By the late 1920s many of the collectors who had made the firm’s fortune were dead. Morgan and Altman had died in 1913, Frick in 1919, Arabella Huntington in 1924 and Henry Huntington in 1927. Brewer observes that Duveen’s life changed little in the 1920s and 1930s: he continued to cultivate a succession of extremely rich clients, “replacing those who died with new millionaires like Andrew Mellon, Julius Bache, and Samuel H. Kress”.[1] He also went on buying collections whole.
The Benson pictures
In 1927 Duveen bought the collection of Robert H. Benson in England, 114 Italian paintings.[2] Benson, a London banker, had formed one of the most important private collections of Italian Renaissance pictures in Britain, and its purchase gave Duveen exactly the kind of stock that his American clients now wanted.
The Dreyfus collection
Three years later he bought the collection of Gustave Dreyfus in Paris, Italian paintings and sculpture.[2] Time magazine told its history in July 1930. Dreyfus, a banker, had bought the collection of the critic Charles Timbal during the siege of Paris in 1870 and added to it over the next twenty years. He died in 1914, and under French law the collection was divided among his son and three daughters; the son wanted to keep it together, but his sisters preferred the money.[3] For ten years dealers had understood that it was for sale at a sufficient price. “Only last week,” Time reported, “before the potent checkbook of suave Sir Joseph Duveen, did the Dreyfuses capitulate”.[3]
The price was not disclosed. Other dealers wagered, Time said, that if Duveen had not paid the appraised price of $6,000,000 he had paid something very close to it; Brewer gives $5 million.[3][1] The collection was particularly strong in sculpture, with works attributed to Verrocchio, Donatello, Leonardo, Mino da Fiesole, Bertoldo di Giovanni and Andrea Riccio, paintings by Giovanni Bellini, Filippo Lippi, Pesellino and Ghirlandaio, and a collection of medals and small bronzes.[3] Duveen sold selections from it to Andrew Mellon and Samuel H. Kress, and these formed the core of the National Gallery’s collections in Washington; as late as 1939 he was still selling works from the Benson and Dreyfus purchases.[2]
A roster of clients
The New Yorker’s list of the firm’s clients in 1928 included, besides the great names of the earlier period, John D. Rockefeller Jr., Clarence H. Mackay, Otto Kahn, Jules Bache, Charles P. Taft and Henry Goldman.[4] The Rockefellers had been buying Chinese porcelain from the Duveens since about 1915, and photographs of their house on West Fifty-Fourth Street show it filled with pieces from the firm.[5]
The firm’s reach was global. The New Yorker reported in 1928 that Duveen had agents all over Europe and in China and Japan, and that dealers said it was almost impossible to start negotiations for an important work of art anywhere in the world without his hearing of it and, if he felt so disposed, “barging in”.[4] He and Lady Duveen divided their time roughly equally between America and Europe; for many years they lived at the Plaza Hotel in New York before taking a house at 15 East Ninety-First Street, and in summer they made long motor tours on the Continent with their daughter Dorothy, partly for pleasure and partly to keep in touch with the market.[4]
Duveen’s service to such clients went well beyond selling pictures. The archive’s history records that he arranged their travel, designed their table settings and kept their favourite cigars in the firm’s vaults.[2] He was “a dapper, social animal”, in Vignon’s description, dining at the best restaurants and becoming friends with his famous customers.[5]
The depression
The crash of 1929 hit the art market hard. The story of Rembrandt’s Aristotle shows how Duveen handled it: when Alfred W. Erickson needed money after the crash, Duveen took the picture back for $500,000, and sold it to him again in 1936 when he had recovered.[1] Not every client was so manageable. Brewer notes that some, like the collector Carl Hamilton, were quite capable of bamboozling him, and that in his last years Duveen fought “a costly and unsuccessful law suit with the shady collector Carl Hamilton”.[1] Kenneth Clark later remarked that when Duveen was present “everyone behaved as if they had had a couple of drinks”,[1] and the firm’s optimism was one of its assets through the depression years.
