The Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
1. At a glance
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson at the Bell Telephone Laboratories in Holmdel, New Jersey, in 1964 and 1965 is one of the most consequential experimental observations in the history of twentieth-century science. The observation was the first detection of the relic radiation predicted by the hot Big Bang cosmology of George Gamow, Ralph Alpher, and Robert Herman, and it became, almost overnight, the central piece of evidence for a cosmological model that would, within a decade, displace the rival Steady State theory and become the consensus view of the origin and evolution of the universe. Penzias and Wilson received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1978 for the discovery. The observation was made, paradoxically, by researchers who were not looking for the cosmic background at all, and who initially interpreted the signal as an unwanted noise in a radio antenna designed for satellite communications.
2. The theoretical prediction, a hot Big Bang
The theoretical context of the discovery begins in the late 1940s, when George Gamow, then at the George Washington University, set out to develop a cosmological model that could account for the observed abundances of the light chemical elements. Gamow’s hypothesis, which he worked out in a series of papers in 1946 and 1948, was that the universe had begun in a state of extremely high density and temperature, that it had expanded and cooled from that state, and that the elements had been synthesised by neutron capture in the early hot universe. The model was worked out in detail in two papers published in 1948 by Ralph Alpher, then a graduate student of Gamow’s, and Robert Herman, a physicist at the Applied Physics Laboratory of Johns Hopkins University. The Alpher-Bethe-Gamow paper of April 1948, which Gamow famously added Bethe’s name to make the author list read alpha-beta-gamma, laid out the basic physics of primordial nucleosynthesis. A companion paper by Alpher and Herman later in 1948 worked out the temperature history of the expanding universe and predicted the existence of a residual radiation field that would, at the present epoch, have cooled to a temperature of about five degrees above absolute zero.
The prediction, in the form given by Alpher and Herman in 1948, was that the universe would be filled with a bath of microwave radiation corresponding to a blackbody temperature of approximately five kelvin. The radiation, in their calculation, was the relic of the decoupling of matter and radiation in the early universe, when the universe cooled below the temperature at which free electrons could combine with protons to form neutral hydrogen. The decoupling, in their model, occurred when the universe was about four hundred thousand years old. The temperature at which the decoupling occurred was about three thousand kelvin, corresponding to a wavelength of about one micron in the infrared. The expansion of the universe since decoupling would have stretched the wavelength of the radiation into the microwave region of the spectrum by a factor of about one thousand, so that the radiation, at the present epoch, would appear at a wavelength of about a millimetre and at a temperature of about three kelvin.
The prediction was published, but it was not at first widely noticed. The physics community of the early 1950s was focused on other cosmological problems, in particular on the Steady State theory developed by Hermann Bondi, Thomas Gold, and Fred Hoyle at Cambridge. The Steady State theory held that the universe had no beginning and no end, that it had always looked approximately as it did at present, and that new matter was continuously created to fill the void left by the expansion. The theory was, in its early years, regarded by many physicists as more philosophically attractive than the Big Bang, in part because it avoided the embarrassing question of what happened at the initial moment. The prediction of a cosmic background radiation was, however, a clear and testable consequence of the Big Bang that the Steady State theory could not produce, and its discovery would, in the event, be decisive.
There were several near-discoveries of the cosmic background in the years between the prediction and the discovery. Andrew McKellar, an astronomer at the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory in Victoria, British Columbia, had in 1941 inferred a temperature of about two to three kelvin from observations of the rotational excitation of interstellar cyanogen molecules, but he had not interpreted this as evidence for a cosmological radiation field. Yakov Zel’dovich and his collaborators in the Soviet Union had in the late 1950s independently predicted a background radiation, and Robert Dicke and his collaborators at Princeton had independently developed the prediction in the early 1960s. The discovery, when it came, was made by researchers who were unaware of the Alpher-Herman prediction but who had, in Penzias’s case, been trained in the relevant radio astronomy and, in Wilson’s case, in the relevant physics.
3. The Holmdel horn antenna
The instrument with which the cosmic microwave background was discovered was the Holmdel Horn Antenna, a large radio telescope that had been built by Bell Telephone Laboratories on a hilltop at the Crawford Hill laboratory in Holmdel, New Jersey, in 1959 and 1960. The antenna had been designed for use in the Echo satellite project, an experiment to use a large passive communications satellite in low earth orbit to relay telephone and television signals across the continent. The Echo satellite was a large balloon that was inflated in orbit and used as a passive reflector of radio signals transmitted from the ground; the Holmdel horn was one of the principal ground stations for the project.
