By the time he moved into Old Master paintings, Joseph Duveen was a fine judge of French eighteenth-century furniture and decorative art. Schjeldahl calls him “a first-rate connoisseur in some areas of taste, such as the art and design of the French eighteenth century, but chronically an amateur in others”.[1] The most important of those other areas was the Italian Renaissance, the field in which American collectors most wanted to buy and in which mistakes were easiest to make. To cover himself there, he needed an expert. He found the most famous expert in the world.
Bernard Berenson
Bernard Berenson was born in Lithuania and grew up in Boston, where, according to Rachel Cohen, he learned at Harvard to keep quiet about the fact that his father worked around the city as a tin peddler.[2] He converted to Episcopalianism, left for Europe in 1887 with the support of a few wealthy friends, among them Isabella Stewart Gardner, and trained himself in connoisseurship by standing for hours in front of paintings in Italian churches and monasteries.[2] Schjeldahl calls his life “one of the great stories of modern self-invention”.[1]
By 1906 he was, at forty-one, among the most respected authorities on Italian painting in the world, but his finances were precarious. He had advised Gardner on her purchases, but she was being priced out of the market by men like Morgan and Frick, and Berenson needed what he called “squillionaires” to take her place.[2] In 1907 he and his wife Mary bought the Villa I Tatti outside Florence, partly with money earned in Gardner’s service.[1][2] It would become, in Schjeldahl’s phrase, a money pit, and it bound him to Duveen.[1]
A meeting on Bond Street
The two men met in London in the autumn of 1906.[2][1] Behrman told a story that Cohen repeats with caution. Berenson is supposed to have called at the Duveen gallery in Bond Street with Lady Aline Sassoon, seen a painting worth having, and offered $150,000 for it on the spot, hoping to secure it for Gardner. “This fellow knows too much,” Duveen remarked to Lady Sassoon, and the couple left without Berenson’s name being spoken; Duveen is said to have guessed who he was, and later to have sold the picture for $300,000.[2] Berenson’s biographer Ernest Samuels suspected that Berenson “may have helped improve” the story.[2]
What is certain is that Duveen set out to win him. “I hope,” he wrote to Berenson in December 1906, “if there is anything you at any time wish me to do for you in London you will not forget that I am entirely at your disposition”.[2] Berenson knew what the trade thought of the newcomer; one dealer close to him called Duveen “Octopus and wrecker Duveen”.[2] But Duveen needed three things that Berenson could supply: accuracy in attributions, authority with American collectors and shrewdness in the Italian market, which Cohen describes as “mayhem”.[2]
Berenson’s method combined an extraordinary visual memory with new tools, photographs and the close comparison of small details, and he was a central figure in whittling down the many pictures that British owners had hopefully attributed to Giorgione and Raphael.[2] He believed that understanding came from sympathy as much as from analysis. “Sympathy kept under the control of reason,” he wrote, “has a penetrating power of its own, and leads to discoveries that no coldly scientific analysis will disclose”.[2] It was precisely this authority, personal and hard to explain, that Duveen wanted to borrow.
The contract of 1912
Berenson did some work for Duveen in 1907, authenticating pictures from one of the new collections, but he hesitated to commit himself further.[2] In 1912 he signed. Cohen, who studied the firm’s archive after it was opened to researchers, gives the terms. Berenson was to receive a fixed fee for consulting on attributions and twenty-five per cent of the net profit on any picture that the firm acquired on his advice. Those pictures were entered in what the contract called “the ‘X’ book”, kept at the Paris office. Berenson would represent the firm in the Italian market and would examine photographs of paintings, or paintings brought from Paris by courier.[2]
The contract was signed in Paris after long negotiations. It referred to the firm throughout as “the Merchants” and to Berenson as “the Expert”.[2] Both sides wanted it kept secret. Berenson guarded his reputation as an independent scholar, and Duveen wanted to be able to tell his clients that the world’s foremost authority had certified a painting without any interest in the sale. Duveen also enjoyed secrecy for its own sake; it seems to have been he who gave the firm’s agents code names, and Berenson was called Doris.[2]
Schjeldahl dates the working relationship from 1906 and says that it lasted thirty years, with Berenson paid a commission of up to twenty-five per cent of the profits on sales of the works he authenticated.[1] The firm’s records of its correspondence with Berenson begin in 1910 and continue to 1959, long after Duveen’s death.[3]

Constant bickering
