Henry Duveen, the younger brother, was by temperament the opposite of Joel. Where Joel was restless and combative, Henry was affable and patient, a man known to everyone in the family and the trade as Uncle Henry.[1] He was the one who went to America, and it was in America that the firm found the buyers who would pay prices no European could match.
The sources differ over when he arrived. The Dictionary of National Biography says that the brothers opened a branch house on Fifth Avenue in 1877; the New Yorker profile of 1928 says that Henry, then twenty-four, came to New York in 1877 and spent a year in Boston before setting up a Delftware shop in Maiden Lane; the archive’s historical note dates the opening of the New York office to 1886.[2][3][4] Vignon, quoted in a review of her study, has Henry sent to New York in 1879 at the age of only twenty-one.[5] The difference between these dates is partly a matter of definition. Henry seems to have been selling in America from the late 1870s, but the house that the firm itself regarded as its New York office dates from the 1880s.
A first class money making country
Henry’s first impressions survive in his letters home. In 1877, Schjeldahl reports, quoting Secrest, he wrote, “I like Amerika very much. It is a first class money making country, it is a fine rich country, it beats England in everything, you will be astonished what it is like, it is A one”.[1] Vignon quotes another early letter in which he told the family, “This is a fine place, and I think we will do good business here”.[5] The spelling of the first letter is a reminder that Henry, like his brother, had grown up speaking Dutch.
His first premises did not impress Joel. The New York Times later described the business as beginning with “a small art shop in John Street”, in what is now the Financial District, where Henry handled antique silver, ivory carvings, rare porcelain, period furniture and oriental rugs.[6] Joel, visiting, recalled, “But what a shock I got when I saw our business premises! They were in a bad neighbourhood, and the place was not much better than a storehouse.” The stock, he complained, was “badly placed and badly lit, and the windows were not good enough for an old clothes shop”.[6] It took time and money to put this right, including a move to Broadway and Nineteenth Street in the fashionable shopping district known as Ladies’ Mile, after which Joel was satisfied that “I had everything in a really good place with ample room to show things and proper lighting”.[6]
The firm moved steadily north with the money. In 1886 Henry moved to 262 Fifth Avenue, between Twenty-Eighth and Twenty-Ninth Streets, following the uptown migration of the smart shops, and in 1889, according to Vignon, he opened a second gallery at 2 West Twenty-Ninth Street in what was then mainly a residential district of the rich.[6] The New Yorker profile gives a simpler sequence, from Maiden Lane to John Street, then to lower Broadway and lower Fifth Avenue.[3]

Benjamin Altman
Henry’s great gift was for friendship with clients. In 1882 he gained the friendship of the department-store owner Benjamin Altman, the Duveens’ first great American client.[1] Brewer, following Secrest, also dates Altman’s first purchases from the firm to 1882.[7] Altman was a shy and private bachelor who had made a fortune from his store on Sixth Avenue and later on Fifth, and over the following thirty years he built one of the finest collections in New York, rich in Chinese porcelain and later in Dutch pictures. When he died in 1913 he left a collection of pictures valued at $20 million.[7]
Altman was the first of a line. Henry went on to win the custom of J. P. Morgan and of Peter A. B. Widener of Philadelphia, and the Dictionary of National Biography lists the Taft, Widener, Gould, Altman and Morgan collections among those the brothers helped to form.[1][2] The firm’s records show how early it was selling not only objects but whole interiors. In 1887 it bought a tester bed of the 1780s by the Paris cabinetmaker Georges Jacob from the Lowengards, a family of Paris dealers, and later sold it to the railway magnate George Jay Gould; the bed is now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.[5]
The quarrel and the reconciliation
The partnership between the brothers was not always easy. Helmreich, Sterrett and van Ginhoven, drawing on Vignon, record that the brothers worked separately for five years or so before 1890 because of a disagreement.[6] The cause of the quarrel is not described in the published sources. What is clear is that it ended in 1890 with a reconciliation and with the formal founding of the firm as Duveen Brothers, and that the New York business then moved to new premises at 302 Fifth Avenue, a brownstone remodelled by the architects McKim, Mead and White.[6] Vignon describes a division of labour that followed: Joel was in charge of purchases in Europe, chiefly in Britain, the Netherlands and France, and Henry was in charge of sales in New York.[5]
The arrangement worked spectacularly well. Brewer, following Secrest, writes that profits from the New York business had reached more than £500,000 by 1895.[7] The London house sent across the Atlantic, every autumn for about six weeks, almost three hundred cases a week.[7] In 1898 a journalist in The Art Amateur, quoted by Vignon, described the New York gallery as “packed from cellar to attic with curiosities, many of which are, singly, worth a fortune”, with one room full of Chippendale furniture and another of tapestries “of all periods, Gothic, later Flemish, after Italian designs, Gobelins and Beauvais”.[5]
The Garland porcelain
The firm’s speciality in New York remained Chinese porcelain, and its most famous achievement in this field was the collection of James A. Garland. The Duveens had built up Garland’s collection for him, and when he died they bought it back as a whole in March 1902 and at once sold it to J. P. Morgan.[2][3] Morgan lent it to the Metropolitan Museum, where it was shown in the museum’s Chinese porcelain gallery as the Garland-Morgan collection.[5] After Morgan’s death in 1913 the Duveens bought the collection a second time, by now much enlarged, for a price said to be $5 million, and sold most of it to Henry Clay Frick.[3]
The story of the Garland porcelain shows a practice that became one of the firm’s trademarks. The Duveens sold the same objects again and again, buying them back from the estates of their clients and finding new owners for them at higher prices.[3] It was a way of keeping prices rising and of making sure that the best things in the market passed through the firm’s hands more than once.