The horn antenna was, by the standards of radio astronomy, a precision instrument. It consisted of a large horn-shaped waveguide, about fifteen metres long, with an aperture of about six by six metres, mounted on a rotating base that allowed it to be pointed at any part of the sky. The horn was shielded from the ground by a ground screen that reduced the contribution of thermal radiation from the ground to the antenna temperature. The instrument was, when new, the lowest-noise radio receiver in the world, and it was used by Bell Labs for a variety of radio astronomy and communications research projects after the Echo project was completed. The instrument had been designed by the team of researchers at Crawford Hill, including Robert Wilson, who had joined Bell Labs in 1963 after completing his doctoral work at Caltech.
Arno Penzias had joined Bell Labs in 1961, after completing his doctoral work at Columbia University, and had been assigned to work at the Crawford Hill laboratory. He and Wilson had planned to use the Holmdel horn for a programme of radio astronomy observations of interstellar hydrogen and other radio sources. They began using the antenna in 1963, and they immediately noticed that the antenna was producing a small but persistent excess of signal that they could not explain. The excess appeared at all frequencies they tested, at all times of day, and in all directions they pointed the antenna. They had, in their initial characterisation, ruled out the major terrestrial sources of radio interference, including the emissions from nearby cities and from the New York metropolitan area, and they had begun to suspect that the source of the excess was in the antenna itself.
4. The discovery in 1964 and 1965
The systematic investigation of the excess began in 1964. Penzias and Wilson went through the antenna with a kind of forensic patience, testing every component of the receiver for possible sources of thermal emission. They checked the antenna feed horn, the waveguide connections, the amplifiers, the receiver electronics. They tested the antenna for radio frequency interference. They measured the contribution of the ground screen to the antenna temperature. They looked for the possibility that the antenna was picking up radiation from nearby objects, including the ground, the buildings, and the surrounding countryside. They ruled out, one by one, every plausible terrestrial source.
The two researchers then considered the possibility that the excess was due to the antenna itself. They looked for nests of birds in the antenna, which they had initially dismissed as a possible cause of the signal but which they were now, in their methodical investigation, prepared to take seriously. They found a pair of pigeons nesting in the antenna and trapped them; the pigeons were released, and the researchers noted the incident, in characteristic style, in the logbook of the antenna. The pigeons came back, twice, and were trapped and released again. The presence of the pigeons did not, in the end, account for the signal. Penzias and Wilson then turned their attention to the possibility that the signal was of celestial origin.
The decisive connection between the Holmdel horn observation and the cosmological prediction was made in the spring of 1965. Penzias mentioned the excess signal in a telephone call to Bernard Burke of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, who was a radio astronomer with a wide acquaintance in the field. Burke mentioned to Penzias that he had heard of a group at Princeton, led by Robert Dicke, that was building an experiment to search for the cosmic microwave background. Penzias telephoned Dicke, and the two groups agreed to publish their results in the same issue of the Astrophysical Journal. The two papers appeared in the July 1965 issue: the Penzias and Wilson paper, titled “A Measurement of Excess Antenna Temperature at 4080 Mc/s,” and the Dicke, Peebles, Roll, and Wilkinson paper, titled “Cosmic Black-Body Radiation.” The first paper described the observation, the second paper interpreted it.
The Penzias and Wilson observation, in its published form, was a measurement of an excess antenna temperature of 3.5 plus or minus 1.0 kelvin at a frequency of 4080 megahertz, corresponding to a wavelength of about seven centimetres. The paper was deliberately understated, and it did not claim any cosmological interpretation of the observation. The interpretive work was done in the companion paper by the Princeton group, which identified the signal as the cosmic microwave background predicted by the Big Bang cosmology. The two papers together, published in the same issue of the same journal, constituted the discovery.
5. Confirmation and Big Bang acceptance
The discovery was immediately recognised as a major result, and within a few years it had transformed the cosmological landscape. The observation of a uniform, isotropic, low-temperature background radiation corresponding to a blackbody spectrum was exactly what the Big Bang model predicted and what the Steady State model could not explain. The Steady State theory was not, in the event, abandoned immediately: Fred Hoyle continued to defend it for many years, and the rival cosmological community was not, in 1965, persuaded that the Big Bang was the correct model. But the observational case for the Big Bang became, with the discovery of the cosmic background, very difficult to dismiss.
Confirmation of the discovery came rapidly from other radio astronomy groups. The Princeton group, led by Roll and Wilkinson, had, before the publication of the Penzias and Wilson result, built a radiometer designed to detect the cosmic background and had obtained measurements consistent with the Holmdel result. Groups at the Naval Research Laboratory, at the University of Cambridge, and elsewhere carried out observations at other wavelengths and found that the spectrum of the background was consistent with a blackbody at a temperature of about three kelvin. The discovery was confirmed, in particular, by observations made by the Soviet group at the Sternberg Astronomical Institute in Moscow, by the group at Queen Mary College in London, and by a number of other radio and infrared astronomy groups around the world.
