Skip to content

The legend of Waterloo

A story told too often

The battle of Waterloo was fought on Sunday 18 June 1815, a few miles south of Brussels. Wellington’s official dispatch announcing the victory reached London at about eleven o’clock on the night of Wednesday 21 June. In between lies one of the most durable stories in financial history: that Nathan Rothschild knew of the victory before anyone else in London and used his knowledge to make a vast fortune on the Stock Exchange.[1]

The story has been told so often that it is widely taken as fact. Brian Cathcart, who examined it for the Rothschild Archive’s annual review, points out that Elizabeth Longford repeated it in her biography of Wellington in the 1970s, and that a version appeared in Niall Ferguson’s history of the family. A second, darker claim usually accompanies it: that Rothschild did not merely profit from early news but used some kind of deception to multiply his gains. That version, Cathcart notes, found its way into the Encyclopaedia Britannica, the Dictionary of National Biography, histories of Waterloo, of the Stock Exchange and of British Jewry, works on business and intelligence, and novels.[1]

Cathcart’s conclusion is blunt. “The story is more legend than fact.” Nothing in the surviving record suggests that Rothschild was the first in London to know of the victory, and there is good evidence that another man had that distinction. Rothschild probably did make a profit that week, but it can only have been modest compared with the fortunes made by others, and “there is no question of trickery”.[1] How a tale so poorly supported came to be believed is, as he says, a curiosity in its own right, and there is no escaping the part that antisemitism played in it.

Satan, a fisherman and a storm

The decisive moment in the legend’s history came not in 1815 but in 1846. In that year a pamphlet appeared in Paris under the title Histoire édifiante et curieuse de Rothschild Ier, roi des Juifs, “the edifying and curious history of Rothschild the First, king of the Jews”. Its author signed himself simply “Satan”. It was an attack on James de Rothschild as a ruthless capitalist and an enemy of the French people, and, according to Cathcart, it sold across Europe in tens of thousands of copies.[1] Its author was the journalist Georges Mathieu-Dairnvaell, writing at a moment, discussed in a later chapter, when the Rothschilds were under fierce attack in France over a fatal railway accident.[2]

“Satan” supplied the dramatic details that have clung to the story ever since. Nathan, he claimed, watched the battle in person, rode in haste to the coast, and bullied and bribed a fisherman into carrying him to England through a terrible storm. Arriving in London twenty-four hours ahead of the official news, he “gained twenty million in a single coup”. This, the pamphlet insisted, was typical of the family’s cynical profiteering at the expense of the French: “This family is our evil genius.”[1]

Ink-and-watercolour illustration of a colonnaded courtyard crowded with men and a few women in Regency dress. A tall young man in a dark coat argues with an elderly man holding a newspaper, a Black merchant in a blue coat listens closely, and others compare notes and papers.
Merchants and brokers trade news and prices in a London exchange courtyard in June 1815, when reports of the fighting in Belgium arrived from several directions at once.

Later writers embellished the tale. The most important addition was trading trickery. No sooner had Nathan reached the City, it was said, than he spread rumours that Wellington had lost, sold heavily to drive prices down, and then bought at the bottom, so doubling the gains he made when the victory became known. The fullest version appeared in a German history of the Rothschilds by Ignatius Balla in 1913. One historian, quoted by Cathcart, imagined the scene at the Stock Exchange: “We cannot estimate how many liveried servants, how many Watteaus and Rembrandts, how many thoroughbreds in his descendants’ stables, the man by the pillar won that single day.”[1]

By then the story was under strain. Anyone who knew the history of the battle knew that Nathan Rothschild had not been there. Friends of the family, uncomfortable with an ugly tale, put forward alternatives that would explain his early knowledge without the villainy. One was that the news came by carrier pigeon, which Cathcart dismisses as “pure fantasy”: there was no organised pigeon post in England in 1815 and no trace of one in the family’s records. Another came from the journalist and historian Lucien Wolf, who was friendly to the family. Wolf claimed that Nathan had arranged relays of couriers from Brussels and a fast boat waiting off the coast, and he appeared to be supported by the diary of a young American, James Gallatin, which recorded on the day of the battle that “Monsieur Rothschild has mounted couriers from Brussels to Ostend and a fast clipper ready to sail”. But the Gallatin diary was later shown to be a fake, concocted near the end of the nineteenth century, and nothing in Nathan’s business correspondence supports the idea of a special courier service set up in advance.[1]

