War and the wheat trade
The making of the Ephrussi fortune belongs to the middle decades of the nineteenth century, when Odessa became Russia’s leading commercial port and grain was, as a Moscow business writer puts it, roughly what oil and gas are to the Russian economy today.[1] By the eve of the Crimean War, the same writer reckons, the firm’s grain dealings were approaching a million roubles. The war of 1853 to 1856, disastrous for Russia, was a stroke of fortune for the house: prolonged fighting shook up and redrew the grain market, and when it ended Ephrussi had pushed aside a mass of competitors.[1] By the time of the founder’s death in 1864 his turnover was approaching 3.5 million roubles, and he was regarded as the largest grain exporter in the Russian Empire.[1]
Those figures come from a magazine feature rather than from a business history, and they should be read as orders of magnitude. The general direction is confirmed from several sides. Edmund de Waal, the family’s best-known historian, writes that the family had cornered the grain trade and that by the 1860s they were known as the “Kings of Grain”.[2] The historian Ivan Jablonka, reviewing his book, repeats the title and dates it to the same decade.[3] The New York exhibition of 2021 described a family that had risen from the shtetl of Berdichev to become, by the 1860s, the world’s largest distributors of grain, in the summary of a Japanese-art scholar who reviewed the show.[4] One American magazine attributes the cornering of the wheat market in the 1840s to Ignace rather than to his father, an attribution not found in the other sources and probably a simplification.[5]
Grain made the family; it also shaped how they saw themselves. When the Ephrussi acquired a coat of arms, it showed, in de Waal’s description, “a proud little sailing ship on a stormy sea”.[2] The Russian account adds that the ship was three-masted and that the motto beneath it read Quod honestum, “what is honourable”.[6] The device looked back to Odessa harbour and the wheat ships, and forward, perhaps, to a family that expected to keep sailing.
The family’s rise was part of a wider shift in the ownership of the trade. Zipperstein gives the figures. By 1851, of the 5,466 people engaged in trade in Odessa, 2,907, or 53.2 per cent, were Jews, and some 17,000 Jews then lived in the city. After the Crimean War disrupted Black Sea commerce, Jews achieved primacy in the grain export trade; by 1875 more than 60 per cent of the city’s commercial firms were in Jewish hands, and by the early twentieth century Jewish-owned firms controlled 89 per cent of Odessa’s grain exports.[7] The Russian-language Jewish encyclopedia gives a precise version of the last figure: in 1910, 46 of the 55 trading companies exporting grain belonged to Jews, and they handled 89.2 per cent of the exports.[8] The Encyclopaedia Judaica’s history of the community explains how the change happened. In the first half of the century, it says, Jewish participation in the export trade was confined to buying grain in the villages and on the estates and to acting as brokers and sub-agents for the large Greek, Italian and French export houses, although by 1838 Jews were well represented among the officials of the exchange and as classifiers, sorters, weighers and loaders. From the 1860s Jewish firms displaced the foreign houses from their near-monopoly, and by the early 1870s the greater part of the grain exports was in Jewish hands.[9] The encyclopedia attributes the success partly to greater efficiency in organising purchases and speed in dispatching them, and partly to the steady rise in grain prices and fall in profit rates, which drove an enormous increase in the volume passing through the port. Banking followed the same path: in the 1840s most of the city’s bankers and money-changers were Jews, and by the early twentieth century Jews administered 70 per cent of the banks of Odessa.[9] The Ephrussi had been at the head of that change in its early decades. By 1910, when Jewish houses dominated the trade, the family had long since moved its centre of gravity to Vienna and Paris.[6][10]
The Russian account also records Léon’s charity in Odessa. He gave 300 roubles in gold towards an orphanage, 1,000 roubles for the poor under the will of his late wife, and 5,000 roubles towards the monument to Mikhail Vorontsov, the governor-general of New Russia, and he financed a commercial school costing more than 60,000 roubles, which by imperial decision bore the name of the Efrussi Municipal School.[6] None of these sums has been checked against Odessa records here. They describe, in any case, the kind of civic philanthropy expected of a first-guild merchant who wanted the goodwill of the governor and the court.
Sons sent west
The founder had built an exporting house. His sons turned it into an international bank. In Jablonka’s summary of de Waal’s research, the family decided in the 1860s to send its sons out to establish branches in different countries of Europe.[3] In practice the move began earlier. According to the City of Vienna’s historical lexicon, Ignaz, the second son, transferred his fortune to Vienna in 1856 and founded the banking house Ephrussi & Co., with branches in Paris and London, which he ran together with his brother Leon.[11] The lexicon also credits Ignaz with founding a commercial bank in Odessa and taking part in the Bessarabian-Taurian Agrarian Bank, an international discount bank and a Russian commercial bank, the sources of his wealth.[11] The Russian account says that Ignace married Emilie Porges, a merchant’s daughter and granddaughter of a president of the Prague Jewish community, in 1855, and that he served as honorary consul of the kingdom of Sweden and Norway in Odessa.[6]
Léon, the eldest son, stayed longer in Odessa. The Russian account says that after the founder’s death Léon headed the house in Odessa, continued its foreign trade in grain and, by a decree of Alexander II dated 15 July 1866, was given the title of commercial councillor with hereditary honorary citizenship.[6] Under his direction, it continues, the house invested in 1868 in the building of the Kharkov–Kremenchug railway and placed railway companies’ bonds on foreign exchanges; in 1871 he was a co-founder of the Russian Bank for Foreign Trade.[6] The Moscow magazine agrees that profits went into railways in southern Russia, into the oilfields of Baku and into the foundation of several large banks, including the Russian Bank for Foreign Trade.[1] The details of these holdings, and how they were divided between Léon and Ignace, need confirmation from the Russian business archives; the outline, of grain profits recycled into the infrastructure of a modernising empire, is consistent across the accounts.