The discovery was, in particular, important because it ruled out a number of alternative explanations. The observed radiation was isotropic to a very high degree, with variations from the mean of less than one part in a thousand. The radiation was, in other words, uniform across the sky to a precision that no known celestial source could explain. The radiation was also unpolarised, at least at the level of the early observations, and this was consistent with the prediction of the Big Bang model and inconsistent with several alternative explanations. The combination of isotropy and thermal spectrum was, in particular, the prediction of the Big Bang that the Steady State theory could not reproduce.
6. COBE, WMAP, and the cosmological revolution
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background was the first step in a longer programme of observational cosmology that has continued for the past half century. The next major step came with the Cosmic Background Explorer, or COBE, a satellite that was launched by NASA in November 1989 and that operated, with its cryogenically cooled instruments, until 1993. COBE carried three instruments, each of which made fundamental contributions to the study of the cosmic background. The FIRAS instrument measured the spectrum of the cosmic background with a precision that confirmed it to be a perfect blackbody to within about one part in ten thousand. The DMR instrument measured the anisotropy of the cosmic background at large angular scales, finding that the temperature of the background varies from place to place across the sky by about one part in a hundred thousand, with the variations tracing the primordial density fluctuations that would later grow into galaxies and clusters of galaxies. The DIRBE instrument measured the infrared emission from foregrounds and helped to clean the cosmic background signal of galactic and solar system contamination.
The discovery of the anisotropy by COBE was, in many ways, as consequential as the original discovery of the background by Penzias and Wilson. The anisotropy is the imprint on the cosmic background of the primordial density fluctuations from which all of the structure in the universe – galaxies, clusters of galaxies, superclusters, and the great walls and voids of the large-scale structure – eventually grew. The detection of the anisotropy, and its measurement with increasing precision by subsequent experiments, has been the principal observational input to the development of the standard model of cosmology, the so-called Lambda-CDM model, in which the universe is dominated by cold dark matter and a cosmological constant, with ordinary baryonic matter contributing only about five per cent of the total energy density. The model has been confirmed by a series of increasingly precise observations of the cosmic background, the most recent of which is the Planck satellite, launched by the European Space Agency in 2009, which has measured the anisotropy of the cosmic background with a precision that has pinned down the parameters of the standard cosmological model to within a few per cent.
The subsequent programme of cosmic background observations has also included ground-based and balloon-borne experiments that have measured the anisotropy at small angular scales and have tested the predictions of the inflationary models of the very early universe. The Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, or WMAP, launched by NASA in 2001, made the first high-precision measurement of the anisotropy at large angular scales and produced the first clear detection of the acoustic peaks in the angular power spectrum of the anisotropy, a feature predicted by the inflationary models. The Planck satellite has refined these measurements and has, in particular, set the most precise current constraints on the parameters of the inflationary model.
7. The cosmological picture
The cosmic microwave background is, in the standard cosmological picture, the oldest light that can in principle be observed. It was emitted, in the Big Bang model, when the universe was about four hundred thousand years old and was at a temperature of about three thousand kelvin. The radiation has travelled through the universe since that time, for the past thirteen and a half billion years or so, and it has been cooled by the stretching of the wavelength due to the expansion of the universe to a temperature of 2.725 kelvin, observed today at a wavelength of about a millimetre. The observation of this radiation, from every direction in the sky, is the direct observation of the universe at the time of recombination, when the free electrons and protons of the early hot universe combined to form neutral hydrogen and the universe became transparent to electromagnetic radiation for the first time.
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background is, in this sense, the discovery of a horizon beyond which no electromagnetic signal from the early universe can be observed. The radiation is the limit of what can be seen by electromagnetic means. Beyond the surface of last scattering, in the period before recombination, the universe was opaque to electromagnetic radiation, and any signals from that period would have to be detected by means other than electromagnetic observation. The observation of the cosmic background is therefore the most distant direct observation in the history of observational astronomy, and the most ancient light that the human species has ever seen.
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background is also one of the cases in the history of twentieth-century physics in which the experimental and theoretical work proceeded in parallel, in different laboratories, with little contact, and arrived at a result that vindicated one theoretical approach and ruled out another. The Alpher-Herman prediction was made in 1948, but it was forgotten. The Dicke prediction was made in the early 1960s, but the Princeton experiment had not yet been completed when the Holmdel horn made the discovery. The Penzias and Wilson observation was made by researchers who were not looking for the cosmic background at all. The chain of events that led from the prediction to the discovery was, in other words, a chain of independent work and independent insight, and the convergence of the different lines on the same result is one of the most striking examples in the history of science of the way in which disparate lines of research can converge on a common answer.
