Skip to content

The Gazette, Proust and the Dreyfus years

Owner and editor

In 1885 Charles Ephrussi bought five-twelfths of the capital of the Gazette des Beaux-Arts, the journal in which he had published his first articles nine years earlier.[1] The Dictionary of Art Historians describes him from that year as co-owner of the Gazette.[2] From 1894 he devoted himself to it fully as editor-in-chief, during the years in which the journal was becoming more scholarly.[2][1] The New York curators described the Gazette as the pioneering journal of art and art history, whose influence was unparalleled for more than a century, and Charles as its editor and part-owner.[3]

He went on acting as an intermediary between collectors and the national museums. De Givry records that he helped the Louvre acquire the Botticelli frescoes from the Villa Lemmi in 1882, and that in 1903 the Ministry of Public Instruction and Fine Arts accepted, from Charles in the name of the Chassériau committee, the gift of the fresco of Peace from the frescoes Théodore Chassériau had painted for the Cour des comptes.[1] Charles was a founding member of the Union centrale des arts décoratifs in 1882 and of the Société des grandes auditions musicales in 1890. He was made a knight of the Legion of Honour in 1882 and an officer in 1903.[1][2]

Ink-and-watercolour illustration of an office lined with shelves of bound volumes. A bespectacled bearded editor marks a proof, a moustached young secretary reads a sheet, two older men check pages and prints, a woman holds a print up to the window light and a girl sketches at the table.
Editors and secretaries check engravings and proofs at a Paris art journal in the 1890s.

His collection by then was eclectic, in de Givry’s word: alongside the paintings, there were Japanese decorative objects, important Empire furniture, rare Sèvres porcelain and statuettes after the antique, an ensemble that matched the figure of the “Benedictine dandy” immortalised by Jules Laforgue and Marcel Proust.[1] Jablonka, following de Waal, writes that as time went by Charles gradually lost interest in high society and became ever more absorbed in art history, collecting and patronage.[4]

Secretaries and a novelist

Charles employed a series of young literary men as secretaries. The title of a study published in the Gazette des Beaux-Arts in 1984 by Philip Kolb and Jean Adhémar names three of them: Laforgue, “A. Renan” and Proust.[1][2] Laforgue’s service is well documented: Encyclopaedia Britannica records that he became Charles’s secretary through Paul Bourget and that Charles introduced him to Impressionist painting.[5] How formal Proust’s role was is less clear, and the sources consulted here do not settle it; what is certain is that the two men knew each other well. The New York wall texts call Charles Proust’s friend and say that Proust took him as the model for Charles Swann, a central character in In Search of Lost Time.[3] De Waal writes that in his Paris study Charles, “Jewish, charming and social, a collector, art historian and editor, entertained and encouraged Proust”.[6]

Swann is the elegant Jewish connoisseur of Proust’s novel, at home in the most exclusive salons, and Proust drew him from more than one original. The Dictionary of Art Historians says that Swann is modelled in part on Ephrussi, and de Waal calls Charles “one of the models”.[2][6] Laforgue’s “Benedictine dandy” is the link between the real man and the fictional one: both combined learning, taste and social glitter, and both were Jews whose acceptance in society depended on not looking too closely at what society said about Jews.[1]

The Japonisme of the novel also draws on the world of the Ephrussi. Jablonka notes that Proust’s Odette receives Swann wearing a kimono in a room decorated with screens and lanterns, at the time when Charles and Louise Cahen d’Anvers were collecting lacquer and ivory, bronzes, fans and Japanese robes.[4] The parallel is suggestive rather than proven; Proust drew on the whole fashionable world of the 1880s, and Japanese decoration was everywhere in it.

Proust put Charles into the novel twice over, once as a source for Swann and once, almost literally, as himself. In the volume known in English as The Guermantes Way, Melanson points out, the narrator dines with the Duke and Duchess de Guermantes and asks the Duke the name of “the gentleman in the top hat” in a picture by the painter Elstir. The Duke cannot remember it, though he knows that the man has been “a sort of Maecenas to Elstir”, and complains that, among all those bare-headed girls, the gentleman “is evidently not aware of the proper time and place for a top hat”.[7] The picture, Melanson writes, is identifiable as Renoir’s Luncheon of the Boating Party, and the overdressed figure is Charles.[7] A moment later the Duke recalls that Swann tried to make them buy a picture of nothing but a bundle of asparagus, for which Elstir “asked three hundred francs”: a joke that only works for readers who know the story of Manet’s asparagus and its buyer.[7] The Duke’s contempt is the point. In the novel, Melanson argues, the paintings serve as a test of taste which the old aristocracy fails and which Swann, the narrator and Charles pass.[7]

The Affair

The world that had welcomed Charles became less welcoming as he grew older. In 1886, as Melanson puts it, Édouard Drumont’s book La France juive brought antisemitism to the masses.[7] Edmond de Goncourt, who had long watched the Ephrussi with distaste, complained that the salons had become “infested with Jews and Jewesses”.[4][8] Renoir’s sneer that Moreau had been clever enough to “take in the Jews” by painting with gold colours, and that “even Ephrussi fell for it”, belongs to the same climate.[4]

Charles was named in such attacks. Melanson quotes a disapproving article of 1886, the year of Drumont’s book, entitled “Jews in Paris”, which described how “through the loophole of art” one of “these energetic Israelites”, Charles Ephrussi, had penetrated the salon of Princess Mathilde and made room for his uncles, aunts and cousins, until her Wednesday receptions had become “in a large degree receptions of the descendants of the tribes”.[7] Melanson’s own argument turns the sneer around. For the Ephrussi, she writes, Impressionism was a means of assimilation into the highest levels of French society, and for Jewish high society more broadly a rallying point and a marker of identity, a way of preserving and refashioning a distinct Jewish sphere.[7] Both readings can be true at once; the article of 1886 shows how quickly the first could be turned into a charge.

In 1894 the Dreyfus Affair broke. The Jewish Museum Vienna’s account of the family says simply that the Affair split French society.[9] The Dictionary of Art Historians, following de Waal, says that the popular antisemitism of the Affair had repercussions for Charles.[2] The Russian account goes further, saying that when French society was split by the Affair in 1894, the Ephrussi family became a target of antisemitic persecution.[10] The details are not given in the sources consulted here.

Death and inheritance

Charles Ephrussi died in Paris on 30 September 1905, at the age of fifty-five; de Givry gives his birth date as 24 December 1849.[1] His death was noted in the Chronique des arts et de la curiosité and the Gazette.[1] He had never married. According to de Givry, his niece, the wife of Théodore Reinach, inherited the bare ownership of his property, and Reinach took over the direction of the Gazette des Beaux-Arts.[1] The niece was Fanny Kann, daughter of Charles’s sister Betty, and she died in 1917.[3]

The collection did not stay together, and some of its pictures can now be found in public museums. Manet’s L’Asperge is in the Musée d’Orsay, and Renoir’s Luncheon of the Boating Party, with Charles in his top hat at the back, is in the Phillips Collection in Washington.[11][12] The netsuke had already left. Six years before his death, Charles had sent them to Vienna, at a moment, Jablonka writes, when the family’s heyday was waning and all things Japanese were passing out of style.[4] They would survive everything that happened to the family that received them.

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Ephrussi