A collector of the new painting
In the late 1870s Charles Ephrussi began to buy the paintings that the official art world of Paris still treated as unfinished sketches. He reviewed the Impressionist exhibitions and, according to the Dictionary of Art Historians, eventually acquired more than forty works by Berthe Morisot, Mary Cassatt, Edgar Degas, Édouard Manet, Claude Monet, Alfred Sisley, Camille Pissarro and Pierre-Auguste Renoir.[1] Ivan Jablonka, summarising de Waal’s research, puts the number at more than sixty.[2] The discrepancy probably reflects different ways of counting drawings, pastels and works bought and sold again, and no published inventory has been found that would settle it. The New York exhibition called him the friend and supporter of Manet, Degas, Renoir and Monet, reviewing their shows and buying their paintings.[3]
His critical writing is generous and alert. De Givry notes that the warmest praise in his reviews went to Degas, Morisot, Pissarro and later Cassatt, though never without reservations.[4] Of Morisot he wrote that “she loves painting that is joyous and lively, grinds flower petals onto her palette in order to scatter them on her canvas with light and witty touches”, a line the New York curators chose to put on the gallery wall.[3] Among the works he owned was Morisot’s Young Woman in a Ball Gown, which hung in the exhibition beside a very different picture, Gustave Moreau’s jewelled symbolist Jason and Medea.[5] A later magazine essay observed that Charles had owned Moreau’s Jason since 1865, a sign of how broad his taste was.[6] The date sits awkwardly with the rest of the record, which places the start of his collecting in the 1870s, and it is noted here as given.

The collection was not confined to modern painting. The New York curators described him as collecting passionately and on a grand scale: Impressionist and Renaissance paintings, tapestries, Meissen porcelain and Rococo furniture.[3] The mixture was typical of the rich Parisian collectors of his generation, and it matters for the story of Renoir, whose relationship with Charles and his circle turned in part on what they liked to hang on their walls.
Melanson, in a second study of the family’s patronage, gives part of the credit for Charles’s conversion to his sister-in-law. Fanny Ephrussi, born in Austria, married into the Paris family in 1876 and quickly established a salon especially welcoming to artists, writers and collectors; her letters to the collector Charles Deudon show, Melanson argues, that she was the first of the Ephrussi to appreciate Impressionism, and that she introduced it to Charles in the late 1870s.[7] The change surprised his friends. Charles was by then an accomplished Dürer scholar, and Manet had once told their mutual friend Théodore Duret to “leave the children to their mother and Ephrussi to Bonnat”, the fashionable academic portraitist.[7] Encouraged by Fanny, Charles began to collect the new painting and published some of the earliest favourable reviews of it in the Gazette in 1878, 1880 and 1881.[7]
The family network carried the pictures abroad. In 1882 Charles sent his Berlin cousins Carl and Félicie Bernstein twelve Impressionist paintings, which they hung in their home for artists, curators and critics to see; a year later, with the support of Charles and the dealer Paul Durand-Ruel, they staged the first Impressionist exhibition in Germany at the Gurlitt gallery in Berlin. Melanson notes that the exhibition and the Bernsteins’ salon have been credited with inspiring German Impressionists such as Max Liebermann and the Berlin Secession of 1898.[7] The same circle shared a neighbourhood. Louise Cahen d’Anvers and the Ephrussi, Melanson writes, frequented the houses of wealthy Jewish families in the newly built Monceau district, among them those of Henri Cernuschi and Moïse de Camondo, both of whom left their collections and houses to the French state as museums, of Asian and of eighteenth-century art respectively; Moïse’s cousin Isaac de Camondo, another close friend and collaborator of the family, left sixty-four important Impressionist paintings to the Louvre.[7] Often, she adds, works were not sold but passed from one relation or friend to another, so that the names of the Ephrussi and their circle appeared together again and again in exhibition catalogues and the press.[7]
Manet’s asparagus
One episode from these years has become famous. Manet sold Charles a still life, A Bunch of Asparagus, for eight hundred francs. Charles sent him a thousand. Manet then painted a single stalk of asparagus on a small canvas and sent it to him with a note: “Il en manquait une à votre botte”, “there was one missing from your bunch”.[8][3] The little painting of 1880, L’Asperge, is now in the Musée d’Orsay in Paris, whose record traces it to Charles’s collection; it came to the museum in 1959 as a gift of the dealer Sam Salz.[8] The New York wall text tells the same story more briefly: Charles asked Manet to paint a bunch of asparagus, overpaid him, and received in return a little canvas with one further spear.[3]
The anecdote is often told as an example of Manet’s wit. It also shows something about Charles. He paid more than he had been asked, which was the gesture of a rich man; he received the extra stalk with delight, which was the response of a friend. A magazine essay on the exhibition remarked that Manet, the older man, saw Charles, the Dürer scholar, as an intellectual equal.[6]
