Skip to content

From Bilbao to Abu Dhabi

Thomas Krens and the global museum

By the 1980s the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation ran two museums: the Wright building in New York and, since Peggy Guggenheim’s death in 1979, her palazzo in Venice.[1][2] In 1988 the foundation appointed as director Thomas Krens, a former director of the Williams College Museum of Art with a degree in management, who believed that a modern museum should be a global institution with branches, partnerships and travelling exhibitions, run with the methods of a modern business.[1] His critics called it franchising; his supporters called it the only way for a museum with a small endowment and a famous name to survive.[1]

Under Krens the foundation expanded rapidly. In 1992 it opened the Guggenheim Museum SoHo in downtown Manhattan, which closed in 2001. In 1997 it opened, with Deutsche Bank, the Deutsche Guggenheim in Berlin, which ran until 2013. In 2001 it opened two exhibition spaces in Las Vegas, one in partnership with the Hermitage Museum of St Petersburg; the larger closed within two years and the other in 2008.[1] Proposals for Guggenheim museums in Salzburg, Rio de Janeiro, Guadalajara, Taichung and on the waterfront of lower Manhattan, designed by Frank Gehry, came to nothing.[1] The project that succeeded beyond anyone’s expectations was in the Basque Country.

Gehry’s Bilbao

In the early 1990s the Basque government was looking for a project to revive Bilbao, an industrial port in decline, whose shipyards and steelworks had closed. It agreed to pay for the construction of a museum and to fund its acquisitions and operations, while the Guggenheim Foundation would provide the name, its expertise and works from its collection.[1][3] The architect was Frank Gehry. His building, on the bank of the river Nervión, is a cluster of curved volumes clad in titanium, limestone and glass, organised round a central atrium, with 24,000 square metres of space, 9,000 of them for exhibitions.[3]

The Guggenheim Museum Bilbao opened in October 1997.[1][3] It was an immediate sensation, attracting visitors from all over the world to a city few tourists had visited before, and its effect on the economy and the image of Bilbao gave a new phrase to the language of urban planning: the Bilbao effect. Cities around the world tried to repeat it with spectacular buildings by famous architects, with mixed results.[1] The museum itself describes the building as a magnificent example of the most groundbreaking twentieth-century architecture, integrated within the urban pattern of the city.[3]

Not every city wanted a Guggenheim. A proposal for a museum in Helsinki, which went as far as an international architectural competition, was rejected by the city council in 2016 after a long public debate about its cost.[1] Krens left the directorship in 2008, and his successors have been more cautious.[1]

Abu Dhabi

The most ambitious of the foundation’s international projects has taken twenty years to complete. In 2006 the government of Abu Dhabi and the Guggenheim Foundation agreed to build a museum of modern and contemporary art on Saadiyat Island, as part of a cultural district that now includes the Louvre Abu Dhabi and the Zayed National Museum.[4][1] The building was designed by Frank Gehry, who died before its completion; the Abu Dhabi Department of Culture and Tourism describes it as the work of the late Pritzker laureate.[4] The project was delayed for years by the financial crisis of 2008, by changes of plan and by criticism of the conditions of the migrant workers who built the cultural district.[1]

Guggenheim Abu Dhabi is due to open on 11 December 2026.[4][5] It will be the largest of the Guggenheim museums. Its collection, in the words of the foundation’s director, Mariët Westermann, is “uniquely local and global, centred in the region but with works from all continents”.[4] The opening will take the name of a family from a Swiss village, by way of Philadelphia, Colorado, Chile and New York, to the shores of the Persian Gulf.

The global strategy has had its critics from the start. Museum professionals argued that branches and partnerships turned works of art into touring commodities and the Guggenheim name into a brand to be licensed; the foundation’s defenders replied that the expansion brought great art to new audiences and paid for the institution’s work in New York.[1] The partnership with the Basque government, which pays for the museum in Bilbao and owns the building, has proved durable, and the foundation now describes its museums in New York, Venice, Bilbao and Abu Dhabi as a constellation sharing a name, a collection and a set of values while serving very different places.[4][1] Mariët Westermann, its director, presents the Abu Dhabi museum as a source of wonder, a hub of connection and a place of curiosity and joy for people from the region and the world.[4]

What the family left

The Guggenheim family today is large, scattered and, for the most part, private. The mining firm that Meyer founded did not survive the generation of his sons as a family enterprise. American Smelting and Refining continued without the family, and was later known as Asarco; Kennecott passed into other hands; the mines of Chile were nationalised, and Chuquicamata and El Teniente are now run by the state company Codelco.[6][7] Guggenheim Brothers dwindled after the nitrate collapse, and the money that remained was divided among many heirs. The family histories trace the decline of a dynasty in which, by the fourth generation, no one ran a business on the scale of the brothers and many had drifted away from Judaism as well as from the firm.[7][8]

