Skip to content

A letter to Lord Rothschild

The naturalist of Tring

The man to whom the most famous letter in modern Jewish history was addressed had spent most of his life thinking about birds, butterflies and giant tortoises. Lionel Walter Rothschild, born in 1868, was the elder son of Natty, the first Lord Rothschild, and his wife Emma. The family moved from London to Tring Park in Hertfordshire, and there, as a small boy, Walter began collecting insects. At the age of seven he told his parents that he was going to “make a museum”, and by the time he was ten he had enough specimens to start one in a garden shed.[1]

His family disapproved of his passion, which was not what the heir to New Court was supposed to care about. Walter dutifully worked in the bank and served in the army, and from 1899 to 1910 he sat in the House of Commons as Liberal Unionist member for Aylesbury, succeeding his uncle in the seat, although Hansard records only five contributions from him in those eleven years.[2][3] He was hopeless at finance and happy only among his specimens. His father accepted the situation with resignation. For his son’s twenty-first birthday Natty built him a museum on the edge of Tring Park, and in 1892 Walter’s Zoological Museum opened to the public.[1][4]

Walter collected on an extraordinary scale. Over his lifetime he employed around four hundred collectors, who sent him specimens from more than forty-eight countries, many of them new to Western science. He hired two outstanding curators, the German ornithologist Ernst Hartert and the entomologist Karl Jordan, who between them made Tring a centre of scientific exchange; Jordan alone described more than three thousand new species. Behind the public galleries lay a research collection of more than a million specimens, including some 300,000 birds and over a million butterflies and moths.[1]

Ink-and-watercolour illustration of a sunlit museum workroom lined with glass cases of birds. A bearded man holds a drawer of butterflies, an older woman in spectacles writes labels, a young assistant sorts specimens, an elderly man looks through a microscope and a mounted cassowary stands in the background.
A workroom at Walter Rothschild’s natural history museum at Tring, with drawers of butterflies, cases of birds and a mounted cassowary.

The museum’s grounds held emus and kangaroos. Walter kept 144 live giant tortoises from the Galápagos and from Aldabra in the Indian Ocean, and for ten years leased the island of Aldabra to protect its tortoises from hunters. He kept sixty-four cassowaries in Tring Park and had a portrait painted of each one. He trained zebras to pull a carriage, which he was even invited to drive into the grounds of Buckingham Palace.[1] The family’s interest in natural history ran in the blood. His younger brother Charles, a banker by day, was an expert on fleas and a pioneer of nature conservation, and Charles’s daughter Miriam became one of the leading naturalists of the twentieth century.

Walter’s private life was less happy than his scientific one. In the 1930s, short of money despite his family’s wealth, he was forced to sell almost his entire bird collection to the American Museum of Natural History in New York. Only after his death was it revealed that for nearly forty years he had been blackmailed by a peeress, once his mistress, and her husband.[1] He died in 1937, aged sixty-nine, and left the museum, its collections and its land to the Natural History Museum in London. It remains the largest private natural history collection ever assembled by one person, and the Natural History Museum at Tring still displays many specimens exactly where he placed them.[1][5]

The family and Zionism

Natty had not been a Zionist. He was impressed by Theodor Herzl as a man, but, like most of the Anglo-Jewish establishment, he regarded the idea of a Jewish state with suspicion, fearing that it would call into question the loyalty of Jews to the countries in which they lived.[4] His death in 1915 made Walter the second Lord Rothschild and, by convention, the most prominent Jew in Britain. Walter, unlike his father, was a Zionist.[4]

The family was divided. Walter’s cousin Lionel, the son of Leopold, chaired the anti-Zionist League of British Jews, founded in November 1917 at a meeting held, pointedly, at New Court.[6][7] In Paris, Edmond had moved closer to the Zionist Organisation during the war, and his son James, who married Dorothy Pinto, was an active supporter. When James was called up into the French army in 1914, Dorothy acted as the intermediary between him, his father and Chaim Weizmann, and so, in her early twenties, she became deeply involved in Zionist politics.[4][8][9] The British government, for its part, had become interested in Zionism for reasons of its own: strategy in the Middle East as the Ottoman Empire collapsed, rivalry with France, and the hope of winning Jewish opinion in Russia and the United States to the Allied side.[10]

The declaration

The central figure on the Zionist side was Weizmann, a chemist at the University of Manchester whose scientific work during the war brought him to the notice of David Lloyd George, then minister of munitions and from December 1916 prime minister.[10] On 7 February 1917 Sir Mark Sykes met the Zionist leaders, among them Lord Rothschild, Herbert Samuel, Rabbi Moses Gaster, Nahum Sokolow and Weizmann. On 19 June the foreign secretary, Arthur James Balfour, invited Lord Rothschild and Weizmann to submit a draft of a declaration of support. The Zionists took a month to agree on a text, and they were careful in their wording, avoiding the phrase “Jewish state” and settling on the more modest “national home”.[10]

The strongest opposition came from within the cabinet. Edwin Montagu, secretary of state for India and one of the few Jews in government, was horrified by the draft and in August 1917 circulated a memorandum titled “The Antisemitism of the Present Government”. His objections led to the addition of safeguards for the existing non-Jewish population of Palestine and for the rights of Jews in other countries. On 31 October Balfour wound up a debate in the war cabinet that had lasted two months.[10]

On 2 November 1917 Balfour signed a short letter to Lord Rothschild, asking him to pass the declaration on to the Zionist Federation. It was made public only on 9 November, so that it could appear first in the Jewish Chronicle.[10] Its central sentence read:

“His Majesty’s Government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country.”[10]

Why was the letter addressed to Walter? Not because the Rothschilds had bought it, as conspiracy theorists have claimed ever since, but because the British government needed a recipient who stood for British Jewry as a whole, and the head of the English Rothschilds, a peer and the bearer of the most famous Jewish name in the country, was the obvious choice. The declaration was a decision of the war cabinet, taken for British reasons and approved in advance by the Allies; it was later endorsed by the League of Nations and written into the British Mandate for Palestine.[10]

Consequences

The Balfour Declaration was greeted with enthusiasm by Jews across the world, particularly in Russia. The Foreign Office came to regret that it had not been published earlier.[10] Under the Mandate it became the legal basis for Jewish immigration to Palestine and, in time, a founding document in the history of the State of Israel. For Palestinian Arabs, who were then the great majority of the country’s population and who are referred to in it only as “existing non-Jewish communities”, it marked the beginning of a national catastrophe. Its two halves, a national home for one people and the protection of the civil and religious rights of the other, have been argued over ever since.

For the Rothschilds, the letter fixed their name to the history of Zionism. Edmond had already given the movement its first villages. His son James settled in England, served in the House of Commons and continued his father’s work, which after his death in 1957 was taken over by his widow Dorothy.[4] His will left funds for a permanent home for the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, which was inaugurated in Jerusalem in 1966, and the family foundation Yad Hanadiv, which Dorothy led after his death, went on to pay for the Supreme Court building, dedicated in 1992.[11][12][9] For Walter, the letter was the most important thing that ever happened to him outside his museum. He is still better remembered at Tring for his cassowaries than for the declaration that bears Balfour’s name.

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Rothschild