Earlier chapters have shown how particular legends arose, from the “Satan” pamphlet of 1846 that invented Nathan’s killing at Waterloo to the attacks that followed the railway accident at Fampoux. This chapter steps back to ask why the name became a symbol, how the symbol changed over two centuries, and why it still circulates today.
Part of the answer lies in the business itself. The Rothschilds were a private partnership, owned and run by one family, which published no accounts and explained nothing. They dealt directly with kings and ministers, lent to governments of every political colour, and moved money across frontiers faster than any state could follow. Their success was visible in palaces, racehorses and art collections, while the work that produced it, the correspondence, the arbitrage, the slow building of trust with clients, was invisible. A business that combined great wealth, close ties to power and secrecy invited speculation.[1][2]
The other part of the answer is that they were Jews. Older Christian images of the Jew as moneylender, usurer and enemy of Christ were ready to hand, and the Rothschilds’ rise in the decades after emancipation seemed to confirm them. For people who felt that the new world of capitalism, railways and stock exchanges was making their lives worse, a single Jewish family that appeared to sit at the centre of that world offered a simple explanation. The Encyclopaedia Judaica notes that in France the power of the Rothschilds was “very evident”, especially under Napoleon III, and that some of the anger at the new age expressed itself in attacks on them.[3]
From the left to the right
In the 1840s that anger came mainly from the left. Socialists in the tradition of Charles Fourier and Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and above all Fourier’s disciple Alphonse Toussenel, made “Rothschild” a shorthand for financial capitalism, and Toussenel’s Les Juifs, rois de l’époque gave the attack its title. Julie Kalman has shown how this left-wing criticism of Rothschild and his co-religionists as “kings of the era” fused economic grievance with older religious prejudice.[2][3] Even after the defeat of 1870 and the Paris Commune, the Encyclopaedia Judaica observes, socialists “quickly adopted the image of Rothschild as the symbol of financial capitalism”.[3]
From the 1880s the main source of the attacks shifted to the Catholic and nationalist right. In 1882 the Union Générale, an investment bank founded in 1878 by Paul-Eugène Bontoux, a former employee of a Rothschild railway company, collapsed in a spectacular crash. Bontoux claimed that his bank had been destroyed by Jewish and German banks and Freemasons hostile to its conservative Catholic backers, and the myth found favour on the antisemitic right, although the economic historian Jean Bouvier, who studied the affair in the archives, found no such conspiracy.[4] Catholic antisemitism, the Encyclopaedia Judaica notes, grew steadily after the collapse.[3] Four years later Édouard Drumont published La France juive, which the same encyclopaedia calls perhaps “the single, most successful antisemitic and counterrevolutionary book ever published”. It went through innumerable editions and spread the myth that the small Jewish community of France held enormous and dangerous economic power. Drumont’s newspaper, La Libre Parole, kept up the campaign, and the climate he created helped to make possible the hysteria of the Dreyfus affair from 1894.[3]
Caricature carried the message further than any book. In 1898 the satirical magazine Le Rire published a cartoon by Charles Léandre showing a caricatured Rothschild holding the world in his hands, an image that the Anti-Defamation League still uses to illustrate the oldest antisemitic myth of all, that Jews secretly control the world.[5] Similar images appeared in German, Austrian and American papers. In the United States, campaigners against the gold standard in the 1890s used the same imagery. W. H. Harvey’s best-selling Coin’s Financial School of 1894, the bible of the free-silver movement, included a cartoon titled “The English Octopus”, a monster spreading its tentacles over the world, which stood for the Rothschilds’ supposed hold on the world’s gold.[6]
The Protocols and the Nazis
The early twentieth century turned these scattered images into a coherent conspiracy theory. The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, first published in a newspaper in the Russian Empire in 1903, claimed to be the minutes of secret meetings of Jewish leaders plotting to take over the world. It was a forgery. In 1921 The Times showed that much of it had been copied from a French political satire, Maurice Joly’s Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu of 1864, which does not mention Jews at all.[7] But the exposure did little to stop it. The Protocols was translated into many languages, and in the United States Henry Ford published a series of articles based on it, collected as The International Jew, which was translated into at least sixteen languages and inspired Nazi leaders, Hitler among them.[7][8]
The Anti-Defamation League argues that the Protocols “laid the groundwork for modern conspiracy theories about the reach and influence of ‘Jewish Power'”, including the claims that the Rothschild family controls the world banking system and that the Federal Reserve is “under the thumb of Jewish financiers”.[5] In this literature the Rothschilds were no longer simply rich bankers but the hidden hand behind wars, revolutions and depressions, which, in the theory’s circular logic, they were said to profit from on both sides.