The New York family tree lists six children of Charles Joachim who reached adulthood: Léon (1826 to 1871), Ignace (1829 to 1899), Michel (1845 to 1914), Maurice (1849 to 1916), Thérèse (1851 to 1911), who married Léon Fould, and Marie (1853 to 1924), who married Guy de Percin.[12] The four sons divided the continent between them. Ignace took Vienna. Léon, his sons and in time his half-brothers Michel and Maurice took Paris, where the house of Ephrussi et Cie was established.[12][6] London followed, and an Efrussi branch remained in Russia, which by 1914 operated from Petrograd.[3]
Leaving Odessa
The founder himself went west. He spent his last years in Vienna, where he died in November 1864. The Vienna lexicon gives the date as 24 November; the Russian account says 12 November, which may be the same day in the Julian calendar then used in Russia, since the two calendars were twelve days apart in the nineteenth century.[11][6] If so, the disagreement is one of reckoning rather than fact, though neither source says which calendar it uses.
Léon left Odessa for Paris at the end of the 1860s or in 1871, and died there in 1871; the Russian account gives his death as 1870, at the age of forty-five.[12][13][6] The Dictionary of Art Historians, whose entry on his son Charles is the most careful published account of that branch, says that the family moved to Paris in 1871 and that Léon’s eldest son, Jules, took charge of the business there.[13] Michel, according to the Russian account, remained for a time head of the Odessa house, a Russian subject and honorary citizen of the city, before he too left, alarmed by the Odessa pogroms of the early 1880s.[6]
The pogroms are a constant presence in the background of the family’s Odessa decades. The Encyclopaedia Judaica counts anti-Jewish outbreaks in Odessa on five occasions, in 1821, 1859, 1871, 1881 and 1905, as well as many attempted attacks, and notes that the monopolists of the grain export, especially the Greeks in 1821, 1859 and 1871, took part in an attempt to strike at their Jewish rivals.[9] The grain trade that made the Ephrussi rich was, in other words, one of the forces behind the violence. The Ephrussi were too rich to be ordinary victims, but they were Jews in a city that periodically turned on its Jews, and the decision to put their capital and their children in Vienna and Paris can be read in that light. It can equally be read as ordinary commercial logic: the money markets that financed grain, railways and governments were in the West.
The Odessa the family was leaving had become, in its own way, as remarkable as Vienna. Zipperstein writes that by the 1860s it was agreed that there was no more influential centre of Jewish life in the empire. It was among the first communities in Russia where synagogue reform was a matter of consensus rather than debate, and by 1867 it had the largest branch outside St Petersburg of the Society for the Promotion of Culture among the Jews of Russia.[7] In the 1860s it became the empire’s centre of Jewish periodical publishing, with Razsvet, Sion and Den’ in Russian and Ha-Melits and Kol mevaser in Hebrew and Yiddish, and the club Beseda, founded in 1863, was widely seen as a model of middle-class Jewish sociability and discussion.[7] It was also a singularly musical city. Jews were attending its theatre in large numbers by the 1830s and 1840s, and the theatre and later the opera house were perhaps its most revered institutions.[7] By 1897 its 139,984 Jews made up 34.6 per cent of the population, the second largest Jewish community in the empire after Warsaw.[7] The Ephrussi had helped to build the commercial base of that world. The sources consulted here do not connect them with its literary and communal life, and no such connection is claimed.
In 1882, according to both a Russian account and an American magazine summary of the New York exhibition, the brothers decided to wind up their Russian enterprise altogether, sell their property and move the business to Vienna.[6][10] An Efrussi bank still existed in Petrograd in 1914, so “altogether” should probably be taken to mean the family’s personal stake in Odessa rather than every Russian interest.[3] Isaac Babel’s line about the tombs at the cemetery gate is the right epitaph for this chapter of the family’s history. The grandfather lay in Odessa’s memory, wrote the Moscow magazine, while his grandchildren and great-grandchildren appeared in Renoir’s paintings and married into the Rothschilds.[1] To understand how that happened, the story has to follow Ignace to the Ringstrasse.
References
OpenClose
- Alexei Volynets, “Bankirskii dom Efrussi: ot torgovli zernom do poloten Renuara” (The Ephrussi banking house, from the grain trade to Renoir’s canvases), Profil *
- Edmund de Waal, “God of small things,” The Guardian, 29 May 2010 *
- Ivan Jablonka, “The Ephrussi Treasure,” Books & Ideas (La Vie des idées) *
- Evgeny Steiner, “The Ephrussi Netsuke: Roots and Remnants,” Impressions 43, part 2 (2022), 109–116 *
- “Family Saga,” The Magazine Antiques, 19 November 2021 *
- “Saga ob Efrussi” (The Ephrussi saga), Kontinent, 19 November 2023 *
- Steven J. Zipperstein, “Odessa,” YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe *
- Электронная еврейская энциклопедия ОРТ (Electronic Jewish Encyclopedia), “Одесса” (Odessa) *
- Encyclopaedia Judaica, “Odesa,” via Jewish Virtual Library *
- Frances Brent, “How a Collection of Japanese Netsuke Sheds Light on a Jewish Family’s Tumultuous History,” Moment, 11 April 2022 *
- Wien Geschichte Wiki (City of Vienna), “Ignaz Ephrussi” *
- The Jewish Museum, New York, “The Hare with Amber Eyes,” exhibition wall texts and Ephrussi family tree (2021) *
- Monique Daniels, “Ephrussi, Charles,” Dictionary of Art Historians *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Ephrussi index page.