The partnership was never easy. One employee of the firm remembered the correspondence between the Merchants and the Expert as a record of “constant bickering and at times outright antagonism”.[2] The firm often owed Berenson large sums and was slow to pay.[2] Mary Berenson, a formidable connoisseur herself, told her family that the Duveens hounded her husband “to make him say pictures are different from what he thinks”, and added: “They have found B.B. very unyielding”.[2]
Berenson drew a line round his own field. He refused to pronounce on works outside the Italian Renaissance, telling the firm, “I will not baptize outside my parish,” and other authorities had to be found for Duveen’s Flemish, Dutch and other pictures.[1] The firm’s archive contains many messages in which Berenson disappointed his employers, some of them very short. One early telegram reads in full: “NOT VERONESE. BERENSON.”.[2]
The two men’s quarrels could be theatrical. Schjeldahl, following Secrest, tells how Duveen, expecting a shouting match over a favour that Berenson had done for another dealer, summoned him to his Paris flat and had the doors muffled with mattresses. Berenson insisted on meeting at Duveen’s offices instead, and the meeting passed off smoothly, because, as Fowles put it, they needed each other.[1]
A divided mind
Berenson felt the arrangement as a moral burden. “For me it is hell,” he wrote to Mary from wartime Paris in 1916, declaring his “determination to get no deeper into the dealing world”.[2] But he had grown up without money, and he did not give it up. Before the crash of 1929, according to Samuels, he had about $300,000 invested in stocks.[2] In a draft letter to his lawyer, explaining to the American tax authorities why his books, pictures and travels were business expenses, he wrote: “I do not earn money by trade. I earn it by enjoying such authority & prestige that people will not buy expensive Italian pictures without my approval”.[2]
At the end of his life, in his Sketch for a Self-Portrait, Berenson wrote that his trade meant that “my reputation and the rest of me scarcely counted. The spiritual loss was great. I have never regarded myself as other than a failure”.[2]
Exposed in court
The secret did not survive the Hahn case, described in a later chapter. In 1923 one of the Hahns’ lawyers asked Berenson whether his opinion of the Louvre’s Belle Ferronière had changed since he entered the employ of Sir Joseph Duveen. Berenson objected to the word “employ”, saying that he only expertised Italian paintings from time to time at the firm’s request; asked whether he was paid for doing so, he said that he was.[2] The dealer René Gimpel, Duveen’s brother-in-law, wrote in his diary that the scholar’s mask had fallen, “that mask which so many enemies have sought to tear away”.[2]
Simpson and the archive
How far Berenson bent his attributions to suit the firm has been argued ever since. Many of the accusations began with Colin Simpson’s book Artful Partners, published in 1986, which had no reference notes but whose author said he had seen the firm’s then embargoed archive.[2] Cohen observes that since the archive was opened, material to verify Simpson’s claims “has not been easy to find”, and that while Berenson sometimes overpraised badly repainted works in letters to clients, he kept a careful distinction between calling a painting beautiful and calling it a Raphael.[2]
Schjeldahl is harsher. He notes that scores of the attributions Berenson made for Duveen, often from black-and-white photographs at I Tatti, have “wobbled” over the years and several have collapsed; a portrait in the National Gallery that Berenson authenticated as a Domenico Veneziano is now catalogued as “Florentine, fifteenth century”.[1] He argues that the collaboration had “a toxic effect on the intellectual culture of art”, accelerating the separation of connoisseurship from criticism.[1] Yet a former Metropolitan Museum curator, Michael Thomas, estimated nearly thirty years after Berenson’s death that more than four-fifths of his attributions still stood.[2]
The break
The partnership ended in 1937 over a single painting, the Allendale Nativity, which Duveen wanted to sell as a Giorgione and Berenson insisted was an early Titian. The story belongs with Duveen’s American clients and is told in a later chapter. It ended with a cable from Fowles to Duveen: “BERNARD INSISTS TITIAN, SO HAVE ACCEPTED RESIGNATION”.[2] Behrman’s verdict on the break is often quoted: “Neither Duveen nor Berenson was ever quite the same after the breakup. Duveen never recovered from the separation; Berenson never recovered from the association”.[1]
Berenson lived until 1959, “the sage of I Tatti”, and left the villa and its library to Harvard.[1] But in the years of the partnership, and especially in the decade before the First World War, his authority was one of the foundations of Duveen’s success with the richest collectors in America.
References
OpenClose
- Peter Schjeldahl, “Masterpieces for Sale”, The New Yorker, 8 November 2004 *
- Rachel Cohen, “Priceless. How Art Became Commerce”, The New Yorker, 8 October 2012 *
- Getty Research Institute, Duveen Brothers records, “Bernard Berenson correspondence, 1910 to 1959” *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Duveen index page.