What the evidence shows

The most serious version of the story came from the Duke of Wellington himself. On several occasions in the 1820s and 1830s, long before “Satan” wrote, Wellington said privately that Rothschild had been brought the news by an agent who was in Ghent, where the exiled French king Louis XVIII was staying, and who saw a messenger deliver word of the victory to the king the morning after the battle. The agent then hurried to London by way of Ostend, and Rothschild traded profitably before telling the government what he knew.[1]

Cathcart found that this story has some basis in fact, but not the basis Wellington gave it. Newspapers of the week after the battle reported that a “Mr C of Dover” had been in Ghent when the news reached Louis XVIII on Monday 19 June, and had hurried to London, arriving some time during the night of Tuesday to Wednesday, perhaps twenty-four hours before the official dispatch. On the evidence of the contemporary record, Mr C was the first person in London to know that the French had been beaten. But nothing in that record connects him with Rothschild. Only Wellington’s table talk makes the link, and Wellington was not in London at the time; his evidence is hearsay, and the earliest versions of his story do not mention Rothschild at all. Mr C, moreover, behaved like a man with nothing to hide. By Wednesday morning he was telling his news publicly in the City, and reports of it were in print by noon.[1]

A tradition that identified the man from Ghent as John Roworth, a known Rothschild employee, also fails. A letter in the Rothschild Archive shows that Roworth was in London on the Monday and could not have been in Ghent.[1]

Rothschild did receive early news, but by a different route. On the Wednesday evening the London correspondent of the Caledonian Mercury in Edinburgh wrote that he had good authority for the victory, from “one who has seen a letter from Ghent, received by Rosschild, the great stockbroker whose information is invariably the best”, adding that Rothschild was “now at the Foreign Office”. The details the correspondent gave, about the Prussian army joining Wellington, were not part of Mr C’s account. Nathan, in other words, had his own informant, who sent a letter rather than coming in person, and the letter reached him some time on Wednesday 21 June, probably in the afternoon. He was one of several people in London who had private information about the battle before Wellington’s dispatch arrived.[1]

Did he use it to trade? Probably, and modestly. In late July Roworth, then in Paris, added a postscript to a business letter: “I am informed by Commissary White you have done well by the early information which you had of the victory gained at Waterloo.” To have “done well” in the financial sense, Cathcart argues, Rothschild must have bought on the Wednesday afternoon, before the official news sent prices sharply upwards on Thursday. Such a purchase might have yielded a handsome overnight return. But it was not a killing on the scale of the legend. The original contractors for that month’s government loan had bought at par and could take holdings as large as they chose, and some of them made fortunes that Rothschild, arriving late in the market, could not match.[1]

The trickery is disproved by the prices. The security most sensitive to news from the battlefield was Omnium, the scrip of the government loan. According to the daily stock reports in the Morning Chronicle, it never slumped. On the Wednesday it opened at a premium of 4¾ per cent, rose to about 6 per cent and slipped back to 4¾ at the close. It never fell below its opening price, which was itself the highest it had reached up to that date. There were rumours of defeat that day, as well as reports of victory, and there was profit-taking, but a stock that dips from its peak is not a stock in collapse. Had Rothschild engineered a panic and made a great fortune, Cathcart adds, it would surely have surfaced in his constant correspondence with his brothers. It did not, and it was not mentioned in any newspaper report during his lifetime or in his obituaries.[1]

The legend did not die with the evidence. In 1940 the Nazi propaganda ministry released a feature film, Die Rothschilds, subtitled Aktien auf Waterloo, “shares on Waterloo”, which turned the story into a parable of Jewish financial treachery.[1][3] Cathcart notes that the tale still circulates on neo-Nazi and antisemitic websites. Many people repeat it with no hostile intent, as a story about the value of information. But the Nathan Rothschild of the legend, he writes, is a stock figure, “scheming, cynical, secretive and fanatically greedy”, and fixing that character in the public mind was precisely the aim of the writer who called himself Satan and of the makers of the 1940 film. Given its pedigree and the absence of evidence for it, Cathcart concludes, “it is probably time historians relegated this legend to the margins and the footnotes”.[1]

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Rothschild