The name Duveen came to stand, in the first decades of the twentieth century, for the most expensive pictures in the world. A Duveen picture hung in the house of every American plutocrat who wanted to be taken seriously, and a Duveen gallery, whether in Old Bond Street, the Place Vendôme or Fifth Avenue, was designed to make a visitor feel that he had entered a palace rather than a shop.[1][2] The firm’s best-known partner, Joseph Duveen, ended his life as Lord Duveen of Millbank, a trustee of three national collections in London and the giver of galleries to the Tate and the British Museum.[3][4] Yet the family’s story begins far from any of this, in a small town in the north-east of the Netherlands, in a foundry that made stoves and safes.
This history follows the Duveens from that foundry to the sale of what was left of their firm in 1964. It is a story about a family of Jewish dealers who moved from the Netherlands to Hull, from Hull to London and New York, and from the trade in blue-and-white porcelain to the trade in Renaissance paintings. It is also a story about how a family remembers itself. Few dynasties of dealers were so busy inventing their own past, and few have had their past so thoroughly reinvented by others.
Two origin stories
The best-known version of the Duveens’ beginnings is a fairy tale. In 1928 a profile of Sir Joseph Duveen in The New Yorker told its readers that the “real founder” of the firm was Sir Joseph’s grandmother, “the wife of a blacksmith of Meppel, Holland”, who had made a fine collection of Delftware on scanty means. In 1870, the profile said, she took her eldest son from the forge and sent him to England to sell her Delft; the business prospered, and she sent her second son, Henry, after him.[1] The playwright S. N. Behrman, whose portrait of Duveen appeared in the same magazine in 1951 and as a book the following year, told much the same story, and it was Behrman’s version that the world remembered.[5][6]
The second version came from inside the family. James Henry Duveen, a nephew of the founder who was known as Jacques and later as Jack, had talked to his uncle Joel at length in the years before Joel’s death in 1908. He set down what he learned in a family history, The Rise of the House of Duveen, published in 1957, and Meryle Secrest, the firm’s modern biographer, suggests that Behrman’s picturesque account was the likely reason he wrote it.[5] In Jack Duveen’s telling there was no blacksmith’s wife and no apron full of Delft. His grandmother, Eva van Minden of Zwolle, was the well-educated daughter of an East India merchant who appears to have had no interest in collecting at all, and his grandfather was not a blacksmith but the owner of an ironworks.[5]
Both versions, it should be said, were stories with a purpose. Behrman’s version made the Duveens self-made men, peasants who rose to sell Rembrandts to millionaires, which was the kind of tale American readers in the 1950s enjoyed. Jack Duveen’s version restored the family’s dignity, and in places it went much further than the evidence will bear.
The descent from Jabach
Jack Duveen claimed to have traced the family’s pedigree back to a seventeenth-century family called Du Vesne, from which he derived the name Duveen, and through them to Eberhard Jabach, the merchant banker and collector who bought heavily at the sale of the collection of Charles I and later sold paintings to Louis XIV that became part of the foundation of the Louvre.[5] Secrest reports this claim and the story Jack told of Jabach entering Paris at the head of a convoy of wagons loaded with pictures, but the genealogy rests on family tradition, and no documentary proof of it has been published.[5] Jack returned to the theme in his memoirs, where one chapter tells of a set of porcelain vases that he believed had once belonged to Jabach and which, by his account, he lost at auction to his own uncle.[7]
The Dictionary of National Biography, whose entry on Joel Duveen appeared in 1912, gave a more modest account. It said that Joel’s great-grandfather, Joseph Duveen of Giessen, had been an army contractor to the King of Saxony and had been ruined, and that his grandfather Henry settled in Meppel.[8] Secrest, working from Jack Duveen and from a Dutch chronicler of the family, says that Henoch Elkan Duveen, whom the family believed to be a descendant of Jabach, came to the Netherlands from Paris during the French Revolution and in 1810 took over a small iron foundry in Meppel.[5] Joel later told the art journalist A. C. R. Carter that his grandfather had been a contractor for horses and their equipment to the King of Saxony, which is close to what the Dictionary says of the great-grandfather.[5][8] The details do not fit together exactly, and the reader should treat the family’s eighteenth-century history as a set of traditions rather than a settled record.
The foundry at Meppel
On firmer ground is the foundry itself. Meppel was a small trading town in Drenthe, and Henoch Elkan Duveen’s iron works there passed to his son, Joseph Henoch Duveen, Joel’s father.[5] The Dutch account used by Secrest describes Joseph Henoch as a manufacturer of stoves and heaters who specialised in iron safes fitted with secret locks, and Joel himself said that a smithy was attached to the foundry and that he had learned to make horseshoes there as part of a long apprenticeship, while he was being trained to run the business.[5] The Meppel register, according to the same chronicler, lists the young Joel as a blacksmith’s apprentice, which is presumably where the legend of the blacksmith began.[5]
The family was also already involved in the trade in antiques. A cousin of Henoch Elkan, Levy Joseph, took the surname Hangjas and set up as an antique dealer in The Hague; the two branches stayed in touch and intermarried, and several Hangjas daughters married dealers.[5] Joseph Henoch had himself dealt in antiques before he took over the ironworks, and he passed that business on to one of his daughters, who married a man named van Esso.[5] It was under this aunt, Jack Duveen said, that the young Joel learned the elements of the trade.[5] Secrest imagines what such an education would have contained, from the marks on old silver to the difference between genuine Delft and the copies then being made in Paris, and coins a phrase that the family itself used: “the Duveen eye”, the ability to spot a hidden treasure in a jumble of goods.[5] Jack Duveen used the same phrase in his memoirs when he described his uncle bidding at Christie’s.[7]
Joel and Henry
Joel Joseph Duveen was the eldest child of Joseph Henoch and Eva Duveen. The Dictionary of National Biography gives his date of birth as 8 May 1843; Secrest gives 30 April 1843.[8][5] He was followed by two sisters, Jette and Betje, the second of whom would be the mother of Jack Duveen, and then by a brother, Henoch, later known as Henry, whom Secrest describes as born in 1855 and twelve years Joel’s junior.[5] The New Yorker profile of 1928, which says Henry was twenty-four in 1877, would put his birth a couple of years earlier, and the archive that holds the firm’s papers gives his life as running to the end of the 1910s.[1][9] The two brothers would build the firm together, and their partnership, sometimes quarrelsome but always resumed, is one of the threads of the first half of this history.
