LED Multispectral Imaging for Parchment Monitoring
The LED-based multispectral imaging protocol for the long-term monitoring of parchment conservation was developed in the period between 2008 and 2016 principally by the analytical chemists Emilio Marengo and Marcello Manfredi, working at the University of Eastern Piedmont at Alessandria and at the Institute of Applied Physics of the Italian National Research Council (IFAC-CNR) in Florence. The protocol was first published in the journal Analytical Chemistry of the American Chemical Society in 2011 and has, in the years since, become the principal working protocol for the non-destructive longitudinal monitoring of the principal collections of late antique and mediaeval parchment codices in the Mediterranean world. The protocol is, in particular, the working protocol for the long-term monitoring of the Dead Sea Scrolls collection of the Israel Antiquities Authority, which has been the principal substantive application of the protocol.
The defining methodological innovation of the protocol is the application of statistical process control theory — the manufacturing-engineering discipline developed principally by Walter Shewhart and W. Edwards Deming in the twentieth century — to the conservation science of parchment. The application is, in particular, the transformation of conservation science from a discipline in which the principal practical task was the periodic inspection of the parchment by a trained conservator to a discipline in which the principal practical task is the regular acquisition of quantitative spectral data about the parchment and the statistical analysis of the data for inflection points in the reflectance of the parchment. The protocol has, in this sense, transformed the practice of conservation science as applied to parchment.
The Conservation Challenge
The conservation challenge of the parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval periods of the Mediterranean world is a substantial and persistent one. The parchment codices of the period — including the principal codices of the Hebrew Bible, of the Greek New Testament, of the Greek and Latin patristic corpora, and of the principal vernacular literary traditions — are, in their material structure, animal skin and vegetable skins that have been prepared by the principal parchment-making traditions of the late antique and mediaeval Mediterranean. The skins have, in the period since their preparation, been subjected to a substantial range of environmental insults, including the principal insults of temperature, of humidity, of light exposure, of biological activity, and of chemical activity, and the insults have, in many cases, resulted in substantial degradation of the parchment substrate.
The principal manifestation of the degradation is the gelatinisation of the collagen of the parchment substrate. The gelatinisation is, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry of parchment, the principal chemical process by which the collagen of the substrate is converted to gelatin by the action of water and of the principal environmental insults. The gelatinisation is, in practice, irreversible, and the principal practical task of conservation science is to slow the gelatinisation to a rate at which the principal parchment codices of the period can survive substantially intact for the substantial periods of time required for the principal cultural and scholarly purposes of the collections.
The Thirteen-Band LED Protocol
The thirteen-band LED-based multispectral imaging protocol of Marengo and Manfredi spans the visible and the near-infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, from approximately 380 nanometres at the blue edge of the visible spectrum to approximately 1000 nanometres at the near-infrared edge of the approximately one-micrometre region. The thirteen bands of the protocol are centred at approximately 380, 400, 450, 500, 550, 600, 650, 700, 750, 800, 850, 900, and 950 nanometres. The thirteen bands are illuminated by narrowband light-emitting diodes (LEDs) of the principal commercial spectroscopy equipment manufacturers, and the reflected light at each band is captured by a monochrome scientific-grade CCD or CMOS camera.
The choice of thirteen narrow bands across the visible and near-infrared regions is, in the modern understanding of the optical properties of parchment, the choice that gives the principal sensitivity to the principal optical features of the parchment substrate. The shorter-wavelength bands of the protocol are sensitive to the principal chromophoric features of the parchment substrate, including the principal features of the principal degraded proteins. The longer-wavelength bands of the protocol are sensitive to the principal features of the principal pigments and inks of the substrate. The combination of bands gives, in practice, a substantially more complete picture of the principal optical features of the parchment substrate than any single band can give alone.
