Skip to content

Diamonds, rubber and nitrates

Leopold’s Congo

The Guggenheims’ search for new properties took them, in the first decade of the twentieth century, to the heart of Africa. The Congo Free State had been the personal possession of King Leopold II of the Belgians since 1885, and by the early 1900s it had become notorious for the forced labour, mutilation and killing used to extract wild rubber from its people. The campaign led by Edmund Dene Morel and Roger Casement had made the Congo an international scandal, and Leopold, under pressure to surrender the territory to the Belgian state, sought foreign investors who might give his regime a more respectable face.[1]

In 1906 Leopold arranged the creation of the Société Internationale Forestière et Minière du Congo, known as Forminière, to exploit the forests and minerals of the Kasai region. American investors took a substantial share. The American Congo Company, incorporated in New York on 22 October 1906, was founded by the financier Thomas Fortune Ryan and Daniel Guggenheim, with the participation of other American capitalists including J. P. Morgan and John D. Rockefeller Jr; one of its purposes was to explore and exploit Forminière’s mineral resources.[1][2] Adam Hochschild, in his history of Leopold’s Congo, describes how the king offered American investors concessions in the hope of winning friends in Washington at a time when the United States government was under pressure to join the protest against his rule.[1]

Angola and the Kasai diamonds

The American Congo Company’s rubber concession proved disappointing, but Forminière’s prospectors made a far more valuable discovery. In 1907 diamonds were found in the Kasai, and over the following decades the region became one of the largest sources of industrial diamonds in the world.[2][1] The Guggenheims, through their engineers and their share in the venture, took part in the exploration of the diamond fields that extended across the border into Portuguese Angola, where a company was formed in 1917 to work them.[2] The Congo and Angola ventures were a small part of the family’s business in money terms, but they were a measure of its reach: in the space of a decade the Guggenheims had interests on five continents.

The Congo also shows the limits of what the family histories say. Unger and Unger mention the African ventures briefly, and Davis and O’Connor say little about the labour conditions in which they were carried on.[2][3][4] Belgium annexed the Congo in 1908, and the worst abuses of the rubber regime were curbed, but forced labour continued in other forms throughout the colonial period.[1] Any account of the Guggenheim fortune should acknowledge that it was made in part in places, in the Congo and elsewhere, where the people who did the work had little share in the wealth they produced.

Guggenheim Brothers and the nitrate fields

In 1916 the partnership of M. Guggenheim’s Sons was reorganised as Guggenheim Brothers.[2] The sale of Chuquicamata in 1923 left the firm with a great deal of cash and a strong desire to find a new venture in Chile, where it had built up an unrivalled store of knowledge and contacts. It found it in nitrates.[5]

The deserts of northern Chile held the world’s largest deposits of sodium nitrate, called caliche by the miners and salitre when refined, which had been worked since the middle of the nineteenth century and exported as fertiliser and for the manufacture of explosives. Chile had won the nitrate provinces from Peru and Bolivia in the War of the Pacific of 1879 to 1883, and the export duty on nitrate was for decades the largest single source of the Chilean government’s revenue.[6][5] The industry was dominated by British, German and Chilean producers using a method of extraction, the Shanks process, which had changed little since the 1880s and could profitably work only rich ore.[7][5]

The nitrate fields themselves were a harsh place to work. The oficinas, the processing works scattered across the desert, were company towns where the workers were often paid in tokens redeemable only at the company store, and the industry had a long history of strikes and repression, including the massacre of striking workers and their families at the Santa María school in Iquique in 1907.[6][8] María Elena, the town built by the Guggenheims for their new plant in 1926, survived the collapse of the industry, and it is now the last of the nitrate towns still in operation.[6]

The Guggenheims entered the nitrate trade at the moment when its future was most in doubt. Before the First World War German chemists had developed the Haber-Bosch process for fixing nitrogen from the air, and the first industrial plant had begun production in 1913.[7][6] Cut off from Chilean supplies by the British blockade, Germany expanded synthetic production during the war, and after it the new method spread to other industrial countries. Chilean nitrate, which had been a near monopoly for half a century, now faced a competitor whose costs were falling every year.[7][5] The Guggenheims believed that better technology could cut the cost of mining and refining natural nitrate enough to meet the challenge, and they applied to the Atacama the methods of mass production that had served them in copper.[6][5] Their wager would be tested in the worst possible conditions, as the depression of the 1930s destroyed demand for fertiliser just as their new plants came into production.[7]