What remained were the institutions. The John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation still awards its fellowships every year.[9] The schools of aeronautics that Daniel and Harry founded trained the engineers of the aircraft and space industries, and Goddard’s rockets, built with Guggenheim money in the New Mexico desert, stand at the beginning of the history of spaceflight.[10][11] Newsday still serves Long Island.[12] The Harry Frank Guggenheim Foundation, which Harry created in 1929 for general philanthropic purposes and later turned towards the study of violence, war and aggression, still makes research grants, funded since his death by his bequest.[13] The Murry and Leonie Guggenheim Foundation, founded in the same year, ran a free dental clinic for the children of New York for decades.[7] The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation runs museums in New York, Venice and Bilbao, and soon in Abu Dhabi.[4][1] The financial firm Guggenheim Partners takes its name from the family through descendants who were among its founders, but it is not the family’s business in the sense that M. Guggenheim’s Sons was.[7]

The family’s industrial legacy has a darker side that the museums and foundations do not show. Asarco, the company that had grown from the smelters trust, was acquired in 1999 by the Mexican mining group Grupo México, and in 2005 it filed for bankruptcy under the weight of its liabilities for the pollution left by more than a century of mining and smelting.[14] In 2009, in what the Environmental Protection Agency described as the largest environmental bankruptcy in the history of the United States, $1.79 billion was paid to fund cleanup and restoration at more than eighty sites around the country.[14] Many of the contaminated places were smelters and mines that the trust had built or bought long after the family had left its management, but some dated from the years when the brothers controlled it. The fortune that paid for the fellowships and the spiral on Fifth Avenue was made in furnaces whose costs, in poisoned land and water, were borne by others for generations.[14][15]

Lengnau remembers

In the Surb valley the double-doored houses still stand, and the old cemetery in the woods between Endingen and Lengnau holds the graves of the families who stayed. A Jewish cultural trail opened in 2009 links the two villages, their synagogues, schools and ritual baths, and the heritage project named after the double doors tells the history of the community to visitors and schoolchildren.[16][17] Gilberte Favre’s account of the family’s Swiss origins notes how few of the millions who visit the museums in New York, Venice and Bilbao know that the name began among the Jews of a small Swiss village.[18]

The arc of the story is extraordinary. It begins with a tailor in his fifties who could not afford a licence to marry, and his son who walked the roads of the Pennsylvania coal country with a pack of stove polish. It passes through the flooded shafts of Leadville and the furnaces of Pueblo and Monterrey, the glaciers of Alaska and the desert of the Atacama, and it brings the family to the boardrooms of Wall Street and the Senate of the United States. It has its share of failure and tragedy, the nitrate collapse, the Titanic, the deaths of children, and its share of the exploitation on which the great fortunes of the age were built.[7][19][15] And it ends, as Meyer could never have imagined, in a palazzo on the Grand Canal, a titanium ship on a Basque river and a white spiral on Fifth Avenue, where millions of people every year walk slowly down a ramp through the art of the century, under a name that was once written in the tax rolls of a Swiss bailiff.[1][2][16]

References

OpenClose
  1. Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, “History” *
  2. Peggy Guggenheim Collection, “About Peggy” *
  3. Guggenheim Museum Bilbao, “The building” *
  4. Department of Culture and Tourism, Abu Dhabi, “Department of Culture and Tourism, Abu Dhabi announces opening of Guggenheim Abu Dhabi on 11 December 2026,” Abu Dhabi Media Office *
  5. Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, “Department of Culture and Tourism, Abu Dhabi announces December 11, 2026, opening of Guggenheim Abu Dhabi,” press release *
  6. “Corporación Nacional del Cobre de Chile,” International Directory of Company Histories, reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
  7. Irwin Unger and Debi Unger, The Guggenheims. A Family History (New York: HarperCollins, 2005), print *
  8. John H. Davis, The Guggenheims. An American Epic (New York: William Morrow, 1978), print *
  9. John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation, “Our legacy of excellence” *
  10. Richard P. Hallion, Legacy of Flight. The Guggenheim Contribution to American Aviation (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1977), print *
  11. NASA, “Dr. Robert H. Goddard, American rocketry pioneer” *
  12. Columbia University Case Consortium, “The founding of Newsday” *
  13. Harry Frank Guggenheim Foundation, “Our Work” and history *
  14. US Environmental Protection Agency, “Case Summary, ASARCO 2009 Bankruptcy Settlement” *
  15. Thomas F. O’Brien, The Revolutionary Mission. American Enterprise in Latin America, 1900 to 1945 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), print *
  16. “Endingen and Lengnau, Switzerland,” Jewish Virtual Library, after the Encyclopaedia Judaica *
  17. Doppeltür, “Historical background,” Jewish heritage project for Endingen and Lengnau *
  18. Gilberte Favre, “The Swiss origin of the Guggenheim family,” Sept *
  19. Elisabeth Glaser-Schmidt, “The Guggenheims and the Coming of the Great Depression in Chile, 1923-1934,” Business and Economic History 24, no. 1 (1995), 176 to 185 *

The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Guggenheim index page.

← Contents of Guggenheim