Skip to content

Andrew Mellon and Washington

Andrew William Mellon, born in Pittsburgh in 1855, entered his family’s bank at nineteen and became one of the richest men in America. He was Secretary of the Treasury from 1921 to 1932 under Harding, Coolidge and Hoover, and then ambassador to Britain in 1932 and 1933.[1] He had bought pictures in Pittsburgh, but he began collecting more ambitiously after he came to Washington in 1921.[1] He was quiet, shy and careful, everything that Joseph Duveen was not.

The mordant Mr Mellon

Mellon was not easily dazzled. Brewer quotes his sardonic reply to one of Duveen’s outbursts of praise for a picture: “Lord Duveen, my pictures never look so marvelous as when you are here!”.[2] His son Paul thought Duveen “an impossibly bumptious and opinionated ass”.[3] But Mellon kept buying. Colin Simpson, quoted by Philip Kopper in his history of the National Gallery of Art, wrote that Mellon spent over $3 million at Duveen’s, that the two men invited each other to their daughters’ weddings, and that Duveen made many of the European arrangements for the honeymoon of Mellon’s daughter Ailsa.[3]

Servants on the payroll

The relationship rested partly on intelligence. Brewer lists among the firm’s morally dubious methods “spying on customers (Andrew Mellon was followed around for years), reading the contents of their wastebaskets, and bribing their servants for information”.[2] According to Simpson, the relationship suffered a setback in 1927 when Mellon came to suspect that Duveen had an inside source of information about his affairs. He was right: his valet, Flore, and his butler, Tom Kerr, were both on the payroll of Duveen’s majordomo, Bert Boggis.[3] It was said that while Mellon was at the Treasury, the contents of his wastebasket would be known at Duveen’s New York office in the time it took the Secretary to walk home.[3]

Nicholas Penny, when director of the National Gallery in London, put it more generally: “There was a lot of espionage … A lot of maids and butlers being paid by rival dealers. Duveen himself had lots and lots of servants in his pay”.[4]

A museum for the nation

Duveen encouraged Mellon’s idea of a national gallery in Washington. When the two men visited the National Gallery in Trafalgar Square together in 1928, Duveen told him that in time such a gallery would offer travelling shows, concerts and study collections; according to Simpson, Mellon “was entranced”, and told Theodore Rousseau a few days later that Duveen had shown him “what a government could do with a museum if it wished”.[3] As late as 1936 Duveen asked Kenneth Clark for information about the London gallery’s rules and organisation to pass on to Mellon.[3]

Kopper is careful to add that the dream was Mellon’s own. He had long haunted the National Gallery in London, had been embarrassed when visiting dignitaries asked to see the nation’s art treasures and he had to take them to his own apartment, and had told his children of his plans by 1927.[3]

In 1928 Mellon bought from Duveen Raphael’s Niccolini-Cowper Madonna, a departure from his usual taste for portraits and landscapes and the kind of painting that a national museum had to have.[3] In 1930 he bought from Duveen Verrocchio’s unfired clay Putto Poised on a Globe.[3] His most spectacular purchases, the twenty-one paintings he bought from the Hermitage Museum in 1930 and 1931, did not come through Duveen at all; the Soviets refused to deal with him.[3][1]

Credit from the client

The arrangement suited Duveen’s finances as well as Mellon’s taste. Mellon liked to live with a picture before buying it and often kept consignments for months. Kopper explains that this gave Duveen ready credit in Mellon’s banks: he had the use of Mellon money, at going rates of interest, while Mellon made up his mind.[3] Schjeldahl describes the same practice, of borrowing from Mellon to buy pictures that he then sold to Mellon at a large mark-up, as one of Duveen’s financial “works of art”.[5]

The sale of 1936

As the winter of 1936 approached, Duveen told Mellon: “I am going to retire from business. You are ready to give your collection for a national gallery. This is a combination of circumstances that can never happen again”.[3] Mellon, eighty-one and ill, could not go to New York, so he sent his aide David Finley, with instructions to bring back “everything [Finley] thought good enough for the National Gallery”. Finley spent three days in a “velvet-hung room” at the Duveen gallery while handlers brought in works for his inspection, and returned with a selection of thirty paintings and twenty-one sculptures.[3]

