The smelters combine
By the late 1890s the smelting industry of the American West was overbuilt and in the grip of cut-throat competition. Rival plants bid against one another for ore, treatment charges fell, and profits with them. The usual remedy of the age was combination: the formation of a single great company, a trust in the language of the time, that would buy up the competing firms and control prices. Oil, sugar, steel and tobacco had already gone this way, and the smelters followed.[1][2]
The American Smelting and Refining Company was incorporated in New Jersey on 4 April 1899, bringing together, according to the Dictionary of American History, eighteen of the country’s largest smelting companies.[1] Its promoters included Henry H. Rogers of Standard Oil, the financier Leonard Lewisohn and the brothers William and James Moore, and the company was capitalised at about $65 million.[3][2] The Guggenheims were invited to join. They refused. The Mining Foundation of the Southwest says that Guggenheim refused to join and in the following year not only out-produced the trust but also bought up a major interest in it.[4]
The reasons for the refusal were partly financial and partly strategic. The terms offered to the Guggenheims did not reflect, in their view, the value of their plants, and above all they did not want to surrender control. Their Mexican smelters, which were outside the combination’s reach, gave them a source of profit that the trust could not match, and Guggenex gave them access to new mines.[3][5][6]
Strike and stand-off
The new company had a difficult first year. It had paid high prices for its plants and was burdened with a heavy capitalisation that required large profits to service. In the summer of 1899 the Colorado legislature passed a law limiting work in mines and smelters to eight hours a day; the smelting companies resisted, and the smelter workers went on strike. The American Smelting and Refining plants in Colorado were closed for weeks.[3][7] The Guggenheims’ own plants, which were not part of the combination, came to terms with the men and kept running, and the family took business from its rival while the trust’s furnaces were cold. The Encyclopedia of World Biography attributes the trust’s difficulties to overcapitalisation and a damaging strike.[6]
Meanwhile the Guggenheims were also outbidding American Smelting for ore, and they had the advantage of their Mexican plants. The trust’s shares fell. Its directors recognised that they could not shut the Guggenheims out, and that the only way to make the combination work was to bring them in on terms they would accept.[3][5][2]
April 1901
The terms were finally agreed in the spring of 1901. The Guggenheims brought their smelters and refineries into American Smelting and Refining in exchange for a large block of the company’s stock and, crucially, control of its management.[1][3] The Dictionary of American History says that in 1901 the firm of Meyer Guggenheim and his sons, the largest of the independents, joined the trust under terms that ensured them control of American Smelting.[1] The Jewish Encyclopedia says that M. Guggenheim’s Sons retained a controlling interest.[8] The Encyclopedia of World Biography gives the scale of the prize: the Guggenheims joined the company on their own terms and took control of the $100 million corporation as well.[6]
It was one of the most remarkable coups in American business history. A family that had refused to join a trust formed in part to destroy it had, within two years, taken it over. Henry Rogers and the Standard Oil group, who had hoped to dominate the metals industry, were left as minority investors, and the Guggenheims became, in the words of one history, the masters of the American smelting industry.[3][7] The Mining Foundation of the Southwest notes that five of Meyer’s seven sons were eventually elected to the board of American Smelting and Refining, and that the company is remembered above all for its association with the Guggenheims.[4]
The takeover took place in the years when the trusts were the central issue of American politics. The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 had made combinations in restraint of trade illegal, but for a decade it was little enforced, and the years around 1900 saw the greatest wave of mergers in American history.[2][3] The Guggenheims’ success therefore attracted attention as well as admiration, and over the following years American Smelting and Refining was attacked by miners who accused it of paying too little for their ore, by politicians in the western states who saw it as an eastern monopoly, and by Progressive journalists who made the family’s name a symbol of concentrated wealth.[7][3] Harvey O’Connor’s history of 1937, written from the left in the depths of the Depression, is the fullest statement of the case against the family, and it remains valuable for its use of contemporary newspapers and the records of congressional and state inquiries.[7]
Daniel at the head
Daniel Guggenheim became chairman of the board and president of American Smelting and Refining, and he remained at its head until 1919.[3][9] Under his direction the company expanded rapidly, buying smelters, refineries and mines in the United States and Mexico, and later in South America. Murry Guggenheim took charge of its sales of metal, a position that gave him great influence in the markets, and Solomon, Isaac and Simon held seats on the board.[3][5]
Daniel was now the most important figure in the family and one of the most powerful businessmen in America. Contemporaries described him as short, intense, restlessly active and possessed of great personal charm; he was a persuasive negotiator and a good judge of men, and he left the technical work to the engineers he employed while reserving to himself the decisions about where to invest.[3][7] His brothers deferred to him in business, although not always willingly. The partnership principle of equal shares remained, but the authority that had been Meyer’s now belonged to Daniel.