Porcelain also served the firm’s public image. In January 1907 the Duveens held a special loan exhibition of rare Chinese porcelain in aid of various charities at the new annex galleries at 302 Fifth Avenue.[8] Such exhibitions, of objects that the firm had sold and that their owners now lent back, became a regular feature of its life. They flattered the clients, displayed the firm’s achievements and reminded other collectors of what was possible.
Henry’s word on porcelain carried great weight, and it could end a rival’s sale. Jack Duveen tells the story of Edgar Gorer, a bold London dealer in Chinese porcelain who had bought three fine Chinese vases from another dealer for £16,000 before leaving for America. He sold the largest of them, a vase with an imperial yellow ground, to one of America’s wealthiest collectors for £40,000. When doubts were raised about it, Henry was called in to give an opinion and, in Jack’s words, declared it “with great reluctance” to be an imitation.[9] The collector returned the vase, and Gorer came back to England to gather evidence for a lawsuit against Duveen Brothers.
The suit was never heard. According to Jack, Gorer sailed for New York again in the Lusitania and was lost when the liner was torpedoed in May 1915; he gave his own life-belt to a woman on deck and then a second one to a Hungarian girl, who survived.[9] Jack’s account is the only source used here for the quarrel, and he does not name the collector. The episode nevertheless shows how much the American trade in Chinese porcelain depended on the judgement of a few experts, and how much a single opinion from Henry Duveen could be worth to his firm or cost a competitor.
Henry the philatelist
Henry had a private passion that had nothing to do with the firm. He was one of the great stamp collectors of his generation, and the Association of British Philatelic Societies records him among the distinguished philatelists of the period.[10] The interest passed to his son Geoffrey, who became an authority on the stamps of Gibraltar and on the history of the gold sovereign; his story is told in the last chapter.[10][11]
Henry married Dora Falcke, and their son Geoffrey was born in 1883.[12] By the early twentieth century Henry was in poor health, and the younger generation was taking over the running of the New York house. In 1910 he would be the main target of the most serious crisis the firm ever faced, a prosecution for customs fraud that is the subject of Chapter 8. He died, according to the New Yorker profile, in 1919, leaving his nephew Joseph the only member of the family active in America; the archive’s historical note gives his death as 1918.[3][4]
Henry’s place in the Duveen story is easily overshadowed by the brilliance of his nephew. But without him there would have been no American business to inherit. It was Henry who found the first great clients, who learned how rich Americans wanted to be sold to, and who, in Schjeldahl’s phrase, “snared” Morgan and Widener.[1] When Joseph Duveen went to New York as a young man, he went to learn from his uncle.
References
OpenClose
- Peter Schjeldahl, “Masterpieces for Sale”, The New Yorker, 8 November 2004 *
- William Roberts, “Duveen, Sir Joseph Joel”, Dictionary of National Biography, 1912 supplement (London: Smith, Elder, 1912) *
- Alva Johnston, “Noble Merchandise”, The New Yorker, 21 April 1928 *
- Getty Research Institute, Finding aid for the Duveen Brothers records, 1876 to 1981 (accession no. 960015) *
- Wendy Moonan, “The Family That Brought European Luxury to America’s Gilded Age Tycoons”, 1stDibs Introspective, 1 September 2019 *
- Anne Helmreich, Jill Sterrett and Jacqueline van Ginhoven, “Purpose-Built. Duveen and the Commercial Art Gallery”, Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide 20, no. 2 (Summer 2021) *
- John Brewer, “The Art of the Deal”, The New York Review of Books, 7 October 2004 *
- Duveen Brothers, Special Loan Exhibition of Rare Chinese Porcelains in Aid of Various Charities, at the New Annex Galleries, 302 Fifth Avenue (New York, 1907) *
- James Henry Duveen, Secrets of an Art Dealer (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1938) *
- Association of British Philatelic Societies, “Who Was Who in Philately” *
- Geoffrey E. Duveen and H. G. Stride, The History of the Gold Sovereign (London: Oxford University Press, 1962) *
- “Sir Geoffrey Edgar Duveen (1883 to 1975)”, American Aristocracy register *
The family tree, timeline, places, glossary and select bibliography for the whole history are on the Duveen index page.