Skip to content

Buying collections whole

At the beginning of the twentieth century the market for Old Master paintings was changing in ways that suited the Duveens perfectly. On one side, the landed families of Europe, and of Britain above all, were selling. Agricultural depression, caused in part by cheap grain from America, had cut their incomes, and death duties made matters worse.[1] On the other side, American industrial fortunes of unprecedented size were looking for things to buy. Brewer lists the American collectors of the period, from Morgan, Altman and the Wideners to Frick, the Huntingtons, Kress and Mellon, as “an inventory of the triumphs of American capitalism” in coal, steel, retailing, banking and transport, and notes that in the decade before 1914 all the highest prices in the art market were paid by Americans.[2]

The rise in prices was spectacular. Brewer, drawing on the price lists compiled by Gerald Reitlinger in The Economics of Taste, notes that almost every kind of work of art and antique rose sharply in price after the 1880s, from Limoges enamels and Italian faience to Chinese porcelain and, above all, French furniture. In 1902 the gold-ground tapestry known as the Mazarin tapestry sold for between £65,000 and £72,000. Between 1870 and 1912 the cost of works by Fragonard rose ten- to twentyfold. Titian’s Man in a Red Cap, sold in 1876 for £94 10s, fetched £50,000 in 1915, and Rembrandt’s Nicholas Ruts, which had cost £375 in 1850, cost £30,000 in 1904.[2] At first the European and English Rothschilds took part in the buying, but in the decade before the war all the top prices were paid by Americans.[2]

Behrman summed up the situation in a line that has been quoted ever since: Duveen “noticed that Europe had plenty of art and America had plenty of money”.[1] Secrest called the line simplistic, pointing out that the Europeans needed money because their own fortunes had collapsed, but she did not dispute that Joseph Duveen exploited the imbalance more boldly than anyone else.[1]

The Kann collections

The most spectacular of the firm’s purchases was the collection of Rodolphe Kann, a Paris banker who, in Brewer’s words, had made a fortune in South African gold and diamonds.[2] Kann’s collection of pictures and works of art was one of the finest in private hands in Europe, rich in Dutch paintings and Rembrandts in particular. After his death it came on the market as a whole.

The sources disagree about when the Duveens bought it and what they paid. The Dictionary of National Biography, citing The Times of 7 August 1907 and The Year’s Art for 1908, says that the firm bought the Rodolphe Kann collection of pictures and objects of art in Paris in 1907 for nearly three quarters of a million pounds.[3] Brewer, following Secrest, dates the purchase to 1905 and gives the price as $4.2 million.[2] The archive’s historical note says that in 1906 Joseph acquired three large collections: those of Rodolphe Kann, of Maurice Kann and of Oscar Hainauer.[4] The differences probably reflect the length of the negotiations, which may have begun in one year and been completed and announced in another, but the published sources do not settle the point.

The Hainauer collection

The second great purchase was the collection of Renaissance objects formed by Oscar Hainauer, who was, in Brewer’s description, the Berlin representative of the Paris Rothschilds.[2] The Dictionary of National Biography says that the Duveens bought the whole of it in June 1906 for about £250,000; Brewer dates the purchase two years after the Kann collection and gives the price as $1 million, adding that within a couple of years the firm had made a profit of $4 million on the Hainauer collection alone.[3][2]

The Hainauer collection was rich in Italian Renaissance sculpture, bronzes, majolica and decorative objects, the kind of goods that American collectors were beginning to want for the Renaissance-style rooms of their new houses. It complemented the Kann pictures, and together the two purchases gave the firm a stock no rival could match.

Selling the spoils

The firm sold the best works from both collections to its American clients. Brewer names J. P. Morgan, Benjamin Altman, who bought four Rembrandts, Arabella Huntington and Peter A. B. Widener.[2] Some objects took years to place. In 1916 the firm sold Joseph E. Widener a pair of stained-glass panels of the Angel of the Annunciation and the Virgin Annunciate by the Florentine Giovanni di Domenico, which had once been in the church of Santa Maria Maddalena dei Pazzi in Florence and which the Duveens had bought from the heirs of Rodolphe Kann; they are now in the National Gallery of Art in Washington.[5] Schjeldahl, following Secrest, notes that at the end of his life Joseph was still selling paintings and decorative objects from his first wholesale purchases.[1]

