Titles from Vienna
The Rothschilds’ services to the allied powers brought honours, and the honours came from Vienna. In 1816 the Austrian emperor Francis I raised four of the brothers, Amschel, Salomon, Carl and James, to the hereditary Austrian nobility, with the right to the particle “von”. The Neue Deutsche Biographie dates the grant to 1816; the Rothschild Archive gives 1817 for the patent, and the difference probably reflects the gap between the decision and the issue of the formal document. Nathan, settled in England, was ennobled separately.[1][2] In 1822 all five brothers were made barons, Freiherren, of the Austrian Empire.[1][2]
With the title came a coat of arms. Its central device was a hand grasping five arrows, a symbol of the five brothers bound together, and its motto was Concordia, Integritas, Industria, “harmony, integrity, industry”.[2][3] Five arrows remained the family’s emblem for the next two centuries and can still be seen on its buildings, wine labels and publications.
The brothers wore their titles in different ways. James in Paris became “Baron James”, and he served for decades as the Austrian consul general there. Salomon in Vienna used his barony in a city where, as a Jew, he still faced legal restrictions on owning property. In London, Nathan did not use the Austrian title at all, and his sons used it only after Queen Victoria gave them permission to do so by royal licence, published in the London Gazette in June 1838.[4][5] For the family the honours were both a mark of acceptance and a tool of business: a title made it easier to deal with ministers and courts, and the consular posts that several of the brothers held gave them official standing and diplomatic channels of communication.
Hep! Hep! in Frankfurt
The titles did not make the brothers equal citizens of their own city. In Frankfurt the emancipation that Dalberg had granted in 1811, and that the community had paid 440,000 florins to obtain, did not survive Napoleon’s fall. The restored free city withdrew the Jews’ civil rights in 1816, and the community spent years petitioning the Congress of Vienna and the German Confederation to restore them.[1][6] Amschel, as head of the parent house, was at the centre of these efforts, and the brothers used their influence with Metternich and the Prussian government on the community’s behalf.
In August 1819 a wave of anti-Jewish riots spread through the German states. It began in Würzburg on 2 August, where students led attacks on Jewish shops and homes, and took its name from the rioters’ cry of “Hep! Hep!”. The Encyclopaedia Judaica records that in Frankfurt, where the dispute over civil rights had been particularly bitter, “the houses of the Rothschilds became a special object of attack”, and the senate restored order only with difficulty, using police and troops. The Rothschilds’ response was to threaten to leave Frankfurt, and Germany, if the violence did not stop. The Encyclopaedia judges that threat to have been more effective than anything else the Jewish communities did.[7]
The riots passed, but equality did not follow. In 1824 the Frankfurt senate granted the Jews equality in civil matters while reinstating many of the old discriminatory laws, and full emancipation came only after the revolution of 1848 had shaken the old order. It was finally achieved in 1864.[6] For half a century, then, the barons of the Austrian Empire, who lent to kings and were received by emperors, were second-class citizens of the city where their firm had its headquarters.
The family’s campaign for the Frankfurt community was long and expensive, and it shows how their new standing could and could not be used. Verity’s account describes the brothers lobbying the Federal Diet of the German Confederation, which sat in Frankfurt from 1815, where Prussia and Austria were sympathetic but the Austrian presiding envoy, Count Buol-Schauenstein, was hostile to the Jews. In his telling, it took until 1822, and the replacement of Buol by Baron von Münch-Bellinghausen with instructions from Metternich to settle the Jewish question, before the Diet pressed the city to compromise.[8] The outcome was the partial settlement of 1824 described above, which granted equality in civil matters while keeping many of the old restrictions in force.[6] Even the most powerful Jewish family in Europe could not buy full citizenship for its own community; it could only make the authorities in Vienna and Berlin take the question seriously.
The family’s relationship with Frankfurt’s Jewish community was close and sometimes contentious. The community was divided between reformers and the traditionally observant, and when the Orthodox minority formed its own religious association in 1851 under Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, the Rothschilds made a large donation towards the building of its new synagogue.[6] Amschel himself was strictly observant, and his nephews in Frankfurt, especially Wilhelm Carl, remained among the most traditional members of the family.
Damascus, 1840
The family’s international standing was tested in 1840 by an episode that became a turning point in modern Jewish politics. On 5 February 1840 a Capuchin friar, Father Thomas, and his Muslim servant disappeared in Damascus, then under Egyptian rule. The French consul, Count Ratti-Menton, encouraged the accusation that the local Jews had murdered them to use their blood for ritual purposes. Several Jews were arrested and tortured; some died, and others “confessed”.[9]
The Austrian consul general in Egypt, Anton Laurin, tried and failed to restrain his French colleague. He then took the unusual step of sending his report on the affair to James de Rothschild, the honorary Austrian consul in Paris, asking him to intervene with the French government. When that brought no result, James published the report in the press, without Metternich’s authorisation, to alert public opinion. In Vienna Salomon approached Metternich directly.[9]
The French government stood by its consul. Replying to critics in the Chamber of Deputies in June, the prime minister Adolphe Thiers declared that while they protested “in the name of the Jews”, he protested “in the name of a Frenchman who until now has carried out his duties with honour and loyalty”. It was after that debate, the Encyclopaedia Judaica notes, that the representative bodies of French and British Jewry, the Consistoire Central and the Board of Deputies, decided to send a high-level delegation to the Middle East, led by Adolphe Crémieux and Moses Montefiore, Nathan Rothschild’s brother-in-law.[9][10]
The delegation was received by Muhammad Ali in Egypt and then went on to Constantinople. The surviving prisoners in Damascus were freed by an order of 28 August 1840, and the sultan in Constantinople later issued a firman declaring the blood libel to be false and forbidding the trial of Jews on such charges.[9] In the Jewish memory of the affair, it ended happily. But the Encyclopaedia Judaica points out that a hostile version was put into circulation almost at once, and that a two-volume work published in Paris in 1846 printed the interrogation protocols as though they were evidence of guilt.[9]
The Damascus affair established a pattern that would last for the rest of the century. Jews in danger in one country appealed to their co-religionists in another, and the wealthy and well-connected families of London and Paris, the Rothschilds above all, were expected to use their access to governments on their behalf. It gave the family a role that went far beyond banking. It also fed the suspicion, which their enemies would exploit, that the Rothschilds were a power in international affairs answerable to no state.
References
OpenClose
- Manfred Pohl, “Rothschild, Mayer (auch: Meyer) Amschel,” Neue Deutsche Biographie 22 (2005), pp. 131–133, Deutsche Biographie online *
- The Rothschild Archive, “The Rothschild name and arms” *
- Justin Cavernelis-Frost, “Intended for magnificent business. The enduring legacy of New Court,” eabh bulletin (2019/20) *
- Victor Gray and Melanie Aspey (eds.), “Nathan Mayer Rothschild. A chronology,” in The Life and Times of N M Rothschild 1777–1836 (London, 1998) *
- The London Gazette, issue 19628, 22 June 1838, p. 1414 *
- “Frankfurt on the Main,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- “Hep! Hep!,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- William Verity, “The Rise of the Rothschilds,” History Today 18, no. 4 (April 1968) *
- “Damascus Affair,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- “Montefiore, Sir Moses,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Rothschild index page.