The success of the takeover had a cost to the unity of the family. Benjamin and William, who had worked in the smelters, objected to the way the partnership was run and to the terms of the merger, and in 1900 and 1901 they withdrew from M. Guggenheim’s Sons, taking their share of its capital with them.[3][5] Isaac too reduced his role in the following years. The withdrawal of Benjamin and William meant that neither of them, nor their children, shared in the enormous profits the firm would make over the next two decades from copper, and that difference would shape the lives of the next generation, Benjamin’s daughter Peggy among them.[3][10] Years later William went to court against his brothers, claiming that his withdrawal had cost him a share of profits he should have received, a quarrel that the family histories treat as a measure of how much the copper years had been worth.[3][5]
Under Daniel’s leadership American Smelting and Refining became one of the largest industrial companies in the United States. It bought mines as well as smelters in the American West, in Mexico and later in South America, and it built up a business in refining and selling metals that made it, for most of the first half of the twentieth century, the dominant force in the American markets for lead, silver and copper.[11][3] The family’s share of the profits came not only through their holdings of its stock but also through the separate companies they kept in their own hands, which sold ore to the trust and bought its services. Critics in the press and in Congress complained of the conflicts of interest this created, and the brothers’ rivals accused them of using the trust to enrich their private ventures at the expense of other shareholders.[11][12] The brothers answered that their private ventures carried risks the trust could not take, and that its shareholders shared in the rewards when they succeeded.[3]
The death of Meyer
Barbara Guggenheim died in 1900, and Meyer, who had loved her deeply, survived her by five years. He spent his last years in New York and in the warmth of Florida. He died at Palm Beach on 15 March 1905, at the age of seventy-seven.[6][12] The New York Times called him a great merchant who had become almost instantly a great miner, and praised his powers of adaptation and careful management.[12] The Encyclopedia of World Biography adds that he maintained nominal ties with his Orthodox Jewish faith, although he apparently had few religious commitments, and that his business success owed much to his seven sons, whom he had trained to become one of the best management teams in the nation.[6]
His estate was large, and the firm he had founded was larger still. In 1905 M. Guggenheim’s Sons controlled American Smelting and Refining, the largest metals company in the United States, with smelters and refineries across the West and Mexico. Over the next decade it would move into copper on a scale that would make the Guggenheims, for a time, the dominant power in the industry. The first of the new copper ventures took the brothers to one of the remotest places in the world, the mountains of Alaska.[3][8]
References
OpenClose
- “Smelters,” Dictionary of American History, reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Isaac F. Marcosson, Metal Magic. The Story of the American Smelting and Refining Company (New York: Farrar, Straus, 1949), print *
- Irwin Unger and Debi Unger, The Guggenheims. A Family History (New York: HarperCollins, 2005), print *
- Mining Foundation of the Southwest, “Meyer Guggenheim,” American Mining Hall of Fame *
- John H. Davis, The Guggenheims. An American Epic (New York: William Morrow, 1978), print *
- “Meyer Guggenheim,” Encyclopedia of World Biography, reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Harvey O’Connor, The Guggenheims. The Making of an American Dynasty (New York: Covici, Friede, 1937), print *
- Isidore Singer et al., “Guggenheim, Meyer,” Jewish Encyclopedia (New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1901 to 1906) *
- “Daniel Guggenheim,” biographical entries reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Peggy Guggenheim, Out of This Century. Confessions of an Art Addict (New York: Universe Books, 1979), print *
- Thomas F. O’Brien, The Revolutionary Mission. American Enterprise in Latin America, 1900 to 1945 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996), print *
- Obituary of Meyer Guggenheim, The New York Times, 17 March 1905 *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Guggenheim index page.