8. Why it matters
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background matters for several reasons. It matters, in the first instance, because it confirmed the Big Bang model of the universe and ruled out the Steady State theory. The observational basis of cosmology was, before the discovery, thin: there were a small number of cosmological observations, including the recession of the galaxies discovered by Edwin Hubble and the abundance of helium produced by primordial nucleosynthesis, but there was no single observation that could be used to discriminate decisively between competing cosmological models. The discovery of the cosmic background was the first observation that could be used in this way, and it was the observation that tilted the balance of the cosmological community decisively in favour of the Big Bang.
It matters, in the second instance, because it opened up a new field of observational cosmology. The cosmic background is a treasure trove of cosmological information, and the study of its properties – the spectrum, the anisotropy, the polarisation – has been one of the most active and productive fields of cosmology for the past half century. The discovery of the anisotropy by COBE was the discovery of the primordial density fluctuations from which all of the structure in the universe eventually developed, and it is the foundation of the modern study of the formation of galaxies and of the large-scale structure of the universe.
It matters, in the third instance, because it transformed the public understanding of the universe. The cosmic background is a part of the everyday description of cosmology, and the picture of the cosmic background from COBE and from Planck is one of the iconic images of modern science. The discovery is part of the story that cosmology has to tell about the origin and evolution of the universe, and it has been a central element of the popular presentation of cosmology from the 1970s to the present.
It matters, in the fourth instance, because it is a parable of the way in which science works. The discovery was made by researchers who were not looking for what they found. The theoretical prediction was made by researchers who were forgotten. The interpretive synthesis was made by a third group, who heard of the observation in a telephone call. The discovery is a reminder that science is a community enterprise, that the work of any one researcher or group is dependent on the work of many others, and that the discoveries that change the way we understand the world are often the discoveries that were not sought.
9. Timeline
-
Andrew McKellar, an astronomer at the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory in Victoria, British Columbia, had in 1941 inferred a temperature of about two to three kelvin from observations of the rotational excitation of interstellar cyanogen molecules, but he had not interpreted this as evidence for a cosmological radiation field.
-
Gamow’s hypothesis, which he worked out in a series of papers in 1946 and 1948, was that the universe had begun in a state of extremely high density and temperature, that it had expanded and cooled from that state, and that the elements had been synthesised by neutron capture in the early hot universe.
-
The Alpher-Herman prediction was made in 1948, but it was forgotten.
-
The instrument with which the cosmic microwave background was discovered was the Holmdel Horn Antenna, a large radio telescope that had been built by Bell Telephone Laboratories on a hilltop at the Crawford Hill laboratory in Holmdel, New Jersey, in 1959 and 1960.
-
Arno Penzias had joined Bell Labs in 1961, after completing his doctoral work at Columbia University, and had been assigned to work at the Crawford Hill laboratory.
-
The instrument had been designed by the team of researchers at Crawford Hill, including Robert Wilson, who had joined Bell Labs in 1963 after completing his doctoral work at Caltech.
-
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson at the Bell Telephone Laboratories in Holmdel, New Jersey, in 1964 and 1965 is one of the most consequential experimental observations in the history of twentieth-century science.
-
The decisive connection between the Holmdel horn observation and the cosmological prediction was made in the spring of 1965.
-
Penzias and Wilson received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1978 for the discovery.
-
The Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, or WMAP, launched by NASA in 2001, made the first high-precision measurement of the anisotropy at large angular scales and produced the first clear detection of the acoustic peaks in the angular power spectrum of the anisotropy, a feature predicted by the inflationary models.
Sources
- The Nobel Prize in Physics 1978: Arno Penzias, Robert Wilson – The Nobel Foundation, 1978
- The Cosmic Microwave Background: How It Changed Our Understanding of the Universe – Rhodri Evans, Cham: Springer, 2014
- The 4-Percent Universe: Dark Matter, Dark Energy, and the Race to Discover the Rest of Reality – Richard Panek, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2011
- The Early Universe: A Course in Cosmology and Particle Astrophysics – Edward W. Kolb and Michael S. Turner, Reading: Addison-Wesley, 1990
- The First Three Minutes: A Modern View of the Origin of the Universe – Steven Weinberg, New York: Basic Books, 1977
- Three Degrees Above Zero: Bell Labs at Bell – Jeremy Bernstein, New York: Scribner, 1984
- Relic Radiation from the Big Bang: A Half-Century Journey from Prediction to Discovery – Robert W. Wilson, in: Reviews of Modern Physics, vol. 82, no. 4, 2010
- Discovery of the Cosmic Background Radiation: A Personal Account – Arno A. Penzias, in: Reviews of Modern Physics, vol. 51, no. 2, 1979
- The Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) Mission – John C. Mather, in: Reviews of Modern Physics, vol. 84, no. 1, 2012