Mellon was too ill even to travel the dozen blocks to the Corcoran Gallery’s basement, so Finley arranged for Duveen to rent the flat below Mellon’s in the McCormick apartment building in Washington and turn it into a private gallery. Duveen installed the works, posted an armed guard and gave Mellon a key. Mellon used it often, entertaining guests there and coming down alone late at night in dressing gown and slippers to look at the pictures.[3]

Finley was the only witness to the negotiation. “Lord Duveen asked astronomical prices. Mr. Mellon countered with lower ones. At one point Mr. Mellon said: ‘Well, Lord Duveen, I think you will have to take all these things back to New York,’ and Lord Duveen replied: ‘Mr. Mellon, I would give you these things for the National Gallery rather than take them away'”.[3]

The sources differ on what was bought and for how much. Kopper says that Mellon bought twenty-four of the paintings and eighteen of the sculptures for $8 million.[3] Brewer, following Secrest, says twenty-six paintings and eighteen sculptures for $21 million.[2] The National Gallery’s own account says simply that in 1936 Mellon acquired forty-two works of painting and sculpture in a single transaction with a major art dealer.[1] Forty-two is the total of Kopper’s figures; the price remains uncertain.

The tax case

The sale took place while Mellon was fighting the Roosevelt administration over his taxes. After Roosevelt came to power the Attorney General, Homer Cummings, announced before going to a grand jury that Mellon was suspected of tax evasion; a grand jury in Pittsburgh declined to indict, but the Internal Revenue Bureau claimed that he had underpaid his taxes for 1931 by $2,050,068, and with penalties and interest assessed him for $3,075,103.[3] The case went before the Board of Tax Appeals in 1935, with Robert Jackson leading for the government.[3]

One of the issues was the A. W. Mellon Educational and Charitable Trust, set up on the last day of 1930, to which Mellon had deeded Hermitage pictures; the government argued that he had not given up control of them.[3] Duveen gave evidence for the defence. Kopper says that his “bombastic testimony … did little besides provide comic relief”, but that it confirmed that Mellon had long intended to build a national gallery for his paintings.[3]

On Christmas Day 1936 Mellon wrote to President Roosevelt offering his collection and a building to the nation.[1] Congress created the National Gallery of Art on 24 March 1937.[1] Mellon died on 26 August 1937, soon after construction began.[1] On 7 December 1937 the board ruled that he owed $485,809 but acknowledged that he “did not file a false and fraudulent return with the purpose of evading taxes”; the Dictionary of American Biography called it “a complete vindication”.[3] Kopper dismisses as a canard the story that the gift was the price of settling the tax case.[3]

Mellon’s gift comprised 126 paintings and twenty-six works of sculpture, and at his suggestion Congress stipulated that no work should ever be added to the gallery “unless it be of a similar high standard of quality”.[1] Asked why he persisted with the gift while the government pursued him, he said: “Eventually the people now in power in Washington will be dead and I will be dead, but the National Gallery, I hope, will be there and that is something the country needs”.[3]

The National Gallery of Art opened on 17 March 1941, eighteen months after Duveen’s death.[1] Its founding collections, Mellon’s above all, then Kress’s and Widener’s, were full of works that had passed through his hands. Penny observed that if one searched the gallery’s online collection for works supplied by Duveen, one could stop at a hundred pages: “The National Gallery of Art in Washington is in large part there because of Duveen”.[4] Vignon counts some two thousand objects obtained through the Duveens in the gallery.[6]

The building was designed by John Russell Pope, the American architect who also designed the sculpture galleries that Duveen gave to the Tate.[7] Schjeldahl notes that in his last years Duveen “concentrated on channelling Duveens to the National Gallery in Washington”.[5] Mellon was not the only collector who would help him do it.

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Duveen