Rebay’s letter to Wright
By 1943 Hilla Rebay had decided that the collection needed a permanent home, and that the war made it impossible to commission any of the European architects she had considered. She chose instead the most celebrated architect in America, Frank Lloyd Wright, then seventy-six, whose theoretical writings she admired.[1] She wrote to him in June 1943 asking for “a temple of spirit, a monument”, a phrase that her biographer and later historians of the museum have often quoted.[2][3] The Landmarks Preservation Commission notes that Wright’s idea of an organic architecture, the translation of nature’s principles into buildable forms, resembled Rebay’s theosophical ideas for her temple.[1]
Wright replied, according to the Commission, that he had never seen a properly designed museum, one in which art was sympathetically displayed and visitors moved effortlessly.[1] He proposed a building in the form of a ziggurat, which thrilled Rebay; he established a mutual respect with Solomon, and was given $21,000 to begin designing even before a site had been acquired. The whole cost, including the site, was to have been $1 million.[1]
Sixteen years of drawings
In the spring of 1944 part of the present site, on Fifth Avenue between 88th and 89th Streets facing Central Park, was bought, and in August 1945 Wright unveiled a design at a luncheon at the Plaza Hotel.[1] His early studies show the rotunda as a ziggurat, an inverted ziggurat and a stack of hexagonal rings; Wright and Rebay disagreed over many features, among them his wish for an exterior of red marble, which she opposed in favour of something more subdued.[1] The rising cost of construction after the war made Solomon hesitate, and in 1948 the site was enlarged by the purchase of another part of the block.[1] Then Solomon died, and Rebay was gone, and Wright had two new clients, Harry Guggenheim and James Johnson Sweeney, when the estate was settled and the funds for the building were transferred to the foundation in 1952.[1]
The design that was finally built was a spiral ramp of reinforced concrete, widening as it rises, around a central space lit from above by a glass dome. Visitors were meant to take a lift to the top and walk slowly down the gentle slope of the ramp, seeing the paintings on the outer wall as they went. When the plans first reached the municipal authorities in 1952 they raised objections to thirty-two building regulations, and it took four years of revisions and appeals before the Department of Housing and Buildings issued a permit in 1956.[1] No builder at first wanted the job, until the architect Edgar Tafel, a former Taliesin apprentice, introduced Wright in August 1954 to George N. Cohen of the Euclid Contracting Corporation, who devised an economical method of building the curved walls by spraying Gunite, a dry mixture of sand and cement, against plywood forms.[1]
Demolition of the buildings on the site began in May 1956 and construction in October.[1] In December 1956 twenty-one artists, among them Willem de Kooning and Robert Motherwell, sent an open letter to the trustees and to Sweeney complaining that the design showed no sympathy for the display of painting and sculpture.[1] Critics such as Lewis Mumford judged the building harshly, and others admired it extravagantly; in a survey of architects in 1958 it was voted among the wonders of American architecture before it was even finished.[1]

Wright called his final design an “Archeseum”, which he explained as a building in which to see the highest, and he also called it “my Pantheon”, comparing it to the domed Roman temple with its single eye open to the sky.[1] The Landmarks Preservation Commission describes the final scheme of 1956 as the culmination of his search for a form made of interpenetrating geometric shapes. Interlocking cones determine the opposed slopes of the outer walls and of the inner edge of the ramp, which rises for a quarter of a mile in ever-widening loops; a smaller drum to the north, called the monitor, held offices, and a long cantilevered band joins the two.[1] The structural problem of a spiral without columns was solved first with the help of the Czech-born engineer Jaroslav Polivka, who tested sections of the ramp in 1946, and finally with twelve concrete webs set at thirty-degree intervals round the rotunda.[1]
The Commission sees the building as a summary of Wright’s career. Prairie-house cantilevers become a projecting balcony; the windowless walls recall the Unity Temple and the Larkin Building; the entrance drive and the dome derive from the Johnson Wax Building.[1] Wright himself presented it as an expression of democracy, writing that it was fortunate that this advanced work appeared on the avenue as a temple of adult education and not as a profit-seeking business venture.[1]
Opening day in October 1959
Wright did not live to see it completed. He died on 9 April 1959, at the age of ninety-one, and his successor firm, Taliesin Associated Architects, finished the work.[1][4] The museum opened on 21 October 1959.[1][3] The speakers at the opening were the foundation’s president, Harry F. Guggenheim; the United States ambassador to the United Nations, Henry Cabot Lodge; Solomon’s eldest daughter, the Countess Castle Stewart; the mayor, Robert F. Wagner; the parks commissioner, Robert Moses; and the Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare, Arthur S. Flemming.[1] The Commission records that on its first Sunday open to the public the museum received 16,039 visitors, and that 750,000 people visited it in its first nine months.[1] The final cost was between $2 million and $3 million.[1]
The building has been argued over ever since. Its admirers see it as one of the supreme works of twentieth-century architecture, a single continuous space in which the visitor’s movement and the art are united. Its critics, beginning with the artists of 1956, complain that the sloping floor, the curved and tilted walls and the low bays make paintings hard to hang and to see, and that the architecture overwhelms the art.[1] Sweeney, who had fought Wright over the lighting and the hanging, resigned in 1960.[5][3]
Restoration and world heritage
The museum was designated a New York City landmark on 14 August 1990, in the report that this chapter has drawn upon, and in 1992 a ten-storey tower designed by Gwathmey Siegel and Associates, based in part on Wright’s own plans for an annex, was added behind the rotunda, with new galleries and offices.[1][3] Between 2005 and 2008 the building’s exterior was restored, its cracked concrete repaired and its many layers of paint removed and replaced.[3]
In 2019 UNESCO inscribed the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum on the World Heritage List as one of eight buildings by Wright that together form “The 20th-Century Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright”.[4] UNESCO’s citation describes the buildings as reflecting the organic architecture Wright developed, with an open plan, a blurring of the boundaries between exterior and interior and an unprecedented use of materials such as steel and concrete.[4] It was the first modern architecture in the United States to be placed on the list. The white spiral that Rebay had imagined as a temple to non-objective painting had become, more than its collection, the symbol of the family’s name, and it would inspire the foundation’s directors, a generation later, to try to repeat the effect in other cities.[3]
References
OpenClose
- New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, “Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum,” designation report LP-1774, 14 August 1990 *
- Joan M. Lukach, Hilla Rebay. In Search of the Spirit in Art (New York: George Braziller, 1983), print *
- Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, “History” *
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “The 20th-Century Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright” *
- Irwin Unger and Debi Unger, The Guggenheims. A Family History (New York: HarperCollins, 2005), print *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Guggenheim index page.