Skip to content

A senator and a fellowship

The brother in Colorado

Simon Guggenheim was born in Philadelphia on 30 December 1867, the sixth of Meyer’s surviving sons.[1] Like his elder brothers he was educated partly in Philadelphia and partly in Europe, and like Benjamin and William he was sent to the West to learn the metals business. He spent much of his early career in Colorado, first at Pueblo and in the purchasing of ore, and he made Denver his home. He was the only one of the brothers who came to think of himself as a westerner.[2][3]

In Colorado he became involved in Republican politics. In 1896 he was nominated for lieutenant governor, but withdrew because he did not meet the age requirement; in 1904 he was proposed for governor and again withdrew.[2] He was a generous contributor to the Colorado Republican party and to good causes in the state, and he built a reputation as a public-spirited businessman. He was also, inescapably, a member of the family that owned the largest smelters in the state, at a time when the conflict between capital and labour in Colorado was among the most bitter in the country.[2][4]

A seat in the Senate

Before the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution took effect in 1913, United States senators were elected not by the voters but by the legislatures of their states. The system was open to abuse, and in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries a number of rich men were accused of buying their seats by paying the campaign expenses of friendly legislators.[2][3] In January 1907 the Colorado legislature elected Simon Guggenheim to the United States Senate as a Republican.[1] His election was greeted with charges, in the Democratic and Progressive press of Colorado and the nation, that he had paid for it by financing the campaigns of Republican legislators; Simon himself acknowledged that he had contributed heavily to the party’s campaign funds, and he defended the practice as normal.[2][4] The episode was cited in the campaign for the direct election of senators that culminated in the Seventeenth Amendment.

He served one term, from 4 March 1907 to 3 March 1913.[1] The Biographical Directory of the United States Congress records his committee work, including the chairmanship of the Senate Committee on Coast Defenses and of the Committee on Expenditures in the Department of Commerce and Labor.[1] He was a quiet senator, who rarely spoke on the floor, and his voting record was that of a conservative Republican loyal to the administration of William Howard Taft. During the Ballinger and Pinchot controversy, which touched his own family’s interests in Alaska, he kept a low profile.[2][5] He did not seek re-election, and after leaving the Senate he returned to business in New York, where he succeeded Daniel as president of American Smelting and Refining in 1919.[1][2]

A son’s death

Simon had married Olga Hirsh, and they had two sons, John Simon and George Denver. In April 1922 John Simon died at the age of seventeen.[6][2] The Guggenheim Foundation records that after his death his parents decided to create a non-profit foundation in his memory.[6] The loss was followed by another: George, the younger son, struggled with depression for much of his adult life and took his own life in 1939.[2]

The idea for the foundation took shape over the following two years. In 1924 Simon engaged a young scholar, Henry Allen Moe, a former Rhodes Scholar, to plan it and lead it in its first years.[6] Moe and his advisers studied the Rhodes scholarships and other models and recommended a fellowship programme that would give mature scholars, scientists and artists the time and freedom to pursue their work, rather than a scholarship for students.[6][7] On 16 March 1925 the John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation was chartered and incorporated by the State of New York.[6] Simon’s letter of gift to the trustees is dated 26 March 1925, ten days later, and some sources take that as the date of foundation.[6][7]

How the fellowships work

The design of the fellowships owed much to Henry Allen Moe. They were awarded not to students but to men and women who had already shown exceptional ability, for a year or more of work on a project of their own choosing, with few conditions about how the time and money were spent.[6][7] Moe believed that the best way to help creative people was to give them freedom, and that the selection should rest on the judgment of distinguished practitioners in each field, who would read the applications and recommend the strongest.[7] The model was much imitated, and it made the foundation one of the most influential private patrons of scholarship and the arts in the United States.

The foundation has kept to that design for a century. Its record year was 1972, when it awarded 366 fellowships, and new fields were added as the arts and sciences changed: the first Fellows in computer science were named in 1962.[6] In 2021 the actor Robert De Niro established a fellowship in honour of his father, the painter Robert De Niro Sr., who had been a Fellow in 1968; the elder De Niro had also been one of the young painters shown by Peggy Guggenheim at Art of This Century, a reminder of how closely the different branches of the family’s patronage were entwined.[6][8]

Simon was the brother most closely involved in the management of American Smelting and Refining in the years after Daniel’s retirement, and he served for many years as the trust’s president.[1][2] His fortune, his wife Olga’s devotion to the memory of their sons, and his own experience of the narrowness of a businessman’s education all shaped the foundation that bears his son’s name. The letter of gift that established it described its purpose in broad terms, as a means of improving the quality of education and the practice of the arts and professions, of fostering research and of providing for the cause of better international understanding, and the trustees were given wide discretion in interpreting it.[6] Olga, who outlived her husband by many years, continued to give generously to the foundation and to the arts, and in their memory the foundation has kept its offices and its traditions in New York for a century.[6][2]

Fellowships since 1925

On 27 May 1925 the foundation’s committee of selection nominated fifteen people, chosen from seventy-four applicants, to form the first class of Fellows; they were appointed by the trustees the next day. The first class included the twenty-four-year-old Aaron Copland.[6] In 1929 a second gift from Simon extended the fellowships to Mexico and parts of the Caribbean and South America, and further Latin American countries were added in later years.[6] It is a curious symmetry that a fortune made in large part from Mexican and Chilean mines came to support the scholars and artists of Latin America.

The list of Guggenheim Fellows over the following century reads like a roll of honour of American and Latin American culture. Martha Graham became the first Fellow in choreography in 1932, Edward Weston the first in photography in 1937, and Maya Deren the first in film in 1946. In 1933 the Whitney Museum exhibited 136 works by fifty-two Fellows, including Isamu Noguchi and Marsden Hartley.[6] The fellowships became among the most prestigious awards in American intellectual life.[7]

Moe led the foundation for nearly forty years, retiring in 1963.[6] Simon Guggenheim died in New York on 2 November 1941.[1] His senatorial career is a footnote in the history of the Senate; his foundation is one of the most enduring things the family created. It has continued to grow through gifts from others, among them the novelist Philip Roth, who left the foundation $1.6 million in 2018.[6] The name that had been attacked in the Progressive press as a symbol of corrupt wealth became, through Simon’s grief and Moe’s judgment, a synonym for the free pursuit of learning.

References

OpenClose
  1. “Guggenheim, Simon (1867 to 1941),” Biographical Directory of the United States Congress *
  2. Irwin Unger and Debi Unger, The Guggenheims. A Family History (New York: HarperCollins, 2005), print *
  3. John H. Davis, The Guggenheims. An American Epic (New York: William Morrow, 1978), print *
  4. Harvey O’Connor, The Guggenheims. The Making of an American Dynasty (New York: Covici, Friede, 1937), print *
  5. Historic American Engineering Record, “Kennecott, Alaska” (National Park Service) *
  6. John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation, “Our legacy of excellence” *
  7. Milton Lomask, Seed Money. The Guggenheim Story (New York: Farrar, Straus, 1964), print *
  8. Peggy Guggenheim Collection, “About Peggy” *

The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Guggenheim index page.

← Contents of Guggenheim