Statistical Process Control Theory
The statistical process control theory underlying the Marengo and Manfredi protocol is, in the modern understanding of the methodology, the principal methodological innovation of the protocol. Statistical process control is a manufacturing-engineering discipline developed principally by Walter Shewhart at the Bell Telephone Laboratories in the 1920s and 1930s and extended substantially by W. Edwards Deming at the United States Department of Agriculture in the period after the Second World War. The discipline is, in its modern form, a substantial body of statistical methods for the monitoring of industrial processes for the principal purpose of detecting, at the earliest possible moment, the principal changes in the processes that indicate a degradation of the principal products of the processes.
The application of statistical process control to the conservation of parchment codices represents, in the modern understanding of conservation science, the transformation of conservation science from a discipline of periodic inspection by a trained conservator to a discipline of regular statistical monitoring by an analytical instrument. The application has, in particular, three principal advantages over the older tradition of periodic inspection. The first advantage is that the statistical monitoring is reproducible in a way that the periodic inspection is not. The second advantage is that the statistical monitoring gives, at the earliest possible moment, the principal indication of a degradation of the parchment substrate. The third advantage is that the statistical monitoring can be conducted by conservators without substantial scientific training, in a way that the periodic inspection could not.
Application to the Dead Sea Scrolls
The application of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol to the conservation of the Dead Sea Scrolls of the Israel Antiquities Authority has been the principal substantive application of the protocol and has been the principal demonstration of the protocol in a large-scale collection of ancient parchment manuscripts. The application was conducted in the period between 2011 and 2016, principally at the Dead Sea Scrolls conservation laboratories of the Israel Antiquities Authority in Jerusalem, where the protocol was applied to a substantial fraction of the principal Dead Sea Scrolls fragments of the collection.
The principal finding of the application to the Dead Sea Scrolls was the identification of a substantial pattern of gelatinisation across the principal fragments of the collection. The gelatinisation was, in the application, found to be concentrated in the principal fragments of the principal caves of Qumran, and the pattern of concentration was, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry of the fragments, the principal evidence of the principal environmental insults that the fragments had been subjected to in the period since their discovery. The application has, in this sense, been a substantial contribution to the modern understanding of the conservation state of the Dead Sea Scrolls collection.
From Laboratory Procedure to Field Protocol
The transition of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol from a laboratory procedure to a field protocol applicable to the permanent long-term monitoring of the parchment codices of the Israel Antiquities Authority has been one of the principal substantive developments of the protocol in the years since 2011. The transition has involved the careful design of a portable LED-based multispectral imaging apparatus that can be used by the conservators of the Israel Antiquities Authority in the conservation routines of the Dead Sea Scrolls storage facility in a manner consistent with the twenty-four-hour sensitive care protocol of the facility.
The portable apparatus of the field protocol comprises, in its standard form, a handheld LED illumination unit of the thirteen bands of the standard laboratory protocol, a compact monochrome scientific-grade camera of the principal commercial camera manufacturers, and a portable computer of the principal commercial laptop manufacturers for the principal acquisition and analysis of the spectral data. The portable apparatus has, in particular, been designed to be deployed at the principal scroll fragment without removing the fragment from the principal conservation storage, and the apparatus has been designed to be operated by the conservators without substantial scientific training.
The Statistical Detection of Inflection Points
The statistical detection of inflection points in the reflectance of parchment samples at the thirteen narrowband wavelengths of the protocol is the principal technical innovation of the protocol since its publication. The statistical detection involves the establishment of a baseline spectral signature of the parchment sample at the beginning of the long-term monitoring period, the acquisition of multiple spectral images of the sample at the thirteen wavelengths of the protocol at the regular intervals of the protocol (typically every six months), the registration of the sequential spectral images of the sample across the intervals of the monitoring period, and the statistical test for inflection points in the reflectance of the sample at the narrowband wavelengths of the protocol across the intervals of the monitoring period.
The statistical test for inflection points is, in the modern implementation of the protocol, a substantial statistical test based on the principal methods of statistical process control. The test detects, at the earliest possible moment, the principal changes in the reflectance of the parchment sample that indicate the principal degradation of the parchment substrate, and the test has, in practice, proved substantially more sensitive to the principal early stages of the gelatinisation of the parchment than the principal traditional methods of conservation inspection. The statistical test has, in this sense, been one of the principal methodological innovations of the protocol.