Samuel H. Kress
The most important new client was Samuel Henry Kress. Born in 1863 and originally a schoolteacher in Pennsylvania, he opened a stationery and notions shop in 1887 that grew into the nationwide chain of S. H. Kress and Company.[6] He began collecting in his fifties, concentrating on Italian painting and sculpture, and in 1929 set up the Kress Foundation.[6] Brewer counts 3,210 works of art in the collection he amassed.[1]
Kress was exactly the kind of client Duveen needed in the 1930s: rich, enthusiastic, interested in the Italian pictures that were the firm’s speciality, and planning to give his collection away. He abandoned his plans for a museum of his own and became the first collector to answer Mellon’s call for gifts to the new National Gallery; for its opening he gave 393 Italian paintings and sculptures.[6]
The Allendale Nativity
The last great sale of Duveen’s career concerned an Adoration of the Shepherds that belonged to Viscount Allendale at Bretton Hall in Yorkshire. Its history went back to the collection of Cardinal Fesch, Napoleon’s uncle, whose sale in Rome in 1845 dispersed it; it was bought in London in 1847 for Thomas Wentworth Beaumont and descended in his family, the Barons and Viscounts Allendale.[7] Experts disagreed about whether it was by Giorgione or by his pupil Titian, and Duveen knew that a genuine Giorgione was far rarer and far more valuable.[8]
Duveen had long wanted it. In 1937, knowing he was very ill, he finally secured it.[8] The firm’s general stock book records it as “Purchased Aug. 3, 1937”.[7] Cohen says that Duveen paid $315,000.[8] He bought it with Mellon in mind, but Mellon died that month.[9][6]
Berenson was on record as calling the picture an early Titian. Duveen and Fowles cabled him in Cyprus; it took several efforts to get a grumpy reaffirmation of his view.[8] Fowles had to explain that they had bought it at “not … even a Titian price, but a Giorgione price … We must sell it as Giorgione”.[8] Fowles was sent to I Tatti with the picture, to no avail. Berenson dictated angry letters to Nicky Mariano, declaring that it would be “utterly below his self-respect, let alone his dignity, to be kept on as a pet, and not as an unquestioned authority”.[8]
There was money at stake on both sides. Berenson had been angry for years that the firm owed him $150,000; under their current contract, Duveen stood to gain $40,000 if Berenson left.[8] The argument lasted through the summer and autumn of 1937. Finally Fowles cabled Duveen: “BERNARD INSISTS TITIAN, SO HAVE ACCEPTED RESIGNATION”.[8] The partnership of twenty-five years was over.
A Christmas window
In 1938 Duveen sold the picture to the Kress Foundation, for $400,000 according to Cohen.[8][7] The firm’s letter to Kress of 21 June 1938 survives in its records.[7] Kress, untroubled by Berenson’s scruples about mixing art and commerce, displayed his new Nativity in the window of his Fifth Avenue store at Christmas.[8][9] In 1939 the Kress Foundation gave it to the National Gallery of Art, where it hangs today as Giorgione’s Adoration of the Shepherds.[7]
Duveen, it turned out, was probably right. Brewer notes that his attribution to Giorgione “has much modern scholarly support”,[1] and in his last lists Berenson himself came round to the consensus that the picture was probably by Giorgione, while maintaining that Titian had a hand in the Virgin and the landscape.[8] Schjeldahl detects “a dank whiff of neurosis” in Berenson’s decision to stand against his patron, in error.[9]
The Allendale Nativity was Duveen’s last triumph as a dealer. By the time Kress put it in his shop window, the man who had sold it was dying.
References
OpenClose
- John Brewer, “The Art of the Deal”, The New York Review of Books, 7 October 2004 *
- Getty Research Institute, Finding aid for the Duveen Brothers records, 1876 to 1981 (accession no. 960015) *
- “Art. Sir Joseph and His Brethren”, Time, 21 July 1930 *
- Alva Johnston, “Noble Merchandise”, The New Yorker, 21 April 1928 *
- Wendy Moonan, “The Family That Brought European Luxury to America’s Gilded Age Tycoons”, 1stDibs Introspective, 1 September 2019 *
- National Gallery of Art, “Founding Benefactors of the National Gallery of Art” (archived July 2024) *
- Samuel H. Kress Foundation, “The Adoration of the Shepherds”, Kress Collection catalogue entry (K509) *
- Rachel Cohen, “Priceless. How Art Became Commerce”, The New Yorker, 8 October 2012 *
- Peter Schjeldahl, “Masterpieces for Sale”, The New Yorker, 8 November 2004 *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Duveen index page.