Brewer explains why buying a collection whole was so attractive. When a dealer buys a single object at auction, its price is public; but when he buys a collection, the value of each piece is whatever he says it is, and how much he reckons he paid for any one item remains a trade secret.[2] The purchases also, in Brewer’s account, pushed Joseph into the first rank of Old Master dealers and enabled him to use the rivalry between Frick, Altman and the Huntingtons to push up prices.[2] He set out, Brewer writes, to monopolise the rich collectors, to play them off against one another and to resell the works they bought.[2]

Ink-and-watercolour illustration of a panelled room hung with paintings. A balding man in a waistcoat writes in a large ledger at a marble table while assistants carry in draped objects, and women and children of different ages look on from the doorway.
Clerks list the contents of a Paris collection as it is packed for shipment in the years before the First World War.

Credit

None of this could have been done without money, and the firm’s financial power has attracted less attention than its salesmanship. Brewer points out that no other dealer had an arrangement with a bank guaranteeing overdrafts of up to $6 million, and that no one had better access to the House of Morgan and its funds.[2] Duveen acted, in effect, as a financial intermediary between the banks and his clients, offering them long-term credit so that they could meet his high prices.[2] He was frank about it. “We have no other course but to make dates of payment for periods with our clients,” he wrote, “and then keep milking them, otherwise the game cannot be carried out”.[2]

The forms of payment were varied and complicated, from instalment plans to bonds, shares and land.[2] The New Yorker profile of 1928 noted that it was a matter of court record that Henry Clay Frick owed the firm $2,190,000 when he died, and that the firm had carried its clients “on the cuff for millions”.[6] Schjeldahl describes Joseph’s financial dealings as “works of art in themselves”, and gives as an example his practice of borrowing money from Andrew Mellon to buy paintings that he then sold to Mellon at a large mark-up.[1]

Prices that only went up

Joseph’s guiding principle was that prices must rise. Brewer writes that he was determined to ensure a bull market and keep prices rising, and that the years before the First World War were a golden age for dealers, when prices reached a level that did not return until the 1980s.[2] He despised bargains. He reminded collectors, Schjeldahl says, that it was easy to find paintings that cost $50,000 each, but that finding one for a quarter of a million took doing; and Behrman tells a story of reverse haggling in which Duveen insisted on paying an English lady more for a family portrait than she had asked.[1]

He disliked buying at auction, because it made public what he had paid, but he made exceptions when he wanted to pay a sum so large that it would set a new benchmark for the market.[1] By 1928 the New Yorker could report that he had set the high marks at public auction on both sides of the Atlantic: $377,000 for Lawrence’s Pinkie in England and $270,000 for Rembrandt’s Titus in America, the English price being given, as the magazine gave it, in dollars.[6]

The Aristotle

No single picture better illustrates the firm’s methods than Rembrandt’s Aristotle with a Bust of Homer, now in the Metropolitan Museum. Duveen sold it no fewer than three times. He sold it first to Arabella Huntington in 1907; later to Alfred W. Erickson, a founder of the advertising agency McCann-Erickson, for $750,000; took it back for $500,000 when Erickson needed money after the crash of 1929; and sold it to Erickson again in 1936, when he had recovered his fortune.[2] Schjeldahl calls it “unassailable”, one of the few Rembrandts among the two dozen or more that passed through Duveen’s hands whose authenticity has never been in doubt.[1]

Has America got it all

The scale of American buying alarmed Europe. “Has America at last got it all?” asked The Year’s Art in 1910.[2] France, Italy and Greece passed laws to protect their artistic heritage, and in Britain, where free trade was an article of faith, prominent figures founded the National Art Collections Fund, a private charity, to raise money to compete with foreign buyers.[2] The one great price of the period not paid by an American was the world record of £310,000 paid by the Tsar of Russia for Leonardo’s Benois Madonna, to prevent its acquisition at the same price by Duveen for Henry Clay Frick.[2]

The Duveens were at the centre of this transfer of art from Europe to America, and the hostility it aroused would follow Joseph for the rest of his life. But it also gave him an incentive to make himself useful to the countries whose treasures he was exporting. His father had already begun that work in London, and its most visible result was a new wing for the Tate Gallery.

References

OpenClose
← Contents of Duveen