The Nazis used the name freely. Their propaganda presented the Rothschilds as the embodiment of the Jewish plutocracy that they claimed had dragged Germany into war, and in 1940 Goebbels’s ministry released the feature film Die Rothschilds, which turned the Waterloo legend into cinema.[9] The persecution that the family suffered in Vienna and Paris, described in the next chapter, was presented as the confiscation of wealth stolen from the German people.
A quotation that never was
One of the most widely shared “Rothschild quotations” on the internet runs, in its commonest form, “Permit me to issue and control the money of a nation, and I care not who makes its laws.” It is usually attributed to Mayer Amschel. There is no evidence that he or any other member of the family ever said or wrote it. No letter, memoir or contemporary report contains it, and it appears only in much later polemical writing, often with different wording and sometimes attributed to different Rothschilds. It belongs with Nathan at Waterloo and the grape at New Court: a story that sounds as if it ought to be true and so is repeated without being checked.[10][11]
The history of the line can be traced in print. Its model is an old saying about the power of popular song, “Let me make the songs of a nation, and I care not who makes its laws”, associated with the Scottish politician Andrew Fletcher of Saltoun at the beginning of the eighteenth century.[11][10] The money version first appears without any name attached. At a hearing of the United States House Committee on Banking and Currency on 29 January 1908, the printed record includes the warning that “the maxim of the money lenders of the Old World will then be in operation: ‘Let us control the money of a country and we care not who makes its laws.'” By 1913 a document printed in the congressional serial set was claiming that the House of Rothschild had “reduced it to the broad maxim”.[11] The first known attribution to Mayer Amschel himself came in 1935, in Money Creators by the American writer Gertrude M. Coogan, who also claimed that “the World is ruled by the International Money Masters”. Mayer Amschel had then been dead for more than 120 years, and later versions date the supposed remark to years anywhere between 1790 and 1863.[10][11]
The quotation still travels. In April 2024 it appeared in Ten Years to Save the West, a memoir by the former British prime minister Liz Truss. After the writer Dorian Lynskey pointed out its origin, the Board of Deputies of British Jews wrote to the publisher, Biteback, which apologised and undertook to remove it from the e-book and future printings, and Truss’s office said that she had believed it genuine.[10] The episode is a small illustration of how a forgery, once detached from its source, can pass into respectable print.
The same is true of the larger claims. The family has never owned or controlled the Bank of England or the Federal Reserve. It did not finance “both sides” of the wars of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries in the way the theory imagines; it lent to the governments it trusted, usually to those it regarded as its own, and it lost heavily when those governments fell. The houses in Naples and Frankfurt closed, the Vienna house was taken by the Nazis, and the Paris bank was seized under Vichy and nationalised by a socialist government forty years later. These are not the fortunes of a family that controls the world.
The myth today
The conspiracy theory has not faded. In March 2018 a member of the Washington DC city council claimed that the Rothschild family was “controlling the climate to create natural disasters they can pay for to own the cities”.[5] Variations on the theme circulate constantly on social media, in which “Rothschild” often works as a coded way of saying “the Jews” without having to say it.
Historians have taken two lessons from this long history. The first is that the conspiracy theory tells us very little about the Rothschilds and a great deal about the anxieties of those who believe it, whether about capitalism, modernity, war or national decline. The second is that the best answer to myth is evidence. The family’s own archive in London holds a vast collection of letters, ledgers and documents, and the work of historians such as Niall Ferguson, who drew on the partners’ private letters, many of them written in Judendeutsch, German in Hebrew characters, has shown a family that was powerful, often lucky, sometimes ruthless and frequently wrong, but never the omnipotent hidden hand of legend.[1]
References
OpenClose
- Niall Ferguson, The House of Rothschild. Volume 1, Money’s Prophets 1798–1848 (London: Penguin, 1999; first published 1998) *
- Julie Kalman, “‘Rothschildian Greed’. This New Variety of Despotism,” French History and Civilization 1 (2005), pp. 215–226 *
- “Antisemitism,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Eugene N. White, “The Crash of 1882, Counterparty Risk, and the Bailout of the Paris Bourse,” NBER Working Paper 12933 (2007) *
- ADL, “Myth. Jews Have Too Much Power,” Antisemitism Uncovered *
- Northern Illinois University Digital Library, W. H. Harvey, Coin’s Financial School (Chicago, 1894), “Pictures and Illustrations” *
- United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, “An Antisemitic Conspiracy. The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,” Holocaust Encyclopedia *
- “Elders of Zion, Protocols of the Learned,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- filmportal.de, “Die Rothschilds” (1940), film record *
- The Jewish Chronicle, “Liz Truss book includes false Rothschild quote about ‘control’ of money,” April 2024 *
- Barry Popik, “Permit me to issue and control the money of a nation, and I care not who makes its laws,” The Big Apple *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Rothschild index page.