The Guggenheim process

Cappelen Smith, the metallurgist who had designed the leaching plant at Chuquicamata, had begun to develop during the war a new process for extracting nitrate from the Chilean ore. By 1922 he had perfected it. It was called the Guggenheim process, and it promised to cut the cost of nitrate production by forty per cent.[5] It used cooler leaching solutions, mechanical handling and refrigeration to crystallise the nitrate, and it could treat ore with as little as seven per cent sodium nitrate, far poorer than the older plants could use.[6][5]

Cappelen Smith, who was now a partner in Guggenheim Brothers, persuaded Murry and Solomon to invest $17 million in Chilean nitrate in 1923 and 1924. Glaser-Schmidt observes that the two brothers remained rather ignorant of the prospects of the international fertiliser trade, but decided to trust their chief engineer’s technical expertise.[5] Guggenheim Brothers acquired the Anglo-Chilean Nitrate and Railway Company and other deposits, and in 1924 the new holdings were reorganised as the Anglo-Chilean Consolidated Nitrate Company.[5] The great new plant, at María Elena in the desert east of Tocopilla, began production in 1926.[5][7]

The venture had, as Glaser-Schmidt puts it, elements of a risky speculative bid.[5] By the mid-1920s synthetic nitrogen made by the Haber-Bosch process was competing with Chilean nitrate in the fertiliser markets of Europe.[5][6] The Guggenheims were betting that a cheaper method of extraction would allow the natural product to hold its own against the synthetic one, and that they had a few years before European mass production conquered the traditional markets.[5]

María Elena, Lautaro and COSACH

At first the bet seemed to pay. A price war in 1925 and 1926 delayed the opening of María Elena, but the years from 1926 to 1929 brought a revival in Chilean nitrate, and the Guggenheim plant proved its efficiency.[5] In 1929 the Guggenheims acquired their most important local competitor, the Lautaro Nitrate Company, with the intention of installing the new process on its deposits. A second large plant, Pedro de Valdivia, was built.[7][5]

Then came the Depression. After a year’s negotiations the Guggenheims and the Chilean state formed a joint venture, the Compañía de Salitre de Chile, or COSACH, which absorbed most of the older producers. Rory Miller describes the hope behind it: that the new firm would monopolise exports and be in a stronger position to negotiate cartel arrangements with the European synthetic producers.[7] COSACH was incorporated in early 1931, with the Guggenheims in control of its management.[5][7] It was immediately overwhelmed. World demand for fertiliser collapsed, the price of nitrate fell, and COSACH could not raise fresh capital. The Chilean government, which had relied on nitrate revenues and on foreign loans, defaulted on its foreign debt in 1931, and the political crisis that followed brought down the government of Carlos Ibáñez.[5] In January 1933 a new Chilean administration announced the liquidation of COSACH.[7]

Glaser-Schmidt calls the nitrate venture the family’s largest business failure and a staggering foreign collapse during the Great Depression, closely intertwined with the Chilean government’s default, and argues that government intervention and mismanagement of the country’s finances were the chief factors in its decline.[5] Miller, working from the Chilean national archives, places more weight on the disruptive effect of synthetic nitrogen and asks hard questions about the managerial competence of the Guggenheims themselves.[7] The two interpretations are not exclusive. The Guggenheims had bought into a declining industry at the top of the market, with a technical advantage that was real but not enough to overcome the competition of chemistry. The family’s capital was much reduced. The great age of the Guggenheims as miners was over, and their history after 1930 is above all a history of what they did with the fortune that remained.

References

OpenClose
  1. Adam Hochschild, King Leopold’s Ghost (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998), print *
  2. Irwin Unger and Debi Unger, The Guggenheims. A Family History (New York: HarperCollins, 2005), print *
  3. John H. Davis, The Guggenheims. An American Epic (New York: William Morrow, 1978), print *
  4. Harvey O’Connor, The Guggenheims. The Making of an American Dynasty (New York: Covici, Friede, 1937), print *
  5. Elisabeth Glaser-Schmidt, “The Guggenheims and the Coming of the Great Depression in Chile, 1923-1934,” Business and Economic History 24, no. 1 (1995), 176 to 185 *
  6. Jaime Wisniak and Ingrid Garcés, “The rise and fall of the salitre (sodium nitrate) industry,” Indian Journal of Chemical Technology 8 (2001) *
  7. Rory Miller, “Disruptive Technologies, Financial Crisis and Political Shocks. The Guggenheims and the Chilean Nitrate Industry, 1926-33,” paper, Business History Conference, 2020 *
  8. Thomas F. O’Brien, The Revolutionary Mission. American Enterprise in Latin America, 1900 to 1945 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), print *

The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Guggenheim index page.

← Contents of Guggenheim