Their mother was, in Jack Duveen’s account, beautiful and cultivated but fragile, and she was an invalid in her last years. She died at the age of fifty-two on 20 August 1864, and her last words to Joel, then twenty-one, were to look after his sisters and his nine-year-old brother and to care for his father.[5]
The collapse
The advice was prescient. According to Jack Duveen, Joseph Henoch took to drink after his wife’s death and neglected the business, and the burden of managing the ironworks fell on Joel.[5] He failed. The story the family told was that he had not paid a government inspector the customary bribe, so that a valuable contract was withdrawn and the firm was effectively bankrupted.[5] Secrest notes that Jack Duveen says nothing about quarrels between father and son, but thinks them likely; whatever happened, Joel, by now in his early twenties, had to make his way elsewhere.[5]
The road out led across the North Sea. An uncle gave him a letter of introduction to Doumouriez and Gotschalk, wholesale importers of Dutch produce in Hull, and in 1866 he sailed for England, leaving his father, his sisters and his brother behind.[5][8] Some later accounts date his arrival a year earlier, but the Dictionary of National Biography, Secrest and the local historians of Hull’s Jewish community all give 1866.[8][5][10] The legend of the Delft in his luggage was told so often that it became part of the firm’s publicity, and Behrman made it the opening of his book; Secrest, following Jack Duveen, calls the prosaic truth an apprenticeship at fifteen shillings a week.[5]
A family that told stories
It is worth pausing over these competing beginnings, because the habit of storytelling did not end in Meppel. The firm that Joel and Henry founded lived on reputation as much as on stock. Its clients paid prices that could be justified only by the belief that a Duveen object was the finest of its kind, and the family learned early that a good story about an object, or about themselves, was worth a great deal of money. Joseph Duveen’s later fondness for grand claims was legendary; the historian John Brewer, reviewing Secrest’s biography, wrote of his habit of hyperbole and of the theatrical rescues by which he extricated himself from tight corners.[11]
The accounts that survive therefore have to be read with care. The New Yorker profile of 1928 was written while Sir Joseph was alive and plainly drew on what the firm wanted known.[1] Behrman wrote with the gifts of a dramatist, and his anecdotes are funny and often impossible to check.[6][12] Jack Duveen was an insider with grievances of his own; he quarrelled with his cousins and was sued by them over his use of the family name.[13][1] Secrest had the advantage of the firm’s own archive, now at the Getty Research Institute in Los Angeles, and much of what follows rests on her work and on the archive’s published descriptions.[11][9] Where the versions differ, this history says so.
What can be said with confidence is that in 1866 a young Dutch Jew with a training in metalwork, a family background in the antique trade and a sharp eye for porcelain arrived in a busy English port with very little money. The next chapter follows him there.
References
OpenClose
- Alva Johnston, “Noble Merchandise”, The New Yorker, 21 April 1928 *
- Anne Helmreich, Jill Sterrett and Jacqueline van Ginhoven, “Purpose-Built. Duveen and the Commercial Art Gallery”, Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide 20, no. 2 (Summer 2021) *
- Tate, “History of Tate Britain” *
- Debbie Challis, “Seeing White. Chromophobia for Chromophobia’s Sake”, 21 January 2022 *
- Meryle Secrest, Duveen. A Life in Art (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2004), opening chapter as published by the Library of Congress *
- Peter Schjeldahl, “Masterpieces for Sale”, The New Yorker, 8 November 2004 *
- James Henry Duveen, Secrets of an Art Dealer (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1938) *
- William Roberts, “Duveen, Sir Joseph Joel”, Dictionary of National Biography, 1912 supplement (London: Smith, Elder, 1912) *
- Getty Research Institute, Finding aid for the Duveen Brothers records, 1876 to 1981 (accession no. 960015) *
- Hull Jewish Archive Committee, Historical Walking Tour of Jewish Hull (Hull, 2008) *
- John Brewer, “The Art of the Deal”, The New York Review of Books, 7 October 2004 *
- Mario Einaudi and Diana W. Thompson, “Stories Aboard the Aquitania”, The Huntington, Verso, 4 September 2015 *
- Getty Research Institute, Duveen Brothers records, “Duveen v. Duveen. Notes of proceedings and judgments before Mr Justice Ridley and a jury, 18 to 19 April 1910” *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Duveen index page.