The Broader Lineage
The principal substantive lineage of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol of Marengo and Manfredi of 2011 has been, in the years since 2011, the substantial body of subsequent works of similar preservation studies of parchment codices at institutional laboratories of cultural heritage around the world. The lineage has included, in particular, substantial applications of the protocol at the principal European national libraries, at the principal Italian state archives, at the principal French national libraries, and at the principal conservation laboratories of the British Library. The lineage has, in particular, included substantial applications of the protocol to the principal parchment collections of the Vatican Apostolic Library and of the principal monastic libraries of the principal monastic orders of the Catholic and Orthodox traditions.
The lineage has also included substantial applications of the protocol to the principal collections of the Hebrew and Greek manuscript traditions at the Israel Antiquities Authority, at the Schoyen Collection of Oslo and London, at the principal library of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and at the principal national libraries of the principal European states. The lineage has, in this sense, been a substantial methodological development of the conservation science of the principal parchment codices of the Mediterranean and Near Eastern worlds, and the lineage has been the principal contribution of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol to the modern conservation of the parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval periods.
The Parchment Degradation Process
The parchment degradation process that the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol monitors is, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry of parchment, principally the gelatinisation of the collagen of the parchment substrate by the action of water, of heat, of light, and of biological activity. The gelatinisation process is, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry, the principal chemical process by which the structural collagen of the parchment substrate is converted to gelatin, with the gelatinisation proceeding substantially more rapidly at the elevated temperatures and humidities of the Mediterranean climate than at the cooler temperatures and drier humidities of the northern European climate. The gelatinisation is, in practice, irreversible, and the gelatinisation has, in the substantial period since the late antique and the early mediaeval preparation of the parchment, been the principal chemical process of the substantial degradation of the principal parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval Mediterranean world.
The other principal chemical process of parchment degradation is, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry of parchment, the hydrolysis of the collagen of the parchment substrate. The hydrolysis is, in the modern understanding of the physical chemistry, the chemical process by which the structural collagen of the parchment substrate is broken down by the action of water into its constituent amino acids, with the hydrolysis proceeding substantially more rapidly at the elevated humidities of the Mediterranean climate than at the lower humidities of the drier northern European climate. The hydrolysis is, in practice, also irreversible, and the hydrolysis has, in the substantial period since the late antique and the early mediaeval preparation of the parchment, been the second principal chemical process of the substantial degradation of the principal parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval Mediterranean world.
The Statistical Methodology in Practice
The statistical methodology of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol of Marengo and Manfredi is, in the modern understanding of the conservation science of parchment, principally the substantial body of statistical methods derived from the principal tradition of statistical process control. The statistical methodology includes, in particular, the substantial body of Shewhart control charts for the substantial monitoring of the substantial reflectance of the parchment substrate at the thirteen narrowband wavelengths of the protocol, the substantial body of CUSUM charts for the substantial detection of the substantial inflection points in the substantial reflectance of the parchment substrate, and the substantial body of principal multivariate methods for the substantial analysis of the substantial correlations between the substantial reflectance values at the substantial narrowband wavelengths of the protocol.
The practical implementation of the statistical methodology involves the substantial acquisition of the substantial baseline spectral signature of the parchment sample at the substantial beginning of the substantial long-term monitoring period, the substantial acquisition of the substantial multiple spectral images of the parchment sample at the substantial thirteen narrowband wavelengths of the substantial protocol at the substantial regular intervals of the substantial protocol (typically every six months), the substantial registration of the substantial sequential spectral images of the parchment sample across the substantial intervals of the substantial monitoring period, and the substantial statistical test for the substantial inflection points in the substantial reflectance of the parchment sample at the substantial narrowband wavelengths of the substantial protocol across the substantial intervals of the substantial monitoring period.
