Loans for the restored monarchies
The peace settlement of 1815 left Europe’s governments exhausted and in debt. Prussia, Austria, Russia, the restored Bourbons in France, Spain and Naples, and a host of smaller states all needed to borrow, and the Congress system, the “Concert of Europe” that the great powers created to keep the peace, needed money as much as it needed diplomacy. In the fifteen years after Waterloo the Rothschild brothers became the bankers of that order.[1][2]
The first great step was a Prussian loan of 1818. Its significance, as Niall Ferguson explains, lay less in its size, £5 million, than in its form. Instead of a loan in thalers raised in Berlin, Nathan offered British investors a Prussian bond denominated in sterling, with the interest payable in London. Foreign government debt became something an English investor could buy and hold like a British consol, and London became a market for the bonds of other states. The model was copied again and again in the following decades.[2] The Rothschild Archive’s chronology of Nathan’s life records it as the family’s “first post-Congress loan”, £5 million at 5 per cent, and notes that in the same year the combined capital of the Rothschild houses stood at £1,772,000, of which Nathan’s share was £500,000.[3]
Not every door opened at once. When France had to pay its war indemnity to the allies, the great loans of 1817 and 1818 went to the established houses of Baring Brothers and Hope & Co., and the Rothschilds were left out. James, by then a fixture in Paris, worked his way into French government finance over the following years, and in 1823 a French 5 per cent loan of £18.5 million was contracted in collaboration with James’s bank in Paris.[2][3] The Austrian connection followed a similar path. Metternich’s government turned to the family for a series of loans from 1820, and the Austrian army’s intervention in Naples in 1821 was financed in part through Rothschild operations, which, as we have seen, is why Carl settled there.[4][5]
Contemporaries noticed. In the twelfth canto of Don Juan, published in 1823, Byron asked who “hold the balance of the world”, who “reign / O’er congress, whether royalist or liberal”, and answered: “Jew Rothschild, and his fellow-Christian, Baring.” Those two, and the Parisian banker Jacques Laffitte, he went on, “are the true lords of Europe. Every loan / Is not a merely speculative hit, / But seats a nation or upsets a throne.”[6] Byron’s lines were satire, and they joined the Rothschilds to their Christian rivals as a single class of money-power. But the image of a Jewish banker who could make or unmake kings would have a long and much uglier future.
The crisis of 1825
The family’s standing in London was cemented by a crisis. In December 1825 a speculative boom in Latin American bonds and mining shares collapsed, dozens of country banks failed, and the Bank of England itself came close to running out of gold. Nathan was able to help. Through his brothers he obtained gold coin from the Continent, above all from France, and supplied it to the Bank, which used it to meet the demands of its creditors until the panic subsided.[2] The family’s own chronology of Nathan’s life puts it simply: he “averts a national banking crisis, by depositing substantial quantities of gold with the Bank of England to shore up reserves”.[3]
The episode showed what the five-city partnership could do in an emergency, and it changed the relationship between the Rothschilds and the institutions of the City. A family that had arrived in London as foreign cloth dealers a generation earlier was now a lender of last resort to the lender of last resort. It also showed the partnership’s limits. The brothers’ letters from these years are full of anxiety about their exposure, and their caution in the following decades, their reluctance to lend to governments they thought unsound and their preference for short-term operations over industrial investment, owed something to the fright of 1825.[2]
Compensation for slave owners
One loan from these years has attracted particular attention in recent times. In 1833 Parliament passed the Slavery Abolition Act, which ended slavery in most of the British colonies from August 1834. Under pressure from the slave-owning interest, the Act provided £20 million to compensate owners for the loss of what it called “the Services of the Slaves”. The enslaved people themselves received nothing, and were forced to work for their former owners for several more years as “apprentices”.[7]
The money had to be borrowed. In 1835 a syndicate led by Nathan Rothschild and his brother-in-law Moses Montefiore underwrote three new issues of government securities to raise £15 million; the remaining £5 million was paid directly in government stock. The historian Nicholas Draper, quoted by the fact-checking organisation Full Fact, notes that it is not known how much of the issue the syndicate retained and how much it sold on.[7][8] The loan was consolidated with other government debt in 1927, and the stock into which it had been folded was finally redeemed in 2015. As Full Fact points out, that does not mean that the whole of the 1835 loan was outstanding until 2015, and no one knows how much of it was.[7]
The episode is a reminder that the Rothschilds’ business was the business of the British state, including its morally compromised parts. It also needs to be kept in proportion. The compensation scheme was the policy of Parliament, the loan was syndicated among many investors, and the Rothschild role, as underwriters, was the role they played in many other government loans of the period. The payments themselves were made to many thousands of claimants, and a Bank of England working paper published in 2022 traces how the compensation was collected through the Bank between 1835 and 1843.[8]
The death of Nathan
By the 1830s the Rothschilds had extended their business far beyond loans to the Concert powers. They lent to Belgium after its independence in 1830, to Portugal, Brazil and Spain, and to a growing number of smaller states. In the mid-1830s Lionel concluded a contract with the Spanish government to market the output of the mercury mines of Almadén, which, as the Archive’s chronology notes, gave the Rothschilds a virtual worldwide monopoly of a metal essential to refining gold and silver.[3][2] They dealt in bullion on a vast scale, acted as agents for central banks and governments, and were among the largest dealers in bills of exchange in Europe.
In June 1836 the whole family gathered in Frankfurt for the wedding of Nathan’s eldest son Lionel to Charlotte, the daughter of his brother Carl. Nathan fell ill there and died in Frankfurt on 28 July 1836, aged fifty-eight, the victim, in the Archive chronology’s words, of “a poorly treated ischio-rectal abscess”. His body was brought back to London, and on 8 August, with a procession of seventy-five carriages leaving New Court, he was buried in the east London cemetery of the Great Synagogue.[3][9] The London house passed to his sons, Lionel at its head, under the guidance that Nathan’s will had given to Hannah.[10]
Within a few weeks of his death, the Times and other papers were speculating about the size of his fortune, and pamphlets and caricatures continued to portray him as the master of the Stock Exchange. The reality was less dramatic but more durable. Nathan had built a firm that was respected for reliability rather than daring: it paid its debts, honoured its commitments and lent to governments it trusted. That reputation, and the partnership that sustained it, would carry the family through the revolutions of the next generation.
References
OpenClose
- Henry Wasserman, Simon R. Schwarzfuchs and Vivian David Lipman, “Rothschild,” Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., reprinted at Encyclopedia.com *
- Niall Ferguson, The House of Rothschild. Volume 1, Money’s Prophets 1798–1848 (London: Penguin, 1999; first published 1998) *
- Victor Gray and Melanie Aspey (eds.), “Nathan Mayer Rothschild. A chronology,” in The Life and Times of N M Rothschild 1777–1836 (London, 1998) *
- The Rothschild Archive, “The Vienna house, S M von Rothschild” *
- The Rothschild Archive, “The Naples house, C M de Rothschild e figli” *
- Lord Byron, Don Juan, Canto XII (1823), stanzas 5–6, Project Gutenberg edition *
- Full Fact, “This is what we know about the government loan to pay slave owners compensation after slavery was abolished in 1833” *
- Bank of England, “The collection of slavery compensation, 1835–43,” Staff Working Paper (2022) *
- Justin Cavernelis-Frost, “Intended for magnificent business. The enduring legacy of New Court,” eabh bulletin (2019/20) *
- Miriam Rothschild, “Rothschild Women,” Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women, Jewish Women’s Archive *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Rothschild index page.