Renoir and the circle of patrons
Charles’s most important artistic friendship in these years was with Renoir, and it is the best documented. Elizabeth Melanson, in a study of Renoir’s Jewish patrons, shows that Renoir introduced himself to Charles in late 1878 with an invitation to preview Madame Charpentier and her Children before it went to the Salon of 1879.[9] In 1879 Charles bought from him the painting Renoir called “the little girl from Berneval”, known as Gypsy Girl.[9] In July 1880 Renoir painted the first of a series of portraits of Charles’s family and friends, Madame Léon Fould, born Thérèse Ephrussi, whom Melanson describes as Charles’s aunt; her mother-in-law and a young Ephrussi cousin, Fernand Halphen, sat for him at the same time.[9]
Melanson writes that in the summer of 1880 Charles persuaded his mistress, Louise Cahen d’Anvers, wife of the banker Louis Cahen d’Anvers, to commission a portrait of her eldest daughter, Irène.[9] Louise was pleased, and ordered a double portrait of her younger daughters, Elisabeth and Alice, which was finished in February 1881 and is often called Pink and Blue.[9] The affair between Charles and Louise was, Melanson says, fairly common knowledge; Edmond de Goncourt delighted in spying on a rendezvous between them at the shop of the dealer Philippe Sichel in 1878.[9] By August 1880 Renoir trusted Charles enough to have him organise his submission to the Salon of 1881 while he was in Algeria, and Charles advised him to send the two Cahen d’Anvers portraits.[9]
Renoir put Charles into the most famous picture of those years. In Luncheon of the Boating Party, painted in 1880 and 1881 on the balcony of the Fournaise family’s riverside restaurant, a man in a top hat stands at the back of the group. The Phillips Collection in Washington, which owns the painting, identifies him as Charles Ephrussi, “a banker and editor of Gazette des beaux-arts”, in conversation with Jules Laforgue, “poet, critic, and Ephrussi’s personal secretary”.[10][1] Laforgue had become Charles’s secretary through the novelist Paul Bourget, and in November 1881 he left for Berlin as reader to the Empress Augusta.[11]
The break
The friendship ended badly. The Cahen d’Anvers family were disappointed by the double portrait of their daughters. Melanson writes that when the Salon closed Louise banished it to the maids’ quarters and failed to pay for it for at least a year.[9] Renoir’s last portrait of a patron from the Ephrussi circle was of Albert Cahen d’Anvers in the autumn of 1881. By the winter he was complaining about the conventional tastes of his Jewish patrons, scornfully naming Léon Bonnat and Gustave Moreau, whose work the circle collected.[9]
His letters of 1882 are ugly. To Charles Deudon in February he wrote that the Cahen d’Anvers family was “so stingy; I am washing my hands of the Jews.”[9] In March, with his Salon submission in the hands of Paul Bérard instead of Charles, he wrote of “Ephrussy” that he was “more Jew than bourgeois” and that he had the right eye for the so-called “hairdresser’s” Salon.[9] An American magazine account of the New York exhibition reports that Renoir dismissed Charles’s Moreau as “art for Jews”.[5] Melanson argues that this rupture fed into Renoir’s turn away from Impressionism in the 1880s towards a drier, more classical manner, since he continued to think about the tastes of the patrons he had rejected.[9]
The episode shows Charles at the meeting point of two worlds that did not always like each other: the painters of the avant-garde and the rich Jewish families who bought their work. Melanson’s term for the second world is the salons juifs, a patronage network in which, she argues, women made the connections and the patronage of modern art became a marker of identity.[9] Renoir took their money and their introductions; then, when they disappointed him, he turned on them as Jews. Charles was neither the first nor the last patron to meet that combination. In the 1890s, with the Dreyfus Affair, he would meet it on a much larger scale.
References
OpenClose
- Monique Daniels, “Ephrussi, Charles,” Dictionary of Art Historians *
- Ivan Jablonka, “The Ephrussi Treasure,” Books & Ideas (La Vie des idées) *
- The Jewish Museum, New York, “The Hare with Amber Eyes,” exhibition wall texts and Ephrussi family tree (2021) *
- Hélène de Givry, “Ephrussi, Charles,” Dictionnaire critique des historiens de l’art, Institut national d’histoire de l’art *
- Frances Brent, “How a Collection of Japanese Netsuke Sheds Light on a Jewish Family’s Tumultuous History,” Moment, 11 April 2022 *
- “Family Saga,” The Magazine Antiques, 19 November 2021 *
- Elizabeth Melanson, “Impressionism and the Salons Juifs. The Ephrussi Family and Jewish Patronage Networks in 1880s Paris,” Athanor (Florida State University) *
- Musée d’Orsay, “L’Asperge,” Édouard Manet, 1880, RF 1959 18 *
- Elizabeth Melanson, “The Influence of Jewish Patrons on Renoir’s Stylistic Response to the Crisis of Impressionism,” Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide 12, no. 2 (Autumn 2013) *
- The Phillips Collection, “Luncheon of the Boating Party,” Pierre-Auguste Renoir, 1880–81 *
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Jules Laforgue” *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Ephrussi index page.