On the true faith of a Christian
By the middle of the nineteenth century most of the legal disabilities of British Jews had quietly fallen away. Robert Woodall, writing in History Today, lists the milestones. Jews could become freemen of the City of London from 1831; Francis Goldsmid became the first Jewish barrister in 1833; Jews could take degrees at the new London University from 1837; and from 1845 a Jew elected to municipal office could make a declaration in the form most binding on his conscience. In 1855 David Salomons became Lord Mayor of London.[1] One barrier remained, and it was the one that mattered most. To sit in either House of Parliament a member had to swear an oath that ended with the words “on the true faith of a Christian”.[1][2]
That phrase was a recent addition. When Parliament repealed the Test and Corporation Acts in 1828, the House of Lords inserted it into the declaration required of office-holders, and the Jews, as Woodall puts it, became “the only minority in Britain to be officially discriminated against because of their faith”.[1] Bills to remove the disability passed the Commons in 1833, 1834 and 1836, supported by Whigs and radicals including Thomas Babington Macaulay, and each time the Lords threw them out. Macaulay’s answer to the argument that Jews should not legislate for a Christian country became famous: “What is proposed is not that the Jews should legislate for a Christian community, but that a legislature composed of Christians and Jews should legislate for a community composed of Christians and Jews.”[1]
The question was forced by the City of London, and by Nathan’s eldest son. In 1847 Lionel de Rothschild stood as a Liberal for the City, a four-member constituency, alongside the prime minister, Lord John Russell. A meeting of Liberal electors endorsed him on 8 July 1847, and the Rothschild Archive notes that his aim was to make Jewish emancipation part of the wider Liberal programme of civil and religious liberty.[3] He was elected. He had told the electors that “as the representative of the most wealthy, the most important, the most intelligent constituency in the world, I shall not be refused admission to Parliament on account of any form of words whatsoever”. When Parliament met in December 1847, he could not take the oath in its Christian form, and so he could not take his seat.[1][4]

Eleven years
Russell, who regarded the matter as one of constitutional principle, at once moved a resolution to remove the offending words. The debate that followed divided the parties in unexpected ways. William Gladstone, still a Tory and member for Oxford University, voted for the Jews against the wishes of his constituents, arguing that one could hold Christianity to be “in the highest degree needful for our legislature” without concluding that every non-Christian must be excluded from it. Benjamin Disraeli, born a Jew and baptised as a boy, spoke for them too, against almost his entire party.[1] The Commons passed the bill; the Lords rejected it in 1848, and again in the years that followed.
Lionel kept standing and kept winning. He was returned again for the City in 1849, with a two-to-one majority, in 1852 and in 1857, when, after yet another bill had failed in the Lords, he resigned and was returned at the by-election that followed.[3][5] On 26 July 1850 he went to the table of the House and asked to be sworn on the Hebrew Bible; called on to withdraw, he came back three days later, was allowed to take the oath in that form, but stopped when he reached the words “on the true faith of a Christian”, saying, “I omit these words as not binding on my conscience”, and he was obliged to withdraw.[3][1][4] At one point his allies discovered that nothing prevented an elected member from serving on a committee of the House, even if he could not vote or sit in the chamber, and Lionel was duly appointed to one. By 1858, Woodall counts, the Commons had passed a bill to admit the Jews ten times, and ten times the Lords had thrown it out.[1]
The deadlock was broken by a compromise. Lord Lucan, a Conservative peer who had voted against every previous bill, proposed that each House should be free to decide for itself what form of oath to accept. Russell disliked a solution that left the Jews’ rights at the mercy of a vote in each House, but accepted it as the only way through, and the Conservative prime minister Lord Derby saw it as the last chance of agreement between the two Houses. The Jews Relief Act received royal assent on 23 July 1858.[1][2]
Three days later, on 26 July 1858, Lionel de Rothschild came to the table of the House of Commons again. He took the oath with his head covered, as Jewish tradition requires, left out the words “on the true faith of a Christian”, signed the roll and went to his seat, the first Jewish member of the British Parliament.[1][6] His wife Charlotte, Woodall reports, was relieved and exultant: “For eleven years we’ve had the MP question screaming in every corner of the house.”[1]
A seat, a silence and a peerage
Lionel sat for the City, with a short break in 1868 and 1869, until 1874.[4] In all his years in the House, as Woodall remarks with some irony, he did not once make a speech. That was not surprising. He had no political ambition and little interest in the business of the House; his purpose had been to vindicate a principle. And as George Goschen, a director of the Bank of England and later Chancellor of the Exchequer, observed, a Rothschild could exert more influence from New Court than almost anyone from anywhere else, certainly more than from the back benches.[1]
Other Jewish members soon followed. Lionel’s brother Mayer was returned for Hythe and sworn in February 1859,[7] David Salomons took his seat for Greenwich, and Francis Goldsmid entered the House. In 1866 the Parliamentary Oaths Act replaced the old oaths with a single uniform oath and removed the words “on the true faith of a Christian” for everyone.[1][8] The Lords remained closed for longer. In 1869 Gladstone proposed Lionel for a peerage; Queen Victoria refused, calling it, in Woodall’s words, “a step she could not assent to”.[1][9]
It was Lionel’s son who crossed that line. In 1885 Gladstone, anxious to keep him loyal to the Liberal party, raised Nathaniel, known in the family as Natty, to the peerage as Baron Rothschild, and he became the first Jew to sit in the House of Lords as a professing Jew. He had sat for twenty years as Liberal member for Aylesbury, and he later moved, like many Whig grandees, to the Liberal Unionists.[9] He was also president of the United Synagogue and, in the words of the Encyclopaedia Judaica, the effective lay head of Anglo-Jewry.[4] By then Lionel had also left his mark on literature. The Encyclopaedia notes that the character of Sidonia in Disraeli’s novel Coningsby, published in 1844, the fabulously rich and learned Jewish banker who advises the young hero, is an idealised portrait of him.[4]
As head of the London house from his father’s death until his own in 1879, Lionel also presided over some of the firm’s most famous loans: for the relief of the Irish famine in 1847, for the Crimean War and, as the next chapter shows, for the purchase of a large part of a canal.[4]
References
OpenClose
- Robert Woodall, “The Jewish Relief Act, 1858,” History Today 25, no. 6 (June 1975) *
- UK Parliament, Living Heritage, “Religion in the nineteenth century” *
- The Rothschild Archive, “Lionel de Rothschild and Jewish Emancipation” *
- Henry Wasserman, Simon R. Schwarzfuchs and Vivian David Lipman, “Rothschild,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- History of Parliament, Members after 1832, “Lionel Nathan de Rothschild” *
- Hansard, House of Commons, “Admission of Baron de Rothschild,” 26 July 1858, vol. 151 *
- Hansard, House of Commons, “Admission of Baron Mayer Amschel de Rothschild,” 16 February 1859, vol. 152 *
- Jewish Encyclopedia (1906), “Acts of Parliament relating to the Jews of England” *
- John Cooper, “Nathaniel Mayer Rothschild (1840–1915), the last of the shtadlanim,” Jewish Historical Studies 43 (2011) *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Rothschild index page.