Skip to content

Dispersal and the long restitution

Where the collection went

The Ephrussi collections in Vienna did not disappear; they were redistributed. The Advisory Board’s decision of 2019 says that all the works of art and the library in the Palais were afterwards distributed among state collections or auctioned.[1] The fate of one painting shows how. Franz Adam’s Camp Scene from 1848 in Italy, painted in 1870, was seized by the Gestapo and delivered to the Kunsthistorisches Museum, which passed it with five other paintings to the Österreichische Galerie; on 16 October 1939 the Army Museum in Vienna entered it in its inventory as a permanent loan from the gallery.[1] The Board’s decision of 2000 identified fourteen further objects, by then in the Federal Furniture Depot, that had been confiscated from the Palais in 1938: a neo-Rococo cabinet, a serving trolley, several tables, among them a small salon table with a gilt-bronze fluted column and three angel figures designed by Theophil Hansen, two onyx lamps, three oil paintings, an empty frame and a carpet.[2]

Behind the Ephrussi case lay a whole city’s robbery. In 2002 the historians Tina Walzer and Stephan Templ published a study of the “aryanisation” of Jewish property in Vienna, where some 200,000 Jews had lived, with a long section, “The Topography of Robbery”, listing businesses, addresses and their former and current owners; they wrote that “in the pillaging of their Jewish neighbors, the Viennese played a leading role for the entire Thousand Year Reich”.[3] Their book, the New York Times noted, was a bizarre walking guide to one of the great cities of Europe.[3]

Claims after 1945

After the war the family began the long work of recovery. The Advisory Board’s account is the most precise. Under the Nullity Act of 1946, which declared Nazi-era confiscations void, the heirs of Viktor Ephrussi first regained the war-damaged Palais. Parts of the furniture, library and art collection taken by the Nazis were also returned, and the heirs set about tracing the rest.[1] Their lawyer applied to the regional finance directorate for Vienna, Lower Austria and Burgenland for the restitution of paintings from the property confiscated in 1938 under the First Restitution Act of 26 July 1946. On 31 March 1948 the directorate told the Army Museum that restitution of the Adam painting would be ordered, and the order was issued on 14 April 1948, though the painting remained for the time being in the museum.[1]

The bank was settled more cheaply. After the Anschluss, Melichar writes, the “non-Jewish” Steinhäusser had acquired the shares of both Weiner and Viktor, and both men had been able to emigrate with their families, Weiner to the United States and Viktor to England. Viktor’s heirs brought a restitution claim and in 1948 received 50,000 schillings in a settlement. Weiner’s claims were confirmed only in 1954; he and Steinhäusser then went to arbitration over the “true value” of the share taken from him, Steinhäusser offering 600,000 schillings and Weiner demanding two million, and they agreed on 1.565 million. Melichar points out the disproportion. If the Ephrussi heirs’ 20 per cent was worth 50,000 schillings, Weiner’s 60 per cent should have been worth 150,000; he received more than ten times as much. He died in the United States two years later, aged eighty.[4]

The person who carried the burden of these claims was Elisabeth. Carey writes that she travelled to Vienna soon after the war and for five years wrote letters from England pressing her family’s case. The process, he says, was disheartening: materials and records were dispersed, bureaucrats were evasive, and Austria, which had welcomed Hitler, was deciding that it had been a victim of Nazism, the first country to be occupied, rather than a perpetrator.[5] Edmund de Waal, interviewed for the Telegraph, put the result bluntly. After the war, he said, the Austrians returned 191 books: “I mean, it was nothing.”[6] The family recovered some valuable tapestries, which were sold for school fees, and the Palais, which, having no wish to return to Vienna, they sold for $30,000 a few years after the war.[6] An AFP report on the 2019 exhibition dates the return of the Palais to 1949 and says that, with the city still occupied and heavily damaged, it fetched just $30,000.[7] Three family portraits, he noted, still hang in the Belvedere.[6]

The Ephrussi experience matched the national pattern. The economist Sidney Zabludoff, surveying the restitution of Holocaust-era assets across Europe, estimated that Austria had returned about $200 million, or a third of what had been looted from its Jews.[8]

The export trap

The most revealing episode concerns the paintings that were returned. Post-war Austria’s law against the export of cultural property gave museums leverage over families who wanted to take restituted works abroad, and the Art Restitution Act of 1998 makes specific provision for objects that passed to the state in connection with such export proceedings.[9][1] The Ephrussi case shows how the leverage worked. On 7 July 1950 the Army Museum asked the Federal Monuments Office to block the export of another painting from the Ephrussi collection, August von Pettenkofen’s Austrian Outposts in the Forest near Acs, because it wanted to buy it.[1] A memorandum of 10 July recorded that the Pettenkofen had already been cleared for export; the museum was therefore promised that the Adam painting would be blocked in its place.[1] A press account of the 2021 restitution says that the Pettenkofen had already been returned to Iggie Ephrussi.[10] On 11 July the family’s lawyer asked for a promised photograph of the Adam, “with an estimated value of S 6,000”, and that sum was paid to him on 14 August 1950 as the purchase price.[1]

The Board’s decision of 2019 explains why the bargain mattered. The Art Restitution Act, passed in 1998 and last amended in 2023, allows the return of objects in federal collections that were restituted, or should have been, and then passed to the state in close connection with export-ban proceedings.[9][1] The Board found that the purchase of the Adam was closely related in time and substance to the Pettenkofen export case, and that the conditions were met. It recommended that the painting be transferred to Viktor Ephrussi’s heirs, noting that the S 6,000 the family had received would have to be repaid, adjusted for inflation, before the transfer.[1]

