PRINTED MASORAH • VENICE 1524–25 • BOMBERG
The Masorah had been written around the biblical text for centuries before it was printed. The first edition to collect it, correct it and arrange it as a system was the second Rabbinic Bible of Daniel Bomberg, edited at Venice in 1524–25 by Jacob ben Hayyim ibn Adonijah. This note follows Aron Dotan’s account of that work. The journal essay tells the story of the edition at greater length.
Jacob ben Hayyim ibn Adonijah of Tunis
Daniel Bomberg, Venice, 1524–25
Miqra’ot Gedolot, the second Rabbinic Bible
S. Frensdorff, Die Massora Magna, Hanover and Leipzig, 1876

Dotan stresses that moving long lists to the end of a book was already a habit of the early copyists; what was new was the alphabetical arrangement.
A Masorah Collected for the Press
Dotan describes Jacob ben Hayyim ibn Adonijah of Tunis as a proofreader in Daniel Bomberg’s printing house at Venice at the beginning of the sixteenth century. He collected a large number of biblical manuscripts and from them edited “a new clear version of the Masorah.” He corrected errors in it and adapted it to the text of the Bible that seemed to him the most correct. In addition he arranged most of the notes of the Masorah magna in the alphabetical order of the words to which they are directed, and printed them as a lexical list at the end of the Bible.[1]
That Masorah was printed with the second edition of the Rabbinic Bible, the Miqra’ot Gedolot of 1524–25. It was later issued in a scholarly edition by S. Frensdorff as Die Massora Magna, at Hanover and Leipzig in 1876.[1] The first Rabbinic Bible, edited by Felix Pratensis in 1517, had not done this work.

Cross References and an Alphabetical List
Besides the correction of errors, Dotan writes, Jacob ben Hayyim’s innovation was to introduce cross references for parallel comments and to add the systematic list at the end. This was “the first attempt to arrange all the masoretical notes alphabetically.”[2]
In that arrangement every alphabetical unit is called a maʿarekhet, and the whole came to be called Masorah maʿarakhit. Ben Hayyim himself used one set of names for the collection at the end and another for the notes in the margins, including the term “middle Masorah.” Dotan, citing the introduction as edited by Ginsburg, treats this terminological differentiation, like the systematic arrangement, as unique to him.[3]
What Was Old and What Was New
He was not, however, the first to move part of the Masorah magna to the end of the text. Early copyists had already done so when the lists were too long for the page. In the manuscripts, Dotan says, there was no essential difference between the lists on the page and those at the back of the book; the longer and more comprehensive lists were simply recorded at the end.[3] The closing lists themselves are described on the page on the Masorah finalis.
What later generations received as “the Masorah,” especially in printed Bibles, is often Ben Hayyim’s rearrangement rather than the notes of any one manuscript. Dotan therefore insists on a distinction between the Masorah of the ancient manuscripts and the “codified orderly Masorah” of Ben Hayyim.[4] Christian D. Ginsburg published an English edition of Ben Hayyim’s introduction in 1867, and returned to the 1524–25 Bible throughout his own Introduction of 1897.
Selected Bibliography
This note follows Aron Dotan’s Encyclopaedia Judaica article, section 3.3.6. Dates of birth and death are given only as Dotan gives them, approximately. The journal essay is not repeated.