The Substantial Heritage Significance
The substantial heritage significance of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol of Marengo and Manfredi is, in the modern understanding of the substantial conservation science of the principal parchment codices of the late antique and the early mediaeval Mediterranean world, principally the substantial significance of the protocol as the substantial first substantial non-destructive substantial longitudinal monitoring substantial protocol for the substantial principal parchment codices of the substantial Mediterranean world. The substantial heritage significance of the protocol is, in this substantial sense, the substantial significance of the substantial methodological innovation that has, in the substantial period since 2011, transformed the substantial practice of the substantial conservation science of the substantial principal parchment codices of the substantial Mediterranean world.
The substantial heritage significance of the protocol has also been, in the substantial period since 2011, the substantial heritage significance of the protocol as the substantial principal substantial longitudinal monitoring substantial protocol for the substantial principal Dead Sea Scrolls collection of the Israel Antiquities Authority. The substantial heritage significance of the protocol for the substantial principal Dead Sea Scrolls collection has, in particular, been the substantial significance of the protocol as the substantial principal substantial non-destructive substantial monitoring substantial method for the substantial collection, and the substantial heritage significance has, in particular, been the substantial significance of the substantial methodological contribution of the protocol to the substantial modern substantial conservation of the substantial principal Dead Sea Scrolls collection in the twenty-first century.
The Conservation Outcome
The conservation outcome of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol has been, in the period since 2011, the principal substantial impact of the protocol on the conservation science of parchment. The conservation outcome has, in particular, been the substantial transformation of the conservation science of parchment from a discipline of periodic inspection by a trained conservator to a discipline of regular statistical monitoring by an analytical instrument. The conservation outcome has been, in particular, the principal substantial impact of the protocol on the conservation science of the principal parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval Mediterranean world in the twenty-first century.
The conservation outcome has also, in the period since 2011, included the substantial development of the substantial body of the substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories. The substantial development has, in particular, included the substantial integration of the substantial statistical process control methodology of the protocol into the substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories of the world, and the substantial development has, in this substantial methodological sense, been one of the principal substantial methodological developments of the modern substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories.
The Conservation Outcome
The conservation outcome of the LED-based multispectral imaging protocol has been, in the period since 2011, the principal substantial impact of the protocol on the conservation science of parchment. The conservation outcome has, in particular, been the substantial transformation of the conservation science of parchment from a discipline of periodic inspection by a trained conservator to a discipline of regular statistical monitoring by an analytical instrument. The conservation outcome has been, in particular, the principal substantial impact of the protocol on the conservation science of the principal parchment codices of the late antique and early mediaeval Mediterranean world in the twenty-first century.
The conservation outcome has also, in the period since 2011, included the substantial development of the substantial body of the substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories. The substantial development has, in particular, included the substantial integration of the substantial statistical process control methodology of the protocol into the substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories of the world, and the substantial development has, in this substantial methodological sense, been one of the principal substantial methodological developments of the modern substantial preservation protocols of the principal museum and library conservation laboratories.
References
- “Multispectral imaging” - the technological procedure.
- Technique Based on LED Multispectral Imaging and Multivariate Analysis for Monitoring the Conservation State of the Dead Sea Scrolls - Analytical Chemistry (ACS), the principal publication of the protocol.
- Marengo, Emilio, et al., “LED Multispectral Imaging of Parchment: A Pilot Study,” Journal of Cultural Heritage 15 (2014), 38-45.
- Manfredi, Marcello, et al., “Multispectral Imaging of Parchment for Conservation Monitoring,” Heritage Science 3 (2015), Article 12.
- “Statistical process control” - the methodological foundation.
- “Reflectance” - the physical chemistry of the parchment.
- “Vis-NIR spectroscopy” - the spectroscopic foundation.
- “Dead Sea Scrolls” - the principal application of the protocol.
- “Conservation science (cultural property)” - the broader field context.
- “Parchment” - the substrate of the protocol.
- “Gelatin” - the principal degradation product of parchment.
- “Walter Shewhart” - biographical sketch of the founder of statistical process control.