Late returns

The Act of 1998 also produced the earlier decision. On 27 March 2000 the Board recommended that the Minister for Economic Affairs return the fourteen objects in the Federal Furniture Depot to Viktor’s heirs. It found that claims made between 1946 and 1948 had covered other property but not these objects, so that the state had acquired lawful title to them under the State Treaty; under the 1998 law they could now be returned free of charge. The law spoke only of “art objects”, the Board noted, but by an extensive interpretation it treated furniture, lamps and a carpet as falling within the term.[2]

The Adam painting was returned in 2021. Curators preparing the Jewish Museum Vienna’s exhibition of 2019, Gabriele Kohlbauer-Fritz and Tom Juncker, found that it should have been restituted under the decision of 1948, and the Board’s recommendation followed.[10] The restitution, carried out through the Jewish Museum with the authorisation of the Defence Minister, Klaudia Tanner, was announced in September 2021.[10][11] The press account adds that nineteen of the roughly seventy paintings in the Ephrussi collection remained lost.[10] Seventy-three years had passed between the order to return the painting and its return.

A novel of return

Elisabeth turned the experience into fiction. The Exiles Return, Carey writes, was written in the mid-1950s, after the fraught years in which she had carried the family’s claims.[5] It is set in Vienna in 1954 and 1955, the last months of the four-power occupation, and follows people who grew up in the city before the war and have come back to see whether they can recover the life they lost.[12] Kuno Adler is a Jewish scientist who fled to New York after the Anschluss and returns to take up his old post; his publisher’s note describes his confrontations with officialdom and with a changed city, where “the lime trees are there no longer” and it is hard to know who behaved well during the war and who was a Nazi sympathiser.[12] Theophil Kanakis, from Vienna’s Greek community, has made a fortune in America and returns to buy an eighteenth-century house and beautiful things; Marie-Theres, eighteen, the daughter of a Viennese princess who emigrated, comes back to a country she has never known, and her story ends in catastrophe.[5][12]

Carey judges Adler “the only real exile”, the character whose story most closely reflects the author’s anger at the small cruelties of post-war Vienna. Reinstated at his old laboratory only at the rank he held fifteen years earlier, he finds that old friends do not really want to see him, and learns that his unpleasant superior worked in a concentration camp experimenting on people.[5] The publisher suggests that each exile carries an aspect of the author, and that Elisabeth most resembled the clever, unglamorous Princess Nina; de Waal described his grandmother to BBC Radio 4 as “desperate to get from one side of the Ringstrasse in this crazily marble and gilt edifice to the other side where there was this fantastically exciting university full of philosophers and economists”.[12] In his preface he wrote that she “was Viennese and this is a novel about being Viennese. As such, it is a novel about exile and about return.”[12]

Elisabeth wrote five novels, two in German and three in English, and none found a publisher in her lifetime.[5] In The Hare with Amber Eyes her grandson called the typescript of The Exiles Return, 261 pages with “painstaking Tipp-Exed corrections”, unpublishable: “The rawness of its emotions makes for uncomfortable reading.”[5] She was harder on herself. “I have always written, all my life,” she noted, “and have always faltered on the way and hardly ever succeeded in getting published…. I think I write in a rarified atmosphere, I lack the common touch, it is all too finely distilled.”[5] She died in 1991; a visitor’s account of the Vienna exhibition gives the place as Monmouth.[13][14] The novel was published by Persephone Books, with her grandson’s preface, and Carey, reviewing it in 2014, thought it “fascinating in its failure”, a book about dislocation “that doesn’t know where it belongs”.[12][5] It is also a document of the restitution years, written by the woman who fought them.

References

OpenClose
  1. Kunstrückgabebeirat (Austrian Art Restitution Advisory Board), decision “Ephrussi Viktor,” 12 April 2019 *
  2. Kunstrückgabebeirat (Austrian Art Restitution Advisory Board), decision “Ephrussi Viktor,” 27 March 2000 *
  3. Steven Erlanger, “Vienna Skewered as a Nazi-Era Pillager of Its Jews,” The New York Times, 7 March 2002 *
  4. Peter Melichar, “Wer war Alexander Weiner?,” Wiener Zeitung, 31 October 2021 *
  5. Leo Carey, “Coming Back,” The New York Review of Books, 24 April 2014 *
  6. Chris Harvey, “Edmund de Waal interview: ‘I feel bereft after selling my family treasures’,” The Daily Telegraph, 2020, reprinted by the Commission for Looted Art in Europe *
  7. AFP, “The rediscovered memories of a Viennese Jewish family,” RFI, 14 November 2019 *
  8. Sidney Zabludoff, “Restitution of Holocaust-Era Assets: Promises and Reality,” Jerusalem Center for Foreign Affairs (formerly Public Affairs) *
  9. Commission for Provenance Research, “Art Restitution Act” *
  10. Vindobona.org, “Jewish Museum Vienna: Restitution to Ephrussi Family after Decades,” 14 September 2021 *
  11. Jewish Museum Vienna, “The Jewish Museum Vienna and the Austrian Ministry of Defense make restitution to the Ephrussi family possible” *
  12. Persephone Books, “The Exiles Return” *
  13. Patrick Comerford, “Tales of the Viennese Jews 2, a ‘positively rabbinic’ portrait of an Anglican dean,” 16 November 2019 *
  14. Persephone Books, “Elisabeth de Waal” *

The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Ephrussi index